1. Introduction: dispute risks in mining projects
Mining projects sit at the intersection of complex construction, volatile geopolitics, environmental scrutiny and long-term capital deployment. The construction phase in particular is increasingly prone to disputes shaped by geopolitical developments, regulatory change, and socio‑environmental pressures. In regions like Saudi Arabia (KSA) and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) – both pursuing ambitious mining and minerals projects under Vision 2030 and similar national agendas – disputes frequently engage state interests and public policy. Across Africa, a surge in resource nationalism and growing environmental, social and governance (ESG) concerns is also redefining the dispute landscape.
This article examines both the most common and emerging categories of disputes affecting mining projects, including expropriation, environmental and ESG‑driven claims, labour‑related issues, and supply‑chain disruption. These risks are of critical importance to employers and contractors in the mining sector. Understanding them at the outset enables parties to anticipate and allocate risk effectively within the contractual framework and to provide for robust mechanisms to manage and resolve disputes as they arise.
2. Summary of key dispute risks
- Resource nationalism (through licence revocations, fiscal increases, local‑content mandates, and other regulatory shifts) is a growing commercial risk for mining projects. Abrupt policy changes often clash with investor expectations and lead to expropriation or unfair treatment claims.
- Environmental and ESG disputes are increasing as governments tighten standards on pollution control, tailings management, and water usage, often mid‑project. When combined with accelerated development timelines, these requirements can trigger regulatory enforcement, project delays, and disputes involving regulators, owners, contractors, lenders, and local stakeholders.
- Labour, safety, and human‑rights issues continue to generate material dispute risk during the construction phase. Incidents arising from unsafe working conditions, regulatory breaches, workforce localisation pressures, and migrant‑labour sensitivities can lead to work stoppages, claims exposure, reputational damage, and increased scrutiny from regulators and financiers.
- Global supply‑chain shocks (including the pandemic, geopolitical conflicts, sanctions, energy shortages and ESG‑driven scope changes) now frequently frequently give rise to force‑majeure, variation, and delay claims, as contractors and owners seek to manage commercial exposure arising from events beyond their immediate control.
3. Resource nationalism, expropriation and political risk
Resource nationalism – states asserting greater control over natural resources, mining activities and related revenues – has become a major driver of disputes. It can take form through a variety of state actions, such as:
- Seizure of mining facilities, equipment and resources belonging to foreign investors;
- Revocation of mining licences;
- Increases in mining taxes and royalties; and
- Any other legislative reforms directly or indirectly affecting existing investments.
While often justified as serving the public interest, such measures often clash with investor expectations and trigger expropriation or unfair-treatment claims. This tension has led to a sharp rise in arbitration claims.
Impact on contractors
Contractors may face sudden local-content requirements, pressure to replace foreign sub-contractors with state-approved entities or even seizure of on-site equipment. In some jurisdictions, governments have suspended or renegotiated mine development agreements, forcing contractors to halt work and later seek compensation.
Impact on project owners
State intervention can derail construction schedules or even strip away project ownership. Although stabilisation clauses are intended to shield investors from the impact of future regulatory change, disputes arise where new legislation is applied despite such protections.
The application of new legislation to beneficiaries of a stabilisation clause, or the revocation of an investor’s mining licence on the basis of failure to comply with new legislation, may constitute a violation of the investment contract and lead to the initiation of arbitral proceedings by the investor.
Regional trends
KSA’s Vision 2030 envisions mining as a “key pillar” of the economy - but insists on in-kingdom value addition and local industrialisation. Its focus to expand domestic refining and mineral processing may conflict with exporting countries seeking to retain value‑addition at home, increasing the risk of cross‑border supply frictions.
The UAE’s push to become a critical minerals trading and processing hub presents lower expropriation risk, but strong state involvement still shapes downstream investments. Foreign operators of refining facilities are subject to local partnership rules and compliance with Emirati processing commitments.
Across Africa, over 31 states have reformed their mining laws since 2014 to increase state participation, mandate local processing of minerals, raise royalties, and tighten environmental and corporate social responsibility (CSR) obligations.
4. Environmental and sustainability-driven disputes
As global and local standards tighten, environmental disputes in mining construction are increasing – arising not only during operations but increasingly during the construction phase. These disputes typically centre on mine waste (tailings) management failures, pollution liability, water resource impacts, and compliance with climate or biodiversity-related obligations, and may involve regulators, project owners, contractors or affected communities.
Middle East focus
Although the Middle East has historically seen fewer mining-related environmental disputes, this is shifting as KSA expands its mining sector (gold, phosphate, and new critical minerals). As projects advance, issues may emerge around the following:
- Sustainable practices and pollution control: KSA’s mining investment law and regulations (the Mining Investment Law, issued under Royal Decree No. (M/140), dated (19/10/1441 AH), which came into effect on 1 January 2021) align with the country’s broader ESG commitments. We can anticipate possible disputes if, say, a mining project’s construction causes unanticipated groundwater depletion or dust pollution affecting nearby communities. Water is a precious resource in KSA; a mine’s excessive water use or contamination could trigger regulatory intervention or community complaints.
- ESG obligations and climate-related pressures: Lenders and investors often impose ESG requirements on mining construction projects (for example, commitments to reduce carbon emissions during construction, protect biodiversity, or uphold indigenous rights). If these are breached, it can lead not only to reputational harm but also contractual disputes or financing drawdown suspensions.
- Conflict mineral issues: The UAE has adopted Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) due diligence standards for conflict minerals (minerals whose handling directly or indirectly finances armed conflict, contributes to human rights abuses, or supports illicit armed groups). If a foreign supplier of raw ore fails to meet these standards, downstream contracts might be cancelled, leading to supply disputes that are rooted in ESG non-compliance.
Comparative note – African jurisdictions
By comparison, various African jurisdictions – where large‑scale mining is more mature – have seen a broader range of environmental disputes, particularly regarding water contamination, land degradation, and tailings‑facility failures. While the regulatory drivers differ, the underlying themes (community impacts, environmental accountability, and ESG‑linked disputes) are increasingly relevant to Middle East regulators and operators as the region’s mining sector scales up.
5. Workforce, labour and human rights disputes
Mining construction typically involves large workforces and a complex mix of local and expatriate labour, giving rise to disputes over:
- unsafe conditions,
- compliance with local employment regimes
- worker mistreatment,
- industrial action or site shutdowns, or
- social conflicts between local communities and migrant workers.
Middle East focus
Both the KSA and UAE have continued to introduce labour-market reforms in recent years, particularly in relation to migrant workers, although international organisations and NGOs still monitor developments closely. While the previous “kafala” system (tying workers to employers) no longer operates in the KSA, certain structural features remain – such as the absence of trade unions and minimum wage protections for foreign workers – which can limit formal avenues for labour claims. As a result, labour-related issues may instead emerge indirectly, for example through project delays, stakeholder engagement, or external reporting.
As the KSA accelerates large‑scale construction for Vision 2030, some external publications have noted challenges typically associated with rapid project expansion, including long working hours, heat-related pressures, and payment-related disputes affecting sections of the workforce. These circumstances can occasionally lead to informal work stoppages or requests for government mediation. Similar themes, such as contractor financial stress and wage-payment delays, are periodically referenced in reporting on the wider Guld construction sector.
Comparative note – African jurisdictions
By comparison, several African mining jurisdictions experience more frequent labour‑driven disputes, including strikes, union‑led action, local‑hiring grievances and community–migrant worker tensions. While the regulatory context differs substantially, the underlying themes of workforce welfare, local‑content expectations and contractor‑management challenges provide useful parallels as Middle Eastern mining and mega‑projects continue to scale.
6. Supply chain disruption and delay claims
Mining projects – often located in remote areas and reliant on heavy machinery, specialised components (like crushers and mills), and large volumes of steel, cement and other materials – have been heavily affected by recent supply chain volatility. A convergence of global shocks, including the COVID-19 pandemic, major geopolitical conflicts, sanctions regimes and clean energy-driven sourcing pressures, has significantly strained the procurement of mine development and triggered a wave of disputes.
Delay and disruption claims
Disputes commonly arise over responsibility for delays and cost spikes when supply routes or material availability are affected. For example, COVID-19 lockdowns led to factory slowdowns, equipment manufacturing backlogs, workforce shortages and shipping delays – triggering contractor claims for time extensions. Similarly, conflicts such as the Russia-Ukraine war, Red Sea Houthi attacks and the Gaza conflict have disrupted supplies of steel, fuel and explosives.
A large Saudi mining project dispute illustrates this risk: an EPC (engineering, procurement and construction) contractor and project owner stakeholders clashed over delays and cost overruns on a USD10 billion plant, with each side blaming the other, resulting in lengthy litigation before settlement.
Cost escalation and force majeure vs foreseeable risk
Fixed‑price, lump‑sum mining construction contracts often leave contractors carrying the risk of cost increases and schedule pressures, while project owners expect delivery regardless of external shocks. Contractors may seek relief under force‑majeure or change‑in‑circumstance clauses, arguing that pandemic‑era shutdowns, sudden sanctions or trade embargoes were unforeseeable; owners may counter that these risks were allocated contractually. For example:
- The Russia-Ukraine conflict saw energy and metal prices soar, prompting EPC contractors to request price adjustments – resisted by owners pointing to fixed-price obligations.
- New ESG and renewable energy requirements can alter project scope mid-project if governments mandate renewable power integration or emission limits, creating variation disputes if not contractually managed.
- Security risks in parts of Africa (such as insurgencies in Mozambique or the Sahel) can halt equipment convoys or close borders. Contractors may invoke force majeure, but disputes arise where owners argue alternative routes or enhanced security could have been used.
Energy shortages and grid instability (e.g. drought‑impacted hydroelectric capacity) can disrupt construction power supply; contractors may claim relief for government‑caused outages, while owners may assert that backup power planning was foreseeable.
7. Conclusion
The modern mining‑construction environment is increasingly shaped by a convergence of structural pressures, including intensifying resource nationalism, expanding environmental and ESG obligations, persistent labour and human‑rights challenges, and acute global supply‑chain volatility.
Together, these factors are materially altering the risk profile of mining projects and driving a rise in complex, high‑value disputes. These disputes commonly manifest as expropriation and unfair‑treatment claims, regulatory enforcement actions, contract variations, delay and disruption claims, workforce‑related conflicts, and increasingly, shareholder disputes. The latter frequently arise where project delays, cost escalation, ESG non-compliance or adverse regulatory action undermine expected returns or trigger alleged breaches of joint-venture arrangements or shareholder commitments – an area of heightened sensitivity in multi-investor mining ventures.
As governments advance policy‑driven agendas and the industry continues to pursue accelerated project delivery, these pressures are likely to intensify. In this environment, successful project execution will increasingly depend on early and informed risk allocation, commercially robust contractual frameworks, and proactive dispute‑avoidance strategies capable of operating effectively within a volatile regulatory, geopolitical, and operational landscape.
A broader discussion of joint-venture dynamics and construction-related disputes in the UAE and wider GCC can be found in our February article, “Living happily ever after: Joint ventures and construction disputes in the UAE and GCC.”
This article was co-authored by Matthew Leech.