This note is for companies in the natural resources, energy, insurance and real estate sectors who engage intermediaries to attract investment or receive other services.[1]
It sets out key legal principles for claims for introducer fees and common pitfalls to be aware of. It addresses practical steps to minimise exposure to such claims, whether in contract or unjust enrichment.
Under English law, an introducer may be entitled to a fee even where (i) they do not have a written contract, (ii) the service provided falls outside the scope of the parties’ agreement, or (iii) the introduction does not directly result in the transaction originally contemplated.
Even where there is a written agreement for the payment of introducer fees, disputes may arise as to the scope of the services provided, whether a particular transaction falls within the agreed mandate, or whether a subsequent transaction is sufficiently connected to the adviser’s involvement to trigger an entitlement to payment. Such issues will be especially acute where the parties’ arrangements are not fully documented or are recorded only informally.
Contract claims: Types of contract and key risks
Key recommendations
-
Contracts can arise without a written agreement. Binding contracts for introduction fees can be formed orally or implied by conduct. Courts have found binding contracts from informal discussions and a "meeting of minds," even without an expressly agreed fee.
- Draft introducer agreements to cover all potential fees and services, with express provisions excluding liability for any introductions or services not covered by the agreement.
- Include express terms stating that the written agreement constitutes the whole agreement and that there will be no oral modification and that there can be no reliance on non-contractual representations.
-
Unjust enrichment provides an alternative route to recovery. Even without a contract, an introducer may claim a fee if the company received a benefit at the introducer's expense and retaining it without payment would be unjust.
- Do not accept an intermediary's services if there is an intention not to pay. If you do not intend to pay, communicate this clearly, promptly, and in writing before the introduction is made.
-
Entitlement under unjust enrichment depends on whether the introduction was the effective cause of the transaction.
- Avoid approving or encouraging even informal approaches by intermediaries unless you are prepared to accept the fee implications of a successful introduction.
- Document when introductions are made (including the relevant introducer) at any given time so that you can demonstrate that any future introduction is not an effective cause.
-
Silence on fees can be treated as acceptance of an obligation to pay. Silence combined with acceptance of services risks being interpreted as an understanding that services were not gratuitous, particularly where the industry norm is payment.
- If services are not required or are to be provided gratuitously, obtain express written acknowledgment of this from the introducer before any services are rendered.
- Maintain a clear, consistent, and contemporaneous documentary trail of all communications with intermediaries concerning the scope of their authority, the investors they are authorised to approach, and the basis on which fees will be paid.
Contract claims: Types of contract and key risks
Express, oral and implied contracts
Contracts for introduction fees can take different forms: express written, express oral, or implied by conduct. A written agreement is preferable as it provides a clear record of the parties’ intentions, but binding contracts can also arise orally or be inferred from conduct.
For a binding contract, all that is required is an offer, acceptance, consideration, and an intention to create legal relations. These components may arise orally or in writing or be implied.
In Energy Venture Partners Ltd v Malabu Oil & Gas Ltd [2013] EWHC 2118 (Comm), a company engaged an intermediary to assist with selling an oil asset. Without a formal written agreement, the court held that a contract could be inferred from conduct, i.e., the intermediary’s provision of services at the company’s request. The focus is on determining the parties’ intention, ascertained objectively.
Similarly, in Premia Marketing Ltd v Regius Mutual Management Ltd [2021] EWHC 2329 (QB), the intermediary, an insurance consulting firm, introduced a client to the defendant without a formal fee agreement. The court found "a sufficient meeting of minds between the parties to constitute a contract”, supported by the introducer’s consistent communication of its fee expectation and the company’s acceptance of the introduction without objection.
Practical safeguards
- Companies should document introducer arrangements in writing.
- Agreements should have a clearly defined scope, expressly address the full range of potential introductions an intermediary might make, and set out the circumstances in which a fee will be paid. Where a company does not wish to engage an intermediary in respect of particular investors, the agreement should exclude fees for introductions not covered and state that the intermediary is not authorised to approach other investors.
- Parties should not act in a way that contradicts the contract.
- For example, companies should not authorise the intermediary to approach additional investors without agreeing a variation to the contract, as doing so may give rise to an unjust enrichment claim notwithstanding the contractual exclusion (as discussed below). The inclusion of “no oral modification” clauses may further mitigate these risks.[2]
- Clauses setting out when payment is due should be drafted with sufficient detail to constitute a "complete statement".
- The contract should also include an entire agreement clause to ensure only the express terms are enforceable, excluding pre-contractual statements and informal discussions.
Unjust enrichment claims
If there is no contract, unjust enrichment provides an alternative basis for an introducer to claim a fee. It allows recovery for services provided where it would be unjust for the company to retain the benefit of the services without payment. The law here is unsettled, with numerous fact-dependent first-instance decisions causing uncertainty.
If a written contract constitutes a “complete statement” of fee entitlement, an unjust enrichment claim is likely to fail.[3] However, where the contract is incomplete or no contract exists, unjust enrichment can provide a route to recovery.
The relationship between contract and unjust enrichment
In Barton v Morris [2023] UKSC 3 (“Barton”), an introducer informally agreed with a property-owning company that he would be paid £1.2 million if he introduced a buyer who purchased the property for £6.5 million. The property was sold to the buyer he introduced, but for £6 million rather than £6.5 million. The Supreme Court (by a 3-2 majority) held that the introducer was not entitled to any fee. The majority held that the express terms of the contract constituted a complete statement of the circumstances in which a fee was payable, and this necessarily excluded any obligation to pay in other circumstances.
Crucially, where a contract governs the parties’ relationship, a claim in unjust enrichment cannot succeed in respect of matters falling within the scope of that contract. Section 15 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 (implying a term to pay a reasonable sum where no consideration is fixed) was held not to apply where the consideration had been determined by the contract.
The test in Benedetti
When determining whether an introducer has a valid unjust enrichment claim, the court will consider the principles in Benedetti v Sawiris [2013] UKSC 50 (“Benedetti”):
- Has the defendant been enriched?
- This asks if the defendant received a benefit, such as a successful introduction leading to an investment. The benefit need not be monetary and may include an asset, opportunity, or access to a third party the defendant would not otherwise have had.
- Was the enrichment at the claimant’s expense?
- The claimant must have been the source of the benefit. In introducer claims, the introducer must show they made the relevant introduction and that it was effective in bringing about the defendant’s gain (discussed further below).
- Was the enrichment unjust?
- The claimant must establish a recognised ground for unjust enrichment, e.g., failure of basis (where a benefit has been conferred on the defendant on the joint understanding that the right to retain that benefit is conditional and where the condition fails, the recipient must return the benefit) and free acceptance (where the defendant voluntarily accepted the benefit knowing it was not gratuitous). The court will examine whether the parties’ conduct gave rise to a reasonable expectation of remuneration.
- Are there any defences available to the defendant?
- Even where the first three limbs are satisfied, the defendant may raise defences to resist the claim. Common defences include estoppel (where the intermediary represented that no payment would be sought) and that the intermediary voluntarily conferred the benefit without expecting payment.
Effective cause
In industries where introducer fees are contingent on success, the relevant question is whether the introducer was the "effective cause" of the investment. The test asks whether the introduction was a real, operative cause of the transaction.[4] Importantly, an introduction can be an effective cause even where the investor was already generally aware of the opportunity or had previously declined to invest.
In DMA Resources Limited v Brazilian Nickel Limited [2026] EWHC 883 (Ch) (“DMA”), an investor was already generally aware of an opportunity to invest in the company (and had previously declined to invest). However, an intermediary made a reintroduction and was found to have presented the opportunity in such a way as to lead to the eventual successful investment. This affirms the importance of the intermediary’s causal role in the transaction.[5]
The "gratuitous services" question
AMP Advisory & Management Partners v Force India Formula One Team Limited [2019] EWHC 2426 (Comm) confirms that where services are not usually provided gratuitously, a valid unjust enrichment claim may arise if the defendant knows the services are not free, the claimant expects remuneration, and the defendant’s conduct encourages this expectation.
In this case, an investor relations firm provided advisory services to a Formula One team in relation to a sponsorship agreement. The team accepted those services but argued it had never agreed to pay. The court found that while there was no contract, the provision of services neither intended nor understood to be gratuitous justified a fee.
This was affirmed in DMA. The introducer raised the issue of fees around the time of the introduction, though the company never substantively discussed fees. The court found it was unconscionable for the company not to pay in all the circumstances: the company had informally authorised the introducer to approach an investor, such services are expected to be paid for in the industry, and the company had internally confirmed that it did not intend to pay without communicating this to the introducer.
This reiterates that companies should be very clear that fees are not going to be paid, obtain the intermediary's acknowledgment, and pending that acknowledgment should not use the intermediary’s services in that context. Silence on the question of payment, combined with acceptance of services risks being interpreted as an understanding that the services were not gratuitous, particularly where the industry norm is payment. The absence of a written agreement does not mean there is no obligation to pay.
Communications with introducers
Fenchurch Advisory Partners LLP v AA Ltd [2023] EWHC 108 (Comm) provides that where a broker or adviser provides services at the defendant’s request and with their knowledge, an unjust enrichment claim may succeed.
This can even be the case where an intermediary or introducer is only informally or verbally authorised to approach a third party. In DMA, the introducer was verbally authorised to undertake “conceptual conversations”, which was found to be sufficient to amount to approval of the intermediary’s conduct and to override contractual limitations on the scope of services. The court held that even limited or informal authorisation can expose a company to fee obligations. Further, it was found that the company had internally decided not to pay the introducer but had not communicated this sufficiently to the introducer.
Conclusion
Clear communication and careful documentation are essential when engaging intermediaries. Companies should ensure written agreements constitute a “complete statement” of an intermediary’s fee entitlement and follow the practical recommendations set out in paragraph 1.2 above throughout the course of dealings with introducers. In light of recent authority, particular care should be taken to: (i) avoid informal or verbal authorisations that may expand the scope of engagement beyond the written contract; (ii) communicate any decision not to pay fees promptly and in writing; and (iii) not assume that prior investor awareness or contact will negate an introducer’s claim to be the effective cause of a transaction.
Please contact us using the details above should you wish to discuss the above issues further.
Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.
[1] The focus of this note is on entitlement to payment for genuinely commissioned services, rather than the propriety of the underlying arrangements and/or anti-bribery and corruption issues.
[2] Rock Advertising Ltd v MWB Business Exchange Centres Ltd [2018] UKSC 24.
[3] Barton v Morris [2023] UKSC 3.
[4] Nightingale v Parsons [1914] 2 KB 621.
[5] Kinled Investments Ltd v Zopa Group Ltd [2022] EWHC 1194.