In Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon OBE & Ors v Associated Newspapers Ltd [2025] EWHC 2930 (KB), the High Court held that documents held by the claimants’ research team were within the claimants’ control for the purposes of disclosure, and this included material created before the research team’s formal engagement by the claimants.

The decision provides useful and robust guidance on how the court will approach “control” under CPR 31.8, that control will be assessed by practical access and serves as a warning that using third-party specialists like researchers or campaigners will not shield documents from disclosure.

Background

The proceedings form part of a group of high-profile claims brought against Associated Newspapers (Associated) alleging unlawful information gathering. A central feature of the litigation has been the involvement of a specialist ’research team’ who had been engaged because of their longstanding experience investigating phone hacking and related misconduct (the Research Team). Although formally retained by the claimants in April 2022, the members of the Research Team had worked closely with the claimants’ lawyers for many years prior to that, including in earlier litigation against other newspaper groups.

The disclosure dispute related to material which would have potential significance for the limitation defences relied upon by Associated. Associated argued that the Research Team was likely to hold documents directly relevant to when certain claimants first knew, or should have known, that they had viable claims. At a previous case management hearing, the court had ordered the claimants to carry out further searches and confirm whether documents held by the Research Team were within their control. Associated maintained that the claimants had failed to properly comply with that order and applied for an unless order requiring full disclosure on pain of strike-out.

The claimants’ position was that only documents generated or obtained by the Research Team after their formal engagement were within the claimants’ control and that documents acquired earlier, whether in the course of journalism, campaigning or work on other litigation, fell outside their disclosure obligations.. The claimants relied heavily on the premise that the Research Team members had worn different ‘hats’ at different times, and that the legal and practical control over the documents depended on the role being performed when they were created.

Associated argued that this ignored the practical reality of the relationship. It submitted that the claimants had long enjoyed access to the Research Team’s material, had relied on this when formulating their claims and defences, and could not now deny control in order to limit disclosure. Associated also pointed to evidence suggesting that sensitive documents had been selectively used, giving rise to a risk of cherry-picking.

Decision

CPR 31.8 adopts a deliberately broad concept of control, extending beyond physical possession to documents over which a party has a right to possession, inspection or copying. The judge emphasised that established authority makes clear that control is not limited to legally enforceable rights of access. Practical control, arising from an arrangement or understanding that documents will be made available, can be sufficient. In assessing control, the court is concerned with the factual reality of access rather than the formal structure of relationships.

The judge rejected the claimants’ reliance on the different ‘hats’ argument. The relevant question was not the capacity in which a document was originally obtained or created, but whether it was now held in circumstances that placed it under the claimants’ practical control. The judge noted that the Research Team members were engaged precisely because of their accumulated material and expertise, that they had worked closely with the claimants’ lawyers since at least 2015, and that they had already carried out voluntary searches and provided documents in advance of the formal engagement.

The court also placed particular emphasis on the evidence which showed that the Research Team had agreed to provide access to their documents for supervised searches and that there was no suggestion of documents being withheld. Although the claimants declined to disclose the engagement agreement on grounds of privilege, the judge inferred from the nature and purpose of the engagement that it was intended to facilitate broad cooperation and effectively unfettered access to material relevant to the litigation. In those circumstances, any attempt to draw a line at the date of formal engagement was artificial.

The judge concluded that documents held by the Research Team, including documents created or obtained prior to April 2022, were within the claimants’ control for the purposes of disclosure. Those documents had to be properly searched and disclosed in accordance with standard disclosure obligations, and the exercise was not to be limited to issues such as limitation. The court made clear that the circumstances in which documents were acquired might become relevant at a later stage in the disclosure process if, for example, the claimants objected to inspection, but it did not affect the issue of control.

While the court was critical of the claimants’ disclosure position, it declined, at this stage, to make an unless order. The judge accepted that the claimants’ approach was based on an erroneous assessment rather than a deliberate defiance of the court’s authority. However, the judgment contains a clear warning. Given the proximity of trial, any further delay or non-compliance with the disclosure ordered was likely to be met with little sympathy and could result in sanctions.

Key takeaways

Parties should not assume that using journalists, campaigners or other third‑party specialists will shield documents from disclosure. The court will focus on practical access and evidence of cooperation, not formal roles or historic job titles. Control under CPR 31.8 extends to situations where documents are available to a party even if not in their legal possession. In complex and long‑running disputes, especially where limitation is in issue, early planning around disclosure is critical. This judgment is a further illustration of the court’s reluctance to allow disclosure obligations to be managed by form rather than substance.

With thanks to Humza Nadeem for his assistance in preparing this post.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post