The First-tier Tribunal’s (FTT) decision in HMRC v Professional Game Match Officials Ltd [2026] UKFTT 654 (TC) (PGMOL) sits within a long line of employment status cases. It stands out for its clear and structured application of the Ready Mixed Concrete (RMC) test, most notably for the clarity it brings to the third limb: the multi-factorial evaluation of the relationship. However, the case does highlight the somewhat subjective nature of this assessment, which means it continues to be difficult to apply in practice, especially as technological advancements drive roles with increasingly diverse characteristics.

The RMC test comprises three elements: (i) mutual agreement to provide personal service, (ii) control by the engager (or putative employer), and (iii) whether the terms of the engagement, taken as a whole, are consistent with a contract of employment rather than self-employment.

The case concerns professional football referees engaged by PGMOL, who typically had other primary careers and accepted individual officiating appointments on a part-time, assignment-by-assignment basis, with no guarantee of ongoing work.

Limb three at the centre of the analysis

What stands out is not novelty, but clarity in the FTT’s approach to the final stage of the RMC test. The case was remitted to the FTT by the Supreme Court following earlier proceedings. At that stage, it had effectively been accepted that personal service was present and that there was a sufficient degree of control whilst the referees performed their duties. The dispute therefore centred on the third limb – whether the relationship, viewed in the round, was consistent with a contract of employment.

The FTT treated that question as a distinct evaluative exercise. Personal service and control were not treated as determinative, but as part of a broader assessment of the relationship. The Tribunal focused on the absence of any overarching obligation, the ad hoc nature of the engagements and the referees’ broader working lives.

That focus matters. There can be a tendency in practice to treat the first two limbs of the RMC test as pointing towards employment unless some factor in the third limb actively counteracts that. However, the FTT’s reasoning is a reminder that limb three is not a formality. It performs an independent function and can point away from employment even where personal service and a degree of control are established.

Control: Regulatory frameworks and the limits of employment control

Control featured heavily, as expected. HMRC relied on performance monitoring, training and detailed expectations placed on referees - features familiar to many employers operating workforces in a regulated environment. However, the FTT drew an important distinction: control derived from a regulatory or professional framework (in this case the rules of the Football Association) is not the same as employer control over how services are performed.

A useful comparison is work carried out in highly regulated environments. Rules and standards may dictate how tasks must be performed, but that does not necessarily amount to employment-type control. What matters is who is directing the work in practice, on a day-to-day basis.

The same analysis was applied in PGMOL. The FTT emphasised that PGMOL was largely administering and enforcing the regulatory framework set by the Football Association, rather than exercising granular control over how referees performed their role in practice. Administering rules is not the same as directing how work is done.

Mutuality and the importance of flexibility

The FTT’s treatment of mutuality of obligation will also be familiar. The absence of any overarching obligation between engagements - no guaranteed work and no obligation to accept it - remained a strong indicator away from employment, even though, in respect of each match for which a referee was engaged, mutuality did exist.

This reflects the approach in recent cases: an assignment-by-assignment model, coupled with genuine flexibility on both sides, is a meaningful factor. While not determinative on its own, it carries weight as part of the overall assessment.

Why this matters in practice

Employment status remains a live and contested area, particularly in the context of IR35 compliance and modern working arrangements. PGMOL does not change the law—but it reinforces key themes:

  • No shortcuts in the RMC test: limb three retains independent significance.
  • Regulation is not control: structure and oversight do not, without more, establish employment-level control.
  • Multi-factorial reality: modern working arrangements often sit between conventional employment categories, requiring careful, fact-sensitive analysis.

A final practical point concerns HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool. While PGMOL demonstrates that even a detailed judicial analysis may require multiple rounds of litigation to reach a conclusion, HMRC maintains that it will stand by a CEST outcome provided accurate information is used to answer the questions and obtain a result. This offers some useful certainty where the tool indicates self-employment. However, where CEST points towards employment in complex or borderline cases, the tool, which is necessarily somewhat simplistic, may not fully reflect the nuanced, multi-factorial analysis required by the case law.

As PGMOL illustrates, there is no bright-line rule: difficult fact patterns do not lend themselves to binary outcomes, and tools such as CEST can struggle to capture the full picture. Applying the RMC test ultimately involves a degree of subjective judgment. Even with helpful judicial guidance, outcomes will not always be easy to predict in practice.

Contact