In a case that benefits those involved in the secondary market for UK debt (and ultimately UK borrowers), the Court of Appeal has confirmed that a long-established Irish secondary debt operation should be entitled to treaty relief in respect of withholding tax on interest, even though it had acquired the debt claim from a person which was not itself entitled to relief. Although the issue pre-dates the introduction of the principal purpose test (PPT) to treaties, the decision may also be of benefit in looking at post-PPT situations. At the same time, the Court made interesting comments both on treaty interpretation and main purpose tests more widely.
The facts in this case are relatively straightforward. A Cayman fund had a right to be paid interest on a debt-claim coming out of the Lehman Brothers administration. Had the fund been paid the interest, there would have been UK withholding tax. It therefore sought to transfer the benefit of the claim via a broker prior to the payment of the interest, which is when the withholding tax obligation would have crystallised. From the fund’s perspective, it was not necessarily the case that a treaty lender was required; it was recognised that any lender which could receive interest gross would be able to offer a competitive price and, as it turned out, the fund did not know who the buyer was, let alone its tax status, when terms were agreed. The buyer, Burlington, was in fact a well-established Irish investment company, which had acquired a large number of Lehman claims. In due course, the interest was paid and Burlington sought a withholding tax refund under the UK/Ireland double tax treaty.
The claim to the refund was challenged by HMRC, on the basis that Article 12(5) of the treaty applied. This denied relief where the main purpose or one of the main purposes of any person concerned with the assignment of the debt claim was to take advantage of the treaty. In concluding that Article 12(5) did not apply and relief was available, the Court made various key observations:
- To “take advantage” of a treaty was not ‘synonymous with obtaining the benefit’ of the treaty, as that would be to defeat the purpose of the treaty (echoing the 2025 decision in VietJet1).
- It is not an abuse of a treaty to acquire a debt-claim in the expectation of obtaining treaty benefits which the treaty expressly provides for.
- The fact that the buyer was prepared to pay more to acquire the right to the interest, because it expected to obtain treaty benefits, was in line with the object and purpose of the treaty. Relief should not be denied on the basis that it only made economic sense for it to acquire the debt because it was entitled to receive interest gross.
- The buyer was not a conduit or similar company; if it had been, it may have been that relief would be denied.
- HMRC and the taxpayer had agreed that, in determining how the main purpose test applied in this situation, regard was had to the UK domestic law case law; this included the recent unallowable purpose cases for loan relationships (such as BlackRock2 and Kwik-Fit3) and transfer of assets abroad (Fisher4). Both judges agreed that this may not have been entirely correct, although they differed in their emphasis here. Falk LJ notably referred to an expectation that provisions such as Article 12(5) should be interpreted consistently internationally.
- While this is probably not part of the ratio of the case, Falk LJ did stress that in looking at how main purpose tests should be applied, one should look at the context of the relevant legislation. In essence, a main purpose test is likely to be interpreted differently in the context of an anti-avoidance regime or provisions (such as the transfer of assets abroad rules). She also expanded on her own comments in BlackRock and Kwik-Fit to confirm that, broadly, simply obtaining the benefit of a particular taxing provision in circumstances where one would generally expect it to apply should not be sufficient to amount, in itself, to having a main purpose of obtaining the benefit of that provision. This is helpful as, given the complexity of tax legislation, taxpayers will often spend significant time on ensuring their tax position is what they expect it to be, only to find that this diligence is itself used as evidence that they were seeking to avoid tax. The requirement that there should be more than this to satisfy a main purpose test is welcome, although it remains to be seen whether that is easy to operate in practice.
Where does this leave us?
- Article 12(5) has of course been amended so that it now contains the PPT wording (which does not therefore contain the “taking advantage” language that the Court relied on here). Another Court may have to come to a view in the future as to whether the same conclusion would be reached on the PPT, which refers to having a purpose of obtaining the benefit of the treaty, which is a slightly different formulation.
- Having said that, in a post-PPT world, one should have regard to the object and purpose of the treaty. Here, the Court’s comments are helpful. The purpose of a treaty is to allocate taxing rights between countries (although it is now explicit in many treaties that fiscal evasion should also be combatted). To deny relief to established operations (which are not conduits – and assuming that the other conditions for relief are satisfied) would be contrary to the purposes of the treaty. That would be self-defeating (to use the Court’s expression).
- Here, it was not disputed that the other conditions were satisfied. In particular, we can expect that HMRC will continue to place emphasis on any requirement that exists for the treaty recipient to be beneficially entitled to the income in question.
- Falk LJ’s comments on main purpose tests continue to be of interest. There is no ‘one-size fits all'.
- Last – but not least, it is of course open to HMRC to seek permission to appeal this decision to the Supreme Court. Given the uncertainty that this case has caused both in the debt markets and more widely, it would be hoped that this does not happen. The judgments are clear – and as noted, Article 12(5) has been amended in the meantime. It is also worth observing that the Supreme Court did not give leave to HMRC to debate the application of the main purpose test in Blackrock. We will wait and see.