Last month the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) announced in a press release that it had opened an enforcement investigation into The Claims Protection Agency Limited (TCPA), a claims management company (CMC) operating within the sector of motor finance claims, following concerns about its advertising and sales tactics (the Investigation Announcement). The Investigation Announcement follows the outcome of the firm’s failed attempt to judicially review the FCA’s decision to make an announcement naming TCPA. We learned of this outcome though the publication of a two-part judgment in the judicial review proceedings between the FCA and TCPA:

  • In October 2025, Part 1 was published on an anonymous basis, without naming TCPA (see TCPA Part 1 Judgment and our Briefing Note on Part 1 Judgement).
  • In January 2026, following time to allow TCPA to seek an appeal, Part 2 was published naming TCPA (see TCPA Part 2 Judgment). At the time of publication, TCPA was the only authorised firm named by the FCA as being under investigation (although 12 enforcement operations were opened between June and December 2025).

In this briefing, we first summarise the key takeaways for firms and then look in a bit more detail at the Investigation Announcement and the Part 2 Judgment.

What are the key takeaways for firms?

  1. Spotlight on CMCs in the motor redress context: This case is another example of the FCA’s current regulatory focus on CMCs within the motor finance sector ahead of the outcome of its consultation on a redress scheme (see our motor finance redress hub). The FCA has been at pains to avoid consumers being ‘missold’ claims and unnecessarily signing up to potentially costly arrangements with CMCs when participating in a free redress scheme might offer a better outcome. Firms operating in this sector should prioritise regulatory compliance and proactive remediation, as they risk public enforcement investigations if their conduct is similar to TCPA's and meets the "exceptional circumstances" test. The FCA and the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA)  recently published a joint warning to firms representing motor finance commission claims and the FCA also wrote to lenders around actions they should take.
  2. Continuation of assertive supervision strategy and overlap with enforcement: The FCA’s assertive supervisory engagement with TCPA in this case, inviting it to apply for voluntary requirements (a VREQ) whilst also making an internal referral to enforcement, highlights the importance of firms addressing supervisory interventions and concerns in a timely and effective manner and devoting adequate internal resource to meet regulatory expectations. Equally, firms should not assume that complying with requests from supervisors will enable them to avoid enforcement as it may be that concurrent enforcement action is being, or soon will be, actively considered (even where this is unbeknownst to the firm). The FCA did not inform TCPA that it was subject to an enforcement investigation until after it had made a VREQ application.
  3. Naming policy in action: A key factor considered by the FCA case team in their assessment of whether to make a naming announcement was that TCPA had engaged in a well-funded and high profile marketing campaign on motor finance claims and that, given its substantial marketing budget and the number of people reached, the potential harm arising from any shortcomings in TCPA’s conduct could be substantial. Firms operating similar wide-reaching marketing campaigns should be particularly mindful of their regulatory obligations, as this may be a factor upon which the FCA relies when deciding whether to name a firm under investigation in the future. The failed judicial review in this case is also a reminder that any firm wanting to challenge an FCA decision to name them in connection with an investigation faces a number of hurdles.

What does the Investigation Announcement say?

TCPA operates by raising awareness of claims, handling new clients and putting them in touch with solicitors. The Investigation Announcement states that the FCA has opened an enforcement investigation into: (i) what TCPA told customers about the amount of redress they might obtain; (ii) whether customers were told they could make a claim for free; and (iii) whether customers were pressurised to sign up. The press release makes it clear that the FCA has not reached any conclusions on whether TCPA has breached any regulatory requirements.

The Investigation Announcement states that the FCA considered that the exceptional circumstances test for naming TCPA had been met on the basis this was “desirable to maintain public confidence in the UK financial system or the market, protect consumers or investors, prevent widespread malpractice, and maintain the smooth operation of the market”. In the FCA’s view, announcing the investigation allows TCPA customers to “consider their options”.

The FCA has concerns about CMCs within the motor finance claims sector as a whole and the Investigation Announcement highlights the FCA’s previous work in this area including: (i) its July 2025 joint statement with the SRA (the Joint Statement); (ii) its July 2025 Dear Firm letter to CMCs (the Dear Firm Letter); and (iii) its October 2025 Consultation Paper (CP25/27) on a proposed motor finance consumer redress scheme.

What did we learn from the Part 2 Judgment about the FCA’s concerns in relation to TCPA?

The Part 2 Judgment expressly states that the Part 1 Judgment already includes everything that could be said openly, including the judge’s conclusions and essential reasons for dismissing the firm’s announcement challenge, and is not repeated. However, the Part 2 Judgment contains some useful further detail regarding the case, including with regards to the background which led to the FCA’s decision to investigate TCPA:

  • July 2025, Dear Firm Letter and Joint Statement: The Dear Firm Letter, which was sent to TCPA as well as other CMC firms, asked TCPA to review its financial promotions to ensure compliance with relevant rules in the FCA Handbook including the Consumer Duty. The Dear Firm Letter stated that the FCA would proactively monitor the market to assess compliance and that, if non-compliant promotions or inadequate mitigations were identified, it would consider appropriate action. The Part 2 Judgment also highlights the Joint Statement in which the FCA and SRA warned law firms and CMCs to make sure that they were compliant with relevant rules in the handling of claims relating to motor finance commissions. The SRA was described as having nine live investigations into 73 law firms.

  • July 2025, TCPA Letter: In addition to the Dear Firm Letter and the Joint Statement, the FCA sent TCPA a bespoke letter (the TCPA Letter). This TCPA Letter:

    • described the recent supervisory work undertaken with TCPA, including a review of 20 customer files and call recordings, TCPA’s website and its advertisements, a discussion with TCPA on 23 July 2025 and a response by TCPA on 28 July to an information request;
    • described concerns about misleading communications relating to refunds, describing content which had advertised “average” potential refunds of £4,000 and references to a possible £4,500 “per vehicle”;
    • highlighted: (i) excessive chasing of customers who had begun onboarding but not continued; (ii) the sufficiency of steps by TCPA to identify and protect vulnerable customers; and (iii) wider concerns, including an example of a routine failure to inform customers of their free to claim alternative;
    • referred to previous warnings and assurances which were described as having been contravened and included a draft set of voluntary requirements for which TCPA was invited to apply pursuant to s55L(5)(a) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA).
  • August 2025, the VREQ: Following receipt of the TCPA Letter, on 11 August 2025, TCPA sent to the FCA the VREQ application which was granted the following day, to remain in effect until such time as the FCA was satisfied it could be lifted. The FCA also published details of the VREQ on the FCA’s register including with regards to ceasing with immediate effect the onboarding of any new customers and the publishing of any new financial promotions.  The judgment noted there was one other VREQ in the sector relating to another CMC. However, at present there is no central list of CMCs which are subject to FCA requirements and identifying relevant firms instead involves searching the FCA register for any requirements on a firm-by-firm basis. Mis Sold PCP Ltd is showing on the FCA register as being subject to a requirement for which it applied in July 2025 that it must not onboard any new customers related to its regulated claims management activities without prior consent of the FCA.

  • August 2025, internal enforcement investigation referral within FCA: Parallel to these developments, on 5 August 2025, the FCA referred TCPA to its enforcement division. By 8 August 2025, internal consideration was being given by the FCA as to whether the test was met for announcing an investigation publicly. None of this was known to TCPA.

  • August 2025, notification of investigation to TCPA: On 12 August 2025, the same day that TCPA’s VREQ application was granted, the FCA notified TCPA that an investigation into its conduct was going ahead (with investigators appointed pursuant to s170(2) of FSMA). The investigation related to potential breaches, including in particular: (i) whether advertisements gave misleading statements as to the potential value of claims; (ii) whether promotions and communications failed adequately to describe the free claim alternatives; (iii) whether there was high-pressure selling and excessive contact; and (iv) whether there were inadequate arrangements to identify and protect vulnerable customers. The judgment notes that TCPA does not accept the FCA’s concerns.

Building on the Part 1 Judgment, the Part 2 Judgment also includes some further detail on the decision to name TCPA. Points of interest here include:

  • The First Memorandum: As part of the decision-making process regarding whether to announce the investigation, the “decision-maker” within the FCA received a 9-page memorandum from three members of the case team (the First Memorandum). The Part 2 Judgment explains that this First Memorandum, which was dated 13 August 2025, reasoned that there was no obvious value to naming TCPA. It recognised the value to consumers which CMCs can bring and identified the difficultly in justifying singling out TCPA, given the sector-wide concerns and the potential prejudice.

The Part 2 Judgment explains that the decision-maker was Therese Chambers, who in response to the First Memorandum asked the case team to revisit the question of publication and listed 11 bullet points which she considered merited consideration and which she said had not featured or had been underplayed in the First Memorandum. This included that naming TCPA would mean being able to warn TCPA’s customers that they may have signed up with TCPA on an overstated basis and that a naming announcement could warn any consumers who had signed up as customers of TCPA, that they may wish to reconsider and withdraw, rather than losing 30% of a much smaller sum of money than they had been led to believe was on the table.

  • The Second Memorandum: On 26 August 2025 the FCA case team submitted a second memorandum to the decision maker (the Second Memorandum). This identified “substantive matters” which it proposed should be included in the announcement. This included that: (i) the investigation related to TCPA’s promotion and handling of motor finance claims, a subject about which the FCA had publicly expressed significant concern – particularly in respect of the forthcoming motor finance redress scheme; (ii) the FCA was concerned that TCPA had in high-profile marking campaigns asserted that motor finance claimants would receive redress of up to (depending on the advertising) £4,000 or £4,500, in circumstances where the FCA estimated that most individuals would probably receive less than £950 in compensation per agreement; and (iii) some of TCPA’s marketing did not include required mandatory information.

    Factors in the case team’s naming assessment included, amongst other things:

    • Maintaining public confidence: In the context of the specified objective of maintaining public confidence in the UK financial system, consumers of TCPA who had already been onboarded may have been influenced in agreeing to use TCPA’s services (and giving up a portion of any compensation they receive) by shortcomings in TCPA’s marketing. In addition, non-compliance with mandatory information requirements meant consumers may not have taken a properly informed decision on whether to proceed with TCPA.
    • Protecting consumers: In the context of the specified objective of protecting consumers, publicising the investigation and explaining the FCA’s concerns in TCPA’s marketing as to the misleading statements it had made in relation to possible levels of redress due to motor finance claimants would help correct the information asymmetry between TCPA and its customers. In doing so, those customers would be able to consider their options on a properly informed basis.
    • Exceptional circumstances: In the context of the exceptional circumstances threshold and relevant factors, the team noted that TCPA had engaged in a well-funded high profile marketing campaign regarding motor finance claims through many different media, including prime-time TV and adverts on public transport and that, given TCPA’s substantial marketing budget and the number of consumers reached or the potential to reach, the harm that had arisen or potential harm that could arise from any shortcomings in the conduct of the firm might be substantial. As a result, the team considered that it was important that customers were given the earliest opportunity to consider whether they remained willing to proceed with the firm on their motor finance claim, given the concerns the FCA has identified.

Contact