In Visa Inc & Ors v Luxottica Retail UK Ltd [2026] EWHC 615 (Comm), the High Court held that the clauses releasing claims in a settlement agreement extended to the claim of a company that was only acquired by the claimant group post-settlement. The Court also rejected the argument that the negotiation and enforcement of the settlement agreement was “sharp practice”.
The decision serves as a reminder to exercise caution when drafting settlement agreements, particularly the clauses which control the scope of the release of claims.
Background
The Claimant, Luxottica Retail UK Ltd, is part of a wider corporate group which sells eyewear. A number of retailers, including the Claimant, issued proceedings against the Defendants, Visa, for alleged breaches of competition law relating to the multilateral interchange fees (“MIFs”) which are imposed when a retailer accepts a card payment from a customer.
The Claimant itself never served its claim form, but entered into settlement discussions with the Defendants and, in January 2021, the parties reached a written settlement.
Meanwhile, GrandVision NV, an entity entirely distinct from the Claimant, had issued an MIF claim against the Defendants in 2018. While the Claimant’s settlement negotiations were ongoing, the Claimant’s parent company had agreed to acquire GrandVision NV, although the deal did not complete until after the Claimant’s settlement agreement was signed.
Once the acquisition of GrandVision NV was complete, the Defendants asserted that the settlement agreement covered GrandVision NV’s claim too. The Claimant rejected this.
The two main issues for the Court to decide were:
- As a matter of construction, did the settlement agreement include GrandVision NV’s claim?
- If the settlement agreement did include the claim, would its enforcement reward “sharp practice” which the law should prevent?
Decision
Construction of the settlement agreement
The Court began by reiterating that contractual construction is a matter of understanding what the words of the contract would convey to a reasonable person with the relevant background information available to the parties at the time of the contract.
The relevant recital (D) in the settlement agreement stated:
"In the interests of reaching a commercial resolution of the Claim and of conclusively resolving any and all other MIF-Related Claims (as defined below, together with the Claim, the 'Settled Claims') that the Claimant and/or any Claimant Associated Company have or may have, Visa have agreed to pay, and the Claimant has agreed to accept, the Settlement Payment (as defined below) in full and final settlement of the Settled Claims on the terms set out below." (emphasis added).
While there was no definition of “Claimant Associated Company”, there was a definition of "'Associated Company', which had:
“[…] the same meaning as in Section 256 of the Companies Act 2006, and shall include past, present or future Associated Companies (together with successors) without any geographical limitation whatsoever". (emphasis added)
“MIF-Related Claim” was also given a wide definition as including:
"any actual or potential claim, counterclaim, demand, action, cause of action, set-off, right, suit, arbitration, inquiry or proceeding of any nature whatsoever (other than in relation to an Acquirer Issue) in any jurisdiction, whether past, present or future, whether known or unknown at the time of this Agreement, whether or not contemplated or foreseen …”
The Claimant believed the express wording of the contract should be limited by implied wording, but the Court rejected this, finding that the drafting was especially broad and included express carve-outs in other areas. In this case, the Court pointed to the exclusion of an “Acquirer Issue” from the definition of “MIF-Related Claim” as evidence that limitations had already been considered by the parties.
Further, while the Court accepted that the primary concern of the settlement was to deal with the Claimant’s claim, the Court found that it was a secondary purpose of the settlement agreement to “’conclusively resolve’ other claims, including at least some claims of ‘Claimant Associated Companies’”.
As “Associated Companies” included future Associated Companies, and the words “may have” in Recital D could include future claims, the Court therefore held that an objective reader would view the settlement agreement as including the claims of companies such as GrandVision NV.
The Court did note the adverse impact a wide construction of the clause would have on the Claimant, but was clear that contractual construction will not rewrite clear contractual language.
“Sharp practice”
The Court accepted the existence of an equitable principle which would prevent the "unconscionable" enforcement of releases in settlement agreements. However, the Court did not find “sharp practice” was at play here.
In the case of settlement, some degree of inequality of information is accepted, and this settlement agreement was expressly framed to catch both known and unknown claims. Therefore, the Court held that if the parties expressly settled on the basis that there may be other claims which one party might be aware of and the other not, silence would not amount to sharp practice.
It was also important that the Claimant was professionally represented; the Court held that the Defendants were under no obligation to make the terms of the settlement fair or explain them to the Claimant, nor is it sharp practice to settle for less than you might have been prepared to offer.
Key takeaways
Commercial parties need to be alert to the risks of drafting releases in settlement agreements too broadly, especially those involving group companies or where there may be a possibility of future acquisitions. If a settlement is intended to settle a specific dispute and nothing further, it is best to make this clear within the contract terms.
The Court is unlikely to rescue a commercial party as a result of alleged “sharp practice”. Where parties are commercial in nature, receive legal advice, and are negotiating on the foundation of an inequality of knowledge, equitable principles are unlikely to bail out a party.
With thanks to Joe Miley for his assistance in preparing this post.
Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.