Introduction

Transfer pricing (TP) certainty matters, and effective dispute resolution mechanisms are equally important. This is perhaps one of the key lessons from the Ørsted case. On 10 September 2026, Ørsted announced that an advisory commission established under the EU Arbitration Convention had issued its final opinion in a long-running disagreement between the Danish Tax Agency (DTA) and HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC).1

The case offers an important precedent of how cross-border tax controversies can be resolved where competent authorities are unable to reconcile fundamentally different views on TP.

Background2

The dispute arose from the TP treatment of offshore wind farm projects developed by the Ørsted group in the UK. While Ørsted sought clarity from both the DTA and HMRC as early as 2015, the discussions ultimately failed to produce an agreed outcome.

In 2020, the DTA adopted a position under which Ørsted would be taxed in Denmark on the full future value of two UK offshore wind farm projects. With the competent authorities unable to reach an agreement, the matter ultimately proceeded under the EU Arbitration Convention. The advisory commission broadly confirmed Ørsted's position, concluding that the projects possessed genuine legal and economic substance and that the profits should primarily be taxed in the UK over the lifetime of the projects.

The value of effective dispute resolution

Perhaps the most important lesson is that international dispute resolution frameworks can operate as intended. Taxpayers often view Mutual Agreement Procedures (MAPs) and arbitration as lengthy and uncertain. The Ørsted case demonstrates that arbitration can provide a meaningful route where competent authorities remain deadlocked.

The procedural context is also noteworthy. Although the UK is no longer a member of the EU, the dispute was resolved through the EU Arbitration Convention because it originated before the end of the Brexit transition period.

More broadly, the case highlights the importance of having access to effective mechanisms capable of eliminating double taxation. Without them, taxpayers can become trapped between competing positions adopted by different competent authorities. The decision reinforces a fundamental principle of international taxation: TP adjustments should not result in economic double taxation merely because jurisdictions disagree.

The TP angle

While the full decision is not public at this stage, Ørsted announcements reveal some interesting facts for TP.

Ørsted stated that the DTA's position was "based on a misconception of the risks and value creation in Ørsted's business model"3. This observation is particularly significant because it reflects one of the most common themes in modern TP controversies. Increasingly, disputes arise not from disagreements over pricing mechanics, but from competing views regarding where value is created and which entities genuinely control and assume the relevant risks.

The conclusion that the projects possessed a "genuine legal and economic purpose"4 also suggests that considerable weight was placed on the underlying commercial reality. This is consistent with the broader direction of TP, which must be supported by economic substance and operational reality.

Why the decision matters beyond Ørsted

The significance of the decision extends beyond a single taxpayer or sector. It may encourage taxpayers to make greater use of dispute resolution mechanisms when confronted with unresolved double taxation.

For tax administrations, the decision serves as a reminder that TP adjustments must be grounded in facts, substance and a coherent analysis of value creation. For taxpayers, it provides reassurance that dispute resolution mechanisms can deliver meaningful outcomes, even in complex cases.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Source: Ørsted receives final opinion regarding taxation of Walney Extension and Hornsea 1

  2. 2

    Source: Ørsted appeals against decision from the Danish Tax Agency on Danish taxation of two offshore wind farms in the UK and Ørsted receives final opinion regarding taxation of Walney Extension and Hornsea 1

  3. 3

    Ørsted receives final opinion regarding taxation of Walney Extension and Hornsea 1

  4. 4

    Ørsted appeals against decision from the Danish Tax Agency on Danish taxation of two offshore wind farms in the UK

Contact