From 2030, master trusts and group personal pensions will generally need a main scale default arrangement holding at least £25 billion in assets under management in order to continue receiving automatic enrolment contributions. Here's what we know so far.
What are the scale requirements?
One of the most hotly debated parts of the Pension Schemes Act 2026 is a new requirement for a commercial defined contribution (DC) scheme to be approved as worth at least £25 billion by 2030 or lose access to the automatic enrolment market. The government wants DC schemes to operate at scale to be in a position to access less liquid assets (see our January 2026 and May 2026 blogs on these requirements).
The scale requirements do not look at assets across an entire master trust or group personal pension provider. Instead, a scheme will need to nominate a single default arrangement, known as the main scale default arrangement, or more commonly, the MSDA, and demonstrate that it holds the required level of assets managed under a common investment strategy. If a MSDA applies to more than one scheme or group personal pension, there will be some scope to treat the relevant schemes and group personal pensions as connected for the scale test.
Key issues that will shape how the scale requirements work
Further developments are expected before the regime comes into force, including consultation on draft regulations, changes to the Pensions Regulator’s code and guidance. For expected timings see our Pension Schemes Act 2026 tracker here.
At this stage important questions still remain about how assets, and schemes, can be treated as bundled together to test against the scale requirements. This will affect whether master trust scheme strategists and providers can ensure their MSDA reaches the required scale or not.
The Government has published a discussion paper looking at key questions:
- What will count towards the threshold? The government is proposing that only assets under management in the DC master trust or group personal pension MSDA will count towards the £25 billion threshold. This means, for example, that assets in bespoke default arrangements or self-select arrangements would be excluded even if they use the same building block funds as the MSDA. This could result in substantial assets not counting towards the £25 billion threshold.
- What constitutes a common investment strategy? To count within an MSDA, assets must be managed under a common investment strategy. This requirement is to ensure that the benefits of scale are genuinely achieved, and that assets pooled in the MSDA are managed together under the same strategy rather than being only nominally combined. The extent of any permitted differences within a common investment strategy will therefore be important.
- When can master trusts and group personal pension schemes be treated as "connected"? This matters because connected arrangements within the same corporate group may be able to combine assets within a single MSDA for threshold purposes. For trustees and providers operating multiple master trusts and group personal pensions, the definition of ‘connected’ could therefore have a significant impact on their ability to meet the £25 billion threshold.
Feedback on the discussion paper will help shape the draft regulations expected in Autumn / Winter 2027.
Which schemes will the scale requirements apply to?
The scale requirements will apply to any authorised DC master trusts or group personal pension schemes currently used by employers to meet their automatic enrolment obligations. They will also apply to any self-invested personal pensions being used for automatic enrolment.
There are a number of authorised DC master trusts which are hybrid and/or not commercially available (the ‘accidental master trusts’). How the regime will apply to those arrangements remains to be confirmed.
When will the scale requirements apply from?
The scale requirements are expected to come into force from April 2030.
What happens if a scheme does not meet the scale requirements in time?
The starting point is that any master trust or group personal pension that has not been approved as having a qualifying MSDA worth at least £25 billion by 2030 will no longer be able to receive automatic enrolment contributions. Employers using the arrangement would therefore need to consider alternative arrangements for meeting their automatic enrolment duties. However, benefits already accrued in the arrangement would not be required to be transferred out.
However there are some alternative pathways.
A master trust or group personal pension may be eligible for the transition pathway if its MSDA has at least £10 billion in assets under management under a common investment strategy and the scheme strategist or provider has a credible plan to reach the £25 billion threshold by 2035. Other conditions may be set out in regulations.
A separate new entrant pathway is also available for new master trusts and group personal pensions. To qualify, the master trust or group personal pension must not yet have any members; its scheme strategist or provider must be able to demonstrate strong potential to grow to the required scale and the scheme must have an innovative product design. Again, other conditions may be applied via regulations in due course.
What to do now to prepare for the scale requirements
Master trust scheme strategists and group personal pension providers are already planning their journey, with default arrangements being consolidated where possible and M&A opportunities being considered. Their gap analysis will include:
- Any differences in existing client default arrangements that could be resolved over time to drive their inclusion in an MSDA.
- Whether employer clients could be persuaded to shift to the provider’s in-house default arrangement instead of current bespoke arrangements.
- What would need to be true in a clear and convincing business plan for reaching the £25 billion threshold if the transition pathway looks the more likely option.
- Policy adjustments as further consultations, regulations and guidance are published.
Trustees and providers may also be looking at the options for bulk transfers to consolidate schemes. Bulk transfers of member pots to DC master trusts is already possible without individual member consent. Providers of FCA-regulated schemes will also be getting a power to transfer savers without their consent where it is in savers’ best interests. That power will be relevant for consolidation for scale as much as for VFM action plans. The FCA expects to be consulting on draft rules for the so-called ‘contractual override’ in Q1 2027, with the power coming into effect in March 2028.
For employers, the key question is whether your current arrangement is going to survive the mass consolidation of the market for scale, and if you are already thinking of changing your DC provider, which of the current alternative providers will have to exit the market. Talk to your provider to understand their plans.
Comment
The scale requirements are now one of the more significant drivers of consolidation in the DC market. While the policy direction is clear, the detail remains uncertain. For some trustees and providers, the rules on what counts towards the MSDA and when assets can be aggregated may significantly impact how and whether they can meet the £25 billion threshold.
The definition of a common investment strategy is going to be particularly key. The current discussion paper suggests the only permitted variation within a common investment strategy should be by reference to a member's age (to allow investment strategies to adjust as members approach retirement). That may be too restrictive. For example, many default strategies are structured around a member's expected retirement date rather than their actual age, as is recognised in the parallel development of the VFM framework.
The timetable also remains a concern. Draft regulations are not expected until late 2027, which leaves the industry with a prolonged period of uncertainty and a compressed window to implement what may be significant operational, governance and commercial changes before the 2030 deadline.