Fraud is the most common crime in the UK. The ecosystem is complex but it includes the use of online advertising and digital services to commit fraud. This puts digital service providers in the spotlight and at the intersect of different legal and regulatory domains and regulators. Legal and Compliance teams need to be aware of and leverage the overlap.

Key recent UK developments digital service providers should engage in and monitor include:

  • The recent Independent Review on Fraud in the Digital Age (the Independent Review) which calls for (i) a new criminal offence targeting technology platforms that fail to prevent fraud on their services, marking a significant potential expansion of the UK’s corporate criminal liability framework; and (ii) an anti-fraud levy on digital and communications providers; and
  • Ofcom’s draft Fraudulent Advertising Code under the Online Safety Act (OSA) which is in consultation. Ofcom calls on the largest online platforms “to up their game …directing more leadership attention and investment to addressing the problem of fraudulent advertising”.

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has also recently signalled its support for greater private sector involvement in proactively tackling fraud. Following publication of the Independent Review, the FCA’s executive director of enforcement and market oversight, Steve Smart, emphasised the need for major technology companies to adopt a more proactive stance in identifying and disrupting fraudulent content across their platforms.

What is the impact and a practical approach to this?

Large corporations already have criminal exposure under UK law for fraud that benefits their organisation if they fail to put in place adequate measures and they should have already assessed and implemented the required measures. With the focus now on preventing fraud perpetrated on their digital surfaces and services, it makes sense to take a consistent enterprise and services wide approach to fraud and create an overarching fraud prevention program of work, leveraging and bringing together what is already in place to address corporate and user legal and regulatory risks and implementing efficiently what may still be required.

We look at these converging developments in more detail below.

Fraud in the digital age

The Independent Review makes 47 recommendations centred around a “zero tolerance” theme, and a shift towards a more proactive enforcement model. The recommendations are broader than the technology sector but include proposed measures targeted at the technology sector given its role in enabling fraud and fraudulent online content and actions.

Recommendation 1: A new criminal offence for online platforms

The Independent Review recommends introducing a new corporate criminal offence for user-to-user services regulated under the OSA who fail to prevent fraud on their platforms, recognising the increasing prevalence of fraud on online platforms, including scam adverts, fake listings and other fraudulent content.

Online platforms can be particularly susceptible to fraud, with social media and search service platforms being described in the Independent Review as “play[ing] a demonstrable role in facilitating fraud”. Citing UK Finance, the Independent Review states that 78% of authorised push payment fraud (where a person is deceived into voluntarily transferring funds to a fraudulent account) originates online, with three-quarters beginning on social media.

The Independent Review proposes that the new offence would “closely mirror” the ‘failure-to-prevent’ fraud offence under the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 (ECCTA), under which large organisations face criminal liability if they fail to prevent fraud committed by associated persons for their benefit (click here to view our recently published articles on the failure-to-prevent fraud offence, which came into force in September 2025). The proposed offence would not impose strict liability, instead mirroring the proportionate, principles-based framework of the ECCTA model, implementing a duty to adopt reasonable prevention procedures, tailored to the platform’s size, risk profile and operational capacity.

The rationale

The Independent Review advocates for the introduction of this new offence, arguing that current failure to prevent fraud offence is limited in scope and represents a “substantial accountability gap”, as it:

  1. applies only where fraud is committed by an associated person for the organisation’s benefit. It would not likely apply to fraud committed by third-party users of a platform, even where the platform profits by user-traffic or advertising revenue generated by the fraudulent conduct; and
  2. captures only “large organisations”, meaning entities that meet at least two of the following factors: (a) more than 250 employees; (b) more than £36 million turnover; (c) more than £18 million in total assets. The Independent Review identifies that only an estimated 0.2% of UK businesses meet ECCTA’s large-organisation threshold.

While acknowledging inherent concerns with extending the failure-to-prevent fraud regime to online platforms, including technical feasibility, proportionality and jurisdictional enforcement, the Independent Review notes that these concerns are “not insurmountable” given the offence would only require reasonable, risk-proportionate measures.

The Independent Review builds on a 2022 report by the House of Commons Justice Committee, that endorsed a failure to-prevent-fraud offence, requiring companies, including social media platforms, to prevent fraud on their systems.

Recommendation 2: An anti-fraud levy

Complementing Recommendation 2, the Independent Review also recommends an anti-fraud levy on digital and communications infrastructure providers, including social media platforms, online service providers and other intermediaries that host or facilitate fraudulent activity. The levy would be administered by the Office of Communications (Ofcom), with a sunset clause allowing for its reduction or removal if measurable improvements in fraud prevention, detection and cooperation are demonstrated.

The regime is modelled on the existing Economic Crime (Anti-Money Laundering) Levy under the Finance Act 2022 that requires regulated entities to contribute to an anti-money laundering fund.

Taken together, these Recommendations signal a clear focus on accountability for platforms in respect of fraud facilitated through their services.

Overlap with the Online Safety Act 2023

The OSA imposes statutory duties of care on certain user-to-user and search services in relation to fraudulent advertising, including duties to use “proportionate systems and processes” to prevent users encountering fraudulent advertisements, to minimise the time such content remains live and to take it down swiftly once identified. The details of what will be considered “proportionate” are currently the subject of Ofcom’s draft Code or Practice which is open to consultation. The duties apply to paid-for advertising or sponsored search content rather than all digital content or services.

These duties of care are imposed at the organisational level, and while Ofcom has the ability to enforce compliance through investigations and issuing civil penalties of up to £18 million or 10% of qualifying worldwide revenue (whichever is higher) or applying business disruption measures, its criminal reach is limited to senior managers who fail to comply with procedural notices or obstruct enforcement functions. The Independent Review’s proposed new offence under Recommendation 2 is therefore intended to sit alongside, and not replace, the OSA’s civil and regulatory regime.

However, the proposed offence would go materially further than the OSA in several key respects, including:

  1. Extending corporate criminal liability to platforms that fail to prevent fraud, whereas the OSA's enforcement regime is primarily civil and regulatory in nature.
  2. Applying to a broader range of platforms – not just those large platforms falling into Category 1 and Category 2A of the OSA, and a broader range of conduct – not just paid-for fraudulent advertising.

Next steps

The Recommendations are at an early stage. We will publish updates when further information is available. It is clear that the Government and regulators remain committed to endorsing a proactive fraud prevention framework.

In the meantime, digital service providers should, given the focus on these issues:

  1. Corporate Responsibility: ensure that they have conducted a risk assessment and put in place reasonable procedures to prevent fraud for their organisation’s benefit, to manage the risk of criminal liability under ECTA.
  2. OSA: those in scope of OSA should also prepare for the incoming measures to prevent fraud under the OSA and ensure that they participate in the Ofcom consultation relating to fraudulent advertising duties, open until the end of September.
  3. A singular approach: for providers whose surfaces, products or services are used to perpetrate fraud, consider how to bring together an overarching fraud program that manages the risks of fraud end-to-end both in your organisation and by use of your organisation’s products and services.

If you would like to discuss how we can help you manage the above or run a fraud program, please get in touch with our regulatory specialists:

Andrew Reeves, Joanna Conway, Stuart Neely, Verity Quartermain

The authors wish to thank Bronte Hearn for her contribution to the article.

Contact