The Law Commission has published its second consultation (the "Second Consultation") on the right to renew business tenancies under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (the "LTA"). Relevant to anyone who owns, leases or invests in commercial property in England and Wales, these proposals will change how business tenancies are granted, renewed and terminated.
Background
Part 2 of the LTA gives qualifying business tenants an automatic right to renew their tenancies when they would otherwise expire. Practitioners, landlords and occupiers will be familiar with the "contracting-out" method, and landlord statutory grounds for opposition.
Whilst the regime has long been a cornerstone of the commercial leasing market, the Law Commission considers that it is not working well for either side — causing unnecessary cost and delay and preventing commercial space from being let quickly and efficiently. The stated aim is to make the regime fit for modern market conditions and genuinely useful, rather than something routinely opted out of.
Previous consultation
The Law Commission's first consultation, published last year, suggested that reform would be relatively limited in scope, retaining the existing "contracting-out" model (see our previous article). On 16 June 2026, it published the anticipated Second Consultation which is considerably broader, covering the full lifecycle of a protected tenancy. The key proposals are summarised below.
Proposals
- Qualifying criteria:
- The Second Consultation proposes to narrow the tenancies that qualify for protection. Most new and renewal periodic tenancies would be excluded from LTA protection (currently, these benefit from security of tenure which cannot be contracted out of), with an exception for renewal tenancies where the tenant already holds a protected tenancy.
- Whether to remove short term tenancies from the Act’s regime by increasing the minimum fixed-term threshold for protection from 6 months to either 1 or 2 years is a key consideration. If set at 1 year, prior occupation under a renewal fixed-term tenancy would be disregarded. If 2 years, it would be considered. The Second Consultation also proposes that any new or renewal tenancy should be capable of being contracted out, to avoid tenancies inadvertently being protected.
- Contracting out of Security of Tenure: The current contracting-out procedure would be replaced by the prescribed warning notice and tenant's declaration forming part of the tenancy agreement itself, along with prescribed wording confirming that any future tenancy would also be contracted out. The same would apply to agreements for future tenancies.
- Agreements to Surrender and Future Renewal Tenancies: The Second Consultation considers whether the contracting-out procedure for agreements to surrender should be scrapped or simplified, and whether it should apply to surrenders of protected tenancies. It also reviews section 28 of the LTA, which disapplies the LTA where the parties agree to grant a future tenancy.
- Terms of the Renewal Tenancy:
- The Second Consultation considers whether renewal terms should be based on market norms rather than the original tenancy and "all relevant circumstances" (per O'May v City of London Real Property Co Ltd [1983] 2 AC 726) but provisionally concludes that the current law should be retained.
- It proposes expressly guiding the courts to treat environmental matters as "relevant circumstances" on renewal.
- Rent on Renewal and During the Continuation Tenancy: The Second Consultation proposes simplifying the interim rent process, either by backdating the renewal tenancy to a fixed valuation date (largely removing the need for a separate interim rent assessment) or by adopting two valuation dates — one for the continuation period and one for the renewal tenancy, with a simplified interim rent assessment. It also considers whether protected tenancies should benefit from a rent-free fit-out period, and whether courts should be able to impose turnover rents on renewal.
- Grounds to Oppose Renewal: Amendments are proposed for two key grounds of opposition. Ground (f) (intention to demolish or reconstruct) would either be expanded to cover modern construction methods such as retrofitting and MEES compliance works or replaced with a broader test of an intention to undertake "substantial works". Ground (g) (landlord's own occupation) would be amended so that landlords can alter the property before occupying part of it, but cannot benefit from the tenant's goodwill if they carry on the same business.
- Compensation for Tenants: Where renewal is successfully opposed on Ground (f) or (g), the Second Consultation asks whether compensation should be calculated by reference to rent rather than rateable value, whether the 14-year threshold for double compensation remains appropriate, and whether the 5-year threshold below which compensation can be excluded by agreement should change.
- Dispute Resolution: Renewal disputes are currently heard in the county courts. The Second Consultation considers whether some or all should move to the tribunal (i.e. the First Tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal) with the High Court for higher-value or complex cases, and whether alternative dispute resolution ("ADR") should play a greater role — either by party election or by including a reference to ADR in statutory notices.
- Identity of the Parties: The Second Consultation asks whether notices under the LTA should be served by and on equitable owners (as opposed to legal owners) during the registration gap (the period of time between an application being made to the Land Registry, and completion of that application during which the transferee of the property owns it on an equitable basis, with legal ownership remaining with the transferor) .
- Procedure for Claiming or Opposing Renewal: Whether or not all tenants (including periodic tenants) should have the right to serve a section 26 notice to initiate renewal, is considered. The Second Consultation also considers whether a 6 or 12-month notice period cap on tenants' ability to terminate continuation tenancies should be introduced.
- Other Issues: The Second Consultation also addresses the requirement for a tenant to be "in occupation", specific challenges in large-scale and/or complex developments, and considers transitional arrangements.
Next steps
The Second Consultation closes on 16 September 2026, and details of consultation events are yet to be announced. The Law Commission will then publish a final report, alongside the final recommendations on its consultation on commercial leasehold law and barriers to transactions (on which we have reported separately here). We, alongside many stakeholders, are interested to see how transformative the final proposals really are. One thing is clear; contracting-out is here to stay.