The UK transfer of trade rules are intended to give a tax neutral outcome to intra-group transfers and reorganisations, and apply automatically when the relevant conditions are met. The aim is that there is continuity of the trading loss and capital allowances position between the transferor and transferee, who is deemed to “step into the shoes” of its predecessor. This general principle is often hard to apply in practice.
A recent Upper Tribunal decision has considered the effect of the specific rules that apply to a transfer of a trade within a group in the context of activities that fell inside and outside the UK’s oil and gas ring-fencing regime. Whilst the decision itself may be specific to its facts, the transfer of trade rules discussed in the case are of more general application and this decision is therefore a useful reminder of the conditions that need to be satisfied before a transfer can take place on a tax-neutral basis.
One key condition is that the transferee must begin to carry on the “same trade” that has ceased to be carried on by the transferor (which can extend to a situation where the activity constitutes an identifiable part of a trade). The decision in Falmer Jeans established that, when considering this “same trade” test, a focus should be given to the substance of the trading activities, and their continuity following the transfer, and not just to the label of the trade itself.
CATS North Sea Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKUT 142 (TCC) considers the interaction between the Part 22 rules, the decision in Falmer Jeans, and section 279 CTA 2010 (which deems that oil-related activities are “to be treated as a separate trade” for corporation tax purposes). While much of the decision relates specifically to interaction of the transfer of trade rules and the oil and gas regime, it provides useful commentary that will be relevant to any group reorganisations involving companies with ring-fenced trades.
The decision concerned a hive-down of the trading activities between two members of the BP group, Amoco (U.K.) Exploration Company, LLC (Amoco) and CATS North Sea Limited (CNSL). Before the hive‑down, Amoco treated all of its pipeline activities as inside the oil and gas ring‑fence, and claimed capital allowances on qualifying expenditure. After the hive‑down, CNSL was not a participator in the relevant oilfield, which resulted in a split of the pipeline activities into two trades once they were being carried on by CNSL: one inside, the other outside the ring-fence. CNSL was later sold to a third party, resulting in a full exit from the ring-fence regime.
The FTT, agreeing with HMRC’s approach, had held that first it was necessary to identify a Part 22 transfer of trade. Section 279 would then apply solely for the purposes of computing ring‑fence profits. On this basis, and applying Falmer Jeans, it found that the continuity of the pipeline activities after the hive-down resulted in the transfer of a single, ring-fenced trade. CNSL’s subsequent use of the pipeline partly for non-ringfenced purposes constituted a disposal event, with the disposal value capped at CNSL’s full historical cost.
The UT disagreed. Remaking the FTT’s decision, it found that section 279 must be applied first, as it defines which activities form the relevant (ring-fenced) trade; it can then be determined if the transferee is still carrying on that same trade after the transfer, and whether Part 22 continuity applies. As a result, the UT found that there was a Part 22 transfer solely in respect of the strand of trade that remained inside the ring-fence once it was carried on by CNSL, with a disposal event when CNSL left the BP group. The other strand, which crossed out of the ring-fence after the transfer, simply resulted in a disposal event for Amoco on the hive down; there would be no subsequent disposal for CNSL once it exited the BP group.
The takeaways
While the decision in CATS will be of interest mainly to those with oil-and-gas operations in the UK’s North Sea, it provides three principles that are helpful to keep in mind when looking at other regimes which create ring-fenced trades by deeming them to be separate trades – such as the tonnage tax rules.
- When considering whether the “same trade” has been transferred, full effect must first be given to any statute which deems certain activities to be treated as a separate trade for corporation tax purposes. Once the separate trades have been identified, Part 22 can be applied to the qualifying strands.
- Falmer Jeans remains the touchstone case for the “same trade” test but cannot be used to sidestep where trades have been ring-fenced or deemed to be so by statute. In such cases, Falmer Jeans’ examination of the continuity of the trading activities should be performed for each statutorily-defined trade separately.
- Where statute deems separate trades, any capital allowance pools should be dealt with through up‑front apportionment, to avoid allocating expenditure relating to different “qualifying activities” to the same pool; disposal values and historic cost should be apportioned consistently between the trades.