In Caterpillar Property Ltd & Anr v Park Cakes Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 575, the Court of Appeal has confirmed that a tenant's unexercised option to renew does not constitute an "agreement for the grant of a future tenancy" under section 28 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (the "1954 Act"), and that the lease therefore remains protected by Part II.
Section 28 of the 1954 Act has rarely been the subject of litigation, making this decision of considerable significance. The case also reached the Court of Appeal with notable speed: the appeal leapfrogged the High Court entirely given the urgency of the matter and the tenant's potential need to exercise the option, which was due to expire in mid-June 2026.
Factual background
The case concerned two 20-year leases of factories in Bolton and Oldham, both granted in June 2007 on identical terms by Caterpillar Property Limited (the "Landlord") to Park Cakes Ltd (the "Tenant"), which occupies the premises for its cake-making business. Each lease contained an option to renew, entitling the Tenant to a further 10-year lease provided it gave at least 12 months' notice after the end of the 17th year of the term and had paid the yearly rent up to the end of the term. Clauses within the option provided for the rent under any renewal lease to be ascertained by indexation, producing a fixed, index-linked rent that would significantly exceed the prevailing market rent. By contrast, section 34 of the 1954 Act stipulates that rent payable under a new lease granted through the statutory renewal process would be determined by reference to the open market rent of the premises. The Tenant therefore wished to pursue a new lease at market rent under Part II of the 1954 Act, rather than exercise the option and be locked into the higher, index-linked figure.
The Landlord argued that the option to renew fell within section 28 of the 1954 Act, which provides that where the landlord and tenant "agree for the grant to the tenant of a future tenancy" on specified terms and from a specified date, the current tenancy is not one to which Part II applies. The Landlord's commercial objective was to ensure that the Tenant could only obtain a renewal on the contractual, index-linked terms and not at the lower market rent available under the 1954 Act.
County Court decision
The County Court decision at first instance held the unexercised option did not fall within section 28 and that the Tenant was entitled to Part II protection. The Judge reasoned that the Tenant only acquires an enforceable right to a new tenancy when the option is fully exercised; before exercise, neither party is under a reciprocal obligation to grant or take a new lease.
Court of Appeal decision
The Court of Appeal’s unanimous decision followed the first instance decision and rejected the Landlord’s appeal, holding that an option to renew is a unilateral or "if" contract, which creates no legal obligations on either party unless and until exercised. It is only upon exercise of the option that it converts into a bilateral contract with mutual obligations. Before that point, a tenant cannot be said to have "agreed for the grant" of a future tenancy as required by section 28. Since Part II exists to protect business tenants, the correct perspective from which to analyse an option is that of the tenant, from whose viewpoint it is analogous to an irrevocable offer rather than a conditional contract.
Key takeaways
The decision provides welcome clarity on a point that, surprisingly, had not previously been considered, despite the frequency with which options to renew are used in commercial leases. Tenants with unexercised options to renew can take comfort that the existence of such an option will not, of itself, deprive them of the protection of Part II of the 1954 Act. Landlords should note that section 28 will only be engaged where there is a binding and enforceable commitment by both parties to the grant of a new tenancy.
The decision also highlights the practical distinction between options (where the tenant's position may be more precarious if there are strict compliance requirements to the exercise of the option) and the statutory renewal regime under the 1954 Act (where grounds of opposition require, for example, persistent delay in rent payment or substantial breaches of covenant). From a tenant's perspective, the decision underscores the tactical value of including a contractual option to renew alongside the statutory protections of the 1954 Act: if a landlord seeks to oppose a new lease on non-fault grounds such as grounds (f) (redevelopment) or (g) (own occupation), the tenant retains the ability to exercise a contractual option as a fallback, provided the conditions for exercise are met.