Member who should have recognised an error in their pension benefits is required to repay the overpayments in full, even though the scheme had made the mistake in paying the benefits.

This Pensions Ombudsman decision highlights the risks for members who are not sufficiently alert to potential errors in their benefits, or who effectively turn a blind eye to them. The concept of ‘Nelsonian knowledge’, where a person suspects something may be wrong but fails to make enquiries, can prevent a member from relying on equitable defences and lead to full recovery of overpayments, even where there has been a clear administrative error by the scheme manager and / or administrator.

In this case the member received duplicate pension benefits after part of his service was mistakenly recorded under two pension records, resulting in overpayments of more than £22,000. The Ombudsman found that while there had been maladministration, there was no injustice because the member had ‘Nelsonian knowledge’ of the error. In other words, the member ought to have realised something was wrong and taken steps to query it.

This meant the member could not rely on the change of position or other defences, because they require good faith. And good faith was not satisfied because the member had reason to suspect an error, but failed to query it. As a result, all of the overpayments were recoverable.

This case also highlights the Ombudsman’s pragmatic approach to recovery. Although the overpayments arose over a period of five years, taking into account the member’s financial position, the Ombudsman directed that the repayments are spread over 15 years, with scope for a further extension of the repayment period if the member’s financial position deteriorates.

Contact