Introduction

Businesses are experiencing a period of geopolitical friction. Sanctions regimes and trade restrictions are expanding, supply chains are being regionalised and states are increasingly prepared to prioritise strategic and political interests over legal and institutional consistency. This creates a practical question: when commercial relationships cross borders, political systems and competing legal regimes, how can businesses remain assured of obtaining an effective, neutral and enforceable form of dispute resolution?

This article argues that international commercial arbitration, while not immune to political headwinds, is unusually resilient to the conditions that have destabilised other mechanisms of cross-border dispute resolution. This resilience can be explained in part by commercial arbitration’s alignment with state and business incentives, but also by its nature as a system that has developed organically over centuries, adapting incrementally to changing political conditions in a manner that might tentatively be compared to biological evolution - with fitness conferred by incremental adaptation from below. This can be contrasted with the architecture of investment arbitration and World Trade Organisation ("WTO") dispute settlement, both of which are comparatively recent, treaty-based constructions that, for all their sophistication, have yet to develop the same degree of institutional flexibility and political insulation.

Investment Arbitration: A case study in vulnerability

The last two decades have witnessed a pronounced turn toward economic nationalism, populism and scepticism of multilateral institutions. Developments such as the United Kingdom's departure from the European Union and the United States' move towards a tariff-based trade policy illustrate a broader retreat from multilateralism and the arrival of an environment in which dispute resolution mechanisms perceived as constraining state sovereignty are prone to attack.

Investment treaty arbitration offers a vivid illustration. The investor-state dispute settlement ("ISDS") regime, built upon a network of bilateral and multilateral investment treaties and underpinned by the widely adopted ICSID Convention, was regarded as a success story of international economic governance, promising foreign investors tangible standards of protection and a neutral forum for investment dispute resolution free from domestic court interference.

Yet ISDS has become one of the most politically contested features of the international legal order. Developing states object that it enables corporations to challenge regulatory measures before tribunals that lack political accountability; Bolivia, Ecuador and Venezuela withdrew from the ICSID Convention and the European Union has proposed a permanent multilateral investment court instead of ISDS. In North America, the North American Free Trade Agreement was replaced with the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement, which scaled back the ISDS provisions between members states. Meanwhile, the withdrawal of multiple contracting parties from the Energy Charter Treaty (“ECT”), driven by the perceived incompatibility between fossil fuel investment protections and climate policy goals, further illustrates how political opposition can impact upon ISDS.

The vulnerability of investment arbitration is, in part, a consequence of its origins. ISDS is the product of a treaty-based system assembled in the latter half of the twentieth century to serve particular geopolitical objectives - mainly to encourage capital flows from developed to developing states. As it involves claims by investors against sovereign states, ISDS inherently engages questions of state regulatory autonomy and creates a tension with domestic political constituencies. ISDS has shown some adaptive capacity: UNCITRAL Working Group III has been engaged since 2017 with proposing reform of the system and ICSID has amended its procedural rules. The system is in transition rather than terminal decline, but the pace and difficulty of these reforms, each requiring the consensus of state parties with divergent interests, illustrates the structural disadvantage of systems designed from the top-down - that they are, in institutional terms, slow to adapt.

The current pressures on ISDS are also visible on the WTO Appellate Body, which, since 1995, has provided binding interpretations of multilateral trade rules. While first instance WTO panels continue to function and issue reports, the Appellate Body is paralysed because, since December 2019, it has lacked the quorum necessary to hear appeals. This is because successive United States administrations have blocked appointments, rendering the appeals process defunct.

The experience of both systems demonstrates that treaty-based dispute resolution requires continued political support from state actors. Neither the WTO mechanism nor ISDS emerged gradually from the practice of disputing parties - both were created at particular historical moments and depend upon continued state consent to function. When any sufficiently powerful actor withdraws that consent, the system's multilateral character becomes its principal weakness.

International commercial arbitration: Structural resilience

Against these examples, the resilience of international commercial arbitration is striking. Commercial arbitration can be subject to the same geopolitical pressures as other forms of international dispute resolution, but it has not experienced a legitimacy crisis, institutional paralysis or a broad political backlash. This resilience reflects a combination of factors: its historical development, its decentralised structure, its symbiotic relationship with national courts and its broader alignment with commercial and state interests.

International commercial arbitration grew organically from the practices of merchants, traders and guilds over many centuries, from historic merchant communities, through specialist commodity arbitration in the great trading cities, to the sophisticated institutional frameworks of the modern era. It has always been rooted in the needs of the commercial necessity rather than state design. Arbitration survived the rise of the modern state not by resisting sovereign authority but by embracing it. It was adopted into domestic legal frameworks and developed a symbiotic relationship with national courts, which serve both to support the process (e.g. by enforcing awards and conservatory relief) and as a check upon arbitral excess (e.g. by policing the neutrality and impartiality of the tribunal). This co-evolution with the state is perhaps the most important structural difference between commercial arbitration and its treaty-based counterparts: where ISDS and WTO dispute settlement exist in tension with sovereign authority, commercial arbitration has developed to work with and alongside it.

Most fundamentally, international commercial arbitration is grounded in party autonomy, a feature that is itself the product of evolution rather than political fiat. The jurisdiction of a commercial arbitral tribunal derives from the agreement of the disputing parties who have chosen to submit their disputes to arbitration. This consensual foundation insulates commercial arbitration from some of the concerns expressed by those who oppose ISDS and WTO dispute resolution.

Commercial arbitration also benefits from a decentralised institutional architecture. There is no single treaty or institution upon which the entire system depends; instead, it rests upon a mosaic of arbitral institutions (such as the ICC and LCIA) each operating independently and competing for the confidence of users. If there is a single indispensable treaty, it is the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (1958) which, with over 170 contracting states, provides a near-universal enforcement framework. The Convention’s durability should not, however, be taken for granted: leading commentators argue that it needs modernisation, most notably because of inconsistent national court interpretations of the public policy exception and the absence of provisions addressing modern arbitral practice. In the current political climate, such reform would probably be impossible to achieve because it would require an unlikely consensus among member states. That no state has ever withdrawn from the Convention (in contrast to the ICSID Convention) is nonetheless a powerful testament to the alignment between its enforcement framework and sovereign commercial self-interest.

International commercial arbitration has also shown a notable capacity for institutional adaptation, driven by competition between arbitral institutions which must attract and retain users. Institutions have responded to criticisms of cost, delay and opacity with expedited procedures, emergency arbitrator mechanisms and revised rules on transparency and third-party funding disclosure. States also compete to be seen as suitable seats by adopting supportive arbitration statutes. This pluralism means the system is not hostage to the political decisions of any single institution, state or bloc: if any given jurisdiction becomes less hospitable, parties migrate to alternative seats and the broader system continues to function. This stands in marked contrast to multilateral treaty-based systems, where any change requires the consensus of states with divergent interests.

The limits of resilience: Qualifications and emerging challenges

Commercial arbitration is not without its own legitimacy challenges. Concerns have been raised about the concentration of arbitrator appointments among a small cohort of practitioners, the lack of diversity in the arbitral community, the opacity of proceedings and the growing influence of third-party funding. These are not trivial objections, and they suggest that commercial arbitration’s continued resilience may depend upon its willingness to address internal governance questions with the same adaptive capacity it has shown in other areas.

Moreover, the line between commercial and sovereign disputes is not always clean. States and state-owned enterprises are frequent participants in high-value commercial arbitration, particularly relating to energy, infrastructure and natural resources, and the resulting awards can be politically significant. The distinction lies not in the absence of political stakes but in the framing: disputes are generally presented as matters of contractual performance rather than assessments of the exercise of sovereign power, allowing states to participate as market actors and containing rather than eliminating political sensitivity.

The increasing weaponisation of economic policy has nonetheless created practical obstacles that test the system’s limits. The Russian Federation presents a compelling example. Following the imposition of EU sanctions in response to the annexation of Crimea in 2014, Russian courts adopted a broad interpretation of public policy to resist enforcement of foreign arbitral awards. In 2020, the Russian Parliament enacted Federal Law 171-FZ (the “Lugovoy Law"), conferring exclusive jurisdiction on Russian courts over disputes involving sanctioned persons even where a valid arbitration agreement provided for resolution abroad, and empowering sanctioned parties to obtain anti-arbitration injunctions with non-compliance subject to fines of up to the full amount in dispute.

The system's response demonstrates the resilience that organic development confers. English courts granted anti-suit injunctions restraining Russian parties from pursuing proceedings in breach of arbitration agreements, a practice upheld by the UK Supreme Court in UniCredit Bank GmbH v RusChemAlliance LLC [2024] UKSC 30. The European Union prohibited the recognition or enforcement within the EU of any Russian court decision issued under the Lugovoy Law. While a determined sovereign actor can disrupt commercial arbitration within its own borders, the decentralised character of the system allows other nodes in the network to compensate: awards remain enforceable elsewhere, and parties relocate their dispute resolution accordingly.

Conclusion

The broader trend toward geopolitical fragmentation may in time exert greater pressure on the international commercial arbitration system. Nevertheless, the fundamental features of international commercial arbitration, particularly its deep roots, its consensual basis, its institutional pluralism, its symbiotic relationship with national courts and its alignment with commercial self-interest, all continue to provide a meaningful buffer against the political headwinds that have destabilised other forms of international dispute resolution.

None of this is to suggest that commercial arbitration is invulnerable, but in an era characterised by the reassertion of state sovereignty and the erosion of multilateral institutions, it has demonstrated a degree of resilience that its younger, treaty-based counterparts currently lack. The broader lesson is that systems of dispute resolution are most durable when they align with the incentives of their users, minimise direct confrontation with sovereign authority and retain sufficient institutional flexibility to adapt to changing conditions. Commercial arbitration satisfies those conditions to a greater degree than its counterparts, but maintaining that advantage will require the system to confront its own internal challenges, from arbitrator diversity to transparency, with the same adaptive energy that has sustained it over its long history.

Issue 24

  • content-type:insights/publication
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/hubs/international-arbitration-report/issue-24
card-grid-item, aem-sourced
International arbitration report
/content/nrf-eds/en-gb/insights/topics/international-arbitration-report-hub

Contact