Introduction

In the last half-decade, dealmakers have had to grow accustomed to living in "unprecedented times", facing increased geopolitical volatility and seismic shifts in global markets. Despite this, 2025 was reportedly the second-highest year on record for global M&A volume (Mergermarket: M&A Highlights 2025). Buyers who shook hands on deals last year may now be left facing an unexpected and substantial loss in value of their once-coveted target. Against the backdrop of the dramatic rise in M&A disputes, this article reviews some of the key practical issues which parties facing arbitration should address at an early stage to ensure they are on the best footing in a post-closing dispute.

The rise in M&A disputes

Global deal volume hit USD 4.8 trillion in 2025, and reports from Q1 2026 suggest that dealmaking is expected to continue in a "cautious but steady" manner despite ongoing uncertainty about the consequences of global conflicts (Mergermarket: M&A Highlights 1Q26). 80 per cent of those surveyed in BRG's 2025 M&A Disputes Report said that the number of M&A disputes their firms worked on had risen in 2025, and around two thirds expected dispute volume to increase over the course of 2026.

With increased M&A activity comes the potential for more M&A disputes. In particular, increased activity in growth areas such as Artificial Intelligence can contribute to a rise in disputes, with deals navigating untested or conflicting regulatory frameworks.

But perhaps the most obvious driver of increased M&A disputes is geopolitical volatility and market turbulence. Buyer's remorse is all-too-likely in a world where the value of assets can shift drastically post-signing, and buyers may look for remedies under their deal terms if assets see significant and unanticipated decreases in value.

Arbitration as a leading mechanism to resolve M&A disputes

International arbitration continues to be a popular mechanism in sale and purchase agreements, particularly for large, cross-border deals (2025 International Arbitration Survey). This is typically due to the significant advantages of arbitration in the context of complex, international transactions, such as the availability of jurisdiction-neutral seats, the cross-border enforcement of awards and the confidentiality and procedural flexibility available through arbitration. However, M&A buyers and sellers contemplating arbitration should be aware of some common practical challenges they might face, and how these can be managed. Some of these challenges arise due to the nature of an M&A transaction and some are inherent in the international and consent-based nature of arbitration. While steps can be taken at the start of an arbitration process, it is helpful for parties to be aware of these issues when negotiating the transaction documents and to seek to make provision for them in anticipation of a future dispute.

Practical challenges in M&A arbitration and early arbitration strategy

Documents: Access, preservation and privilege

Practical difficulties in relation to the control and preservation of relevant documents often arise in international M&A arbitration.

For example, sellers commonly face the difficulty of no longer having access to the documents relevant to a dispute, having sold the target whose servers contain the potentially relevant documents. Without access to documents, it can be difficult to bring or defend a claim. In anticipation of a dispute potentially arising in future, sellers should seek to address in the transaction documents as far as possible what, if any, access to these documents they will continue to have after completion.

Rules relating to the preservation of evidence differ across jurisdictions and can therefore give rise to uncertainty in cross-border disputes. The IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Commercial Arbitration 2020, widely accepted as best practice by arbitral tribunals, recommend early consultation between the parties and with the tribunal on questions of evidence, but this advice is often overlooked. Parties should consider their approaches to the preservation of documents as early as possible, not least as negative inferences can be drawn by a tribunal if relevant documents have been destroyed. While there is no overarching obligation in arbitration to implement a "litigation hold", parties should consider taking early advice on what evidence must be preserved.

Privilege is commonly a contentious issue in international arbitration, as privilege rules vary between jurisdictions, and, in the absence of agreement between parties, tribunals generally have broad discretion to determine the approach they deem appropriate. Tribunals often approach the task by looking at different available tests including the “connecting factor” test, which is based on the most salient connection to the privileged situation and a relevant law (for example, the law of the place of arbitration; the contract; or where the document was created/exchanged/stored); and the ‘most-favoured nation’ approach, which requires choosing the most protective privilege rules among those potentially applicable.

It is sensible to assess the approach to privilege in all potentially applicable jurisdictions as early as possible in the context of a potential dispute. Parties should remain vigilant as documentary evidence can continue to be created as a dispute progresses. However, even before a dispute is contemplated, internal communications during the due diligence and information gathering phases may become relevant to a later dispute and will not necessarily be privileged. It is therefore sensible to bear in mind the potential for a dispute post-closing when negotiating the deal itself so that steps are taken to limit sensitive communications to what is necessary and to ensure that recipients of any such communications are limited.

Similarly, interviews with personnel, especially those who may be witnesses in the arbitration, should also be treated with caution from a privilege perspective, with thought given to the question of who conducts interviews and stores or handles interview notes to ensure privilege is maintained.

Parties can also mitigate the uncertainty around privilege by seeking to agree an approach to privilege at the outset of an arbitration (where agreement is possible).

Witnesses

Parties should be aware that the approach to witness evidence in arbitration may differ significantly from the rules and processes in their national courts and should seek advice at an early stage of the dispute. For example, arbitral rules may take a broader approach about who can give witness evidence on behalf of a commercial party and who can interview witnesses than the court rules in some civil law jurisdictions. Parties will want to avoid being surprised by a witness for the other side and/or the scope of their testimony.

Where a target company has been acquired, both buyers and sellers will need to consider access to the target’s employees who have relevant knowledge of events leading to the dispute. Key personnel may have left as part of the transaction and/or be reluctant to give evidence (particularly where remaining employees are being asked to give evidence which could be adverse to their new employer or parent company). Identifying witnesses at an early stage enables parties to assess the strength of their case. Parties should consider how best to approach potential witnesses and should not assume it is possible to compel witnesses to participate in an arbitration.

As with access to documents, when negotiating the transaction, sellers should consider what access to target employees they may require after completion, for the purposes of obtaining evidence.

Conclusion

Arbitration retains its status as a highly popular mechanism for the resolution of large, cross-border commercial disputes, including M&A disputes. Although arbitration proceedings have the benefit of flexibility, parties should give early thought to a number of practical issues, particularly given the breadth of tribunals' discretion in areas such as privilege. In a time of an increasing risk of buyer's remorse, early consideration of such issues in anticipated M&A disputes is key to ensuring that parties are on the best possible footing from the outset.

Issue 24

  • content-type:insights/publication
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/hubs/international-arbitration-report/issue-24
card-grid-item, aem-sourced
International arbitration report
/content/nrf-eds/en-gb/insights/topics/international-arbitration-report-hub

Contact