Trustees can start preparing their  Virgin Media  fix now, says the Pensions Regulator. If your pension scheme has potentially invalid historic changes, it’s time to get your advisers doing the groundwork. That way you can get actuarial clearance as soon as the Pension Schemes Bill is passed, and get rid of this problem.

Why the Virgin Media fix is needed: A reminder

The Court of Appeal in the Virgin Media case confirmed that, for amendments made between 1997 and 2016, contracted-out defined benefit schemes needed a written confirmation from the scheme actuary. The actuary had to confirm, before the change was made, that the change had been considered and that the statutory reference scheme test would continue to be met after the amendment.

Absent that confirmation, amendments could be invalid. For more detail on the case, see our digest of the judgment here.

Actuarial confirmation to validate past rule amendments

The Pension Schemes Bill introduces a legislative remedy of an actuarial confirmation and the FRC guidance sets out the steps actuarial advisers will have to follow – see our previous briefing on the statutory fix and the FRC guidance here.

Using the statutory fix, trustees will be able to get a retrospective confirmation of compliance from the scheme’s appointed actuary to clear any potential invalidity of previous rule amendments. To give that confirmation, the Bill would require the actuary to be satisfied that it is  “reasonable to conclude”  that the change would not have stopped the scheme from  “continuing to satisfy”  the reference scheme test in place at the time of the amendment.

TPR expects trustees to prepare now

The Pensions Regulator has now issued guidance focusing on trustees’ roles and responsibilities and the practical steps trustees should be taking now. It usefully brings together existing themes and provides trustees with some practical tips about seeking retrospective confirmations. It also reinforces the need for good governance, clear decision making and proper record keeping as trustees prepare to use the remediation power.

The section of the Pension Schemes Bill covering the statutory fix is now unlikely to change again before the Bill is passed, so we can be confident on the process. Between the Bill, the FRC guidance and TPR’s guidance, there is now enough detail to identify which amendments may be in scope and to decide what action, if any, to take.

Checklist for trustees

Trustees should use the checklist below to get ahead.

  • Do you already know which amendments to your scheme rules should have had, but did not have, actuarial confirmation? It may not always be clear but we can help here.
  • What information do you already have for those amendments and what further information might reasonably be needed? The investigation doesn’t have to be exhaustive, but the more information you have, the easier it will be to get the confirmation. Again, we can help you assess the need and work with your scheme actuary.
  • Who might have the information? Check with the scheme administrator, scheme sponsor and your advisers.
  • What’s the best way forward to get any additional information that might require more extensive investigation?
  • Prepare clear instructions for the scheme actuary, including scope, approach and timing.
  • How should decisions and discussions in relation to the actuarial confirmations be recorded and retained to ensure a clear audit trail?
  • Do you have any amendments that can’t be cleared? The actuarial confirmation only works if the scheme actuary agrees the change was caught by Virgin Media, and that may not always be clear. Your scheme actuary will need to work with us to identify and resolve any problems.
  • Do members have to be told about the process? It will depend on what comes out of the investigation and whether any benefit adjustments are required, but you may want to think about adding something to the next newsletter.

The aim is to get enough information to your scheme actuary to allow them to assess whether they can give you the necessary confirmation for each of your historic changes. The FRC’s guidance for actuaries who are asked to provide this retrospective confirmation is particularly helpful. It encourages actuaries to take a practical and proportionate approach. For our more detailed overview of the FRC guidance, see here, but as a reminder the key principles are that:

  • Actuaries do not need certainty to reach a conclusion.
  • Actuaries only need sufficient, not complete, evidence and can make assumptions and presumptions.
  • The presumption is that the contracting-out reference scheme test was satisfied immediately before the potentially invalid amendment took effect.

Please get in touch if you have questions about your scheme’s exposure to the Virgin Media problem, the statutory fix, the scope to resolve affected amendments or the steps to be taking now. You may find arranging a short trustee training session would be helpful in supporting early decision making and preparation. Please contact your usual NRF adviser if we can help you with this.

Contact