Blog 2 Product Recalls under the General Product Safety Regulation: New Guidance of the European Commission Which companies are required to carry out a product recall and what remedies must be offered?

Introduction

In recent weeks, there has been a notable surge in product recalls across the European Union (EU) underscoring the critical importance of understanding and complying with the new regulatory framework. Moreover, on 19 November 2025, the European Commission published landmark guidance on the application of the EU General Product Safety Regulation (GPSR) providing essential clarity on how companies are expected to handle product recalls in practice.

The GPSR has been inforce since 13 December 2024 and sets harmonised requirements for companies handling product recalls across all EU Member States. Under this framework, product recalls are no longer a purely operational or technical exercise. They require clear governance, early legal and compliance involvement, effective consumer communication, and the ability to deliver appropriate remedies—often across multiple markets and under the direct supervision of national authorities. In practice, this makes product recalls a board-level risk.

Practical takeaway: boards and senior management should ensure that they understand the GPSR framework and the Commission’s expectations, and that their organisations are prepared—procedurally and operationally—to manage a product recall effectively before one becomes unavoidable.

This blog article builds on our earlier piece, “New EU Product Recall Requirements under the General Product Safety Regulation: What Do Companies Need to Know” (link), which examined the scope of the GPSR and when recall obligations may arise.

This blog moves from framework to execution, addressing which companies are required to carry out a product recall under the GPSR and the remedies which must be offered.

Which companies are required to carry out a product recall?

The text of the GPSR is very clear: dangerous products placed on the EU market should be withdrawn or recalled. The GPSR requires manufacturers, importers and distributors to carry out a product withdrawal or recall but encourages all market players to make customers aware of product withdrawals and recalls.

The GPSR differentiates between two main categories of businesses:1

• Economic operators such as manufacturers, authorised representatives, importers, distributors and service providers.

• Providers of online marketplaces, which are defined as providers of intermediary services using an online interface which allows consumers to conclude distance contracts with traders for the sale of products.2

Each business category has different obligations under the GPSR. The European Commission has, in their guidelines, has  clarified that the company’s profile is not decisive to determine a company’s business category but the business category is determined by the services a company provides for a given product.3 Moreover, a company can fall into multiple business categories under the GPSR.4  For example, an online marketplace that lists third party products is a provider of an online marketplace for those products, but if it also sells private-label products on the same site, it is a manufacturer for those products.5 Likewise, a company that resells goods purchased from a manufacturer is a distributor for those goods, but if it rebrands some of the goods under its own name, it becomes a manufacturer for those rebranded items.6

The European Commission therefore recommends that companies carefully review their role in all products they handle in order to determine their business category – or categories – for the relevant products.7  Companies that fall in multiple business categories must comply with multiple sets of obligations simultaneously.8 To assist companies in understanding their main obligations under the GPSR, the European Commission has included in their guidelines checklists for manufacturers, authorised representatives, importers, distributors, service providers and providers of online marketplaces (link).

Which remedies should companies offer in a product recall?

When a product is recalled, the GPSR requires that consumers are offered effective, cost-free and timely remedies.9  In that regard, economic operators must offer consumers, as a minimum, the choice between two of the following options: repair (in case the safety of the repaired product can be ensured), replacement or adequate refund.10 As an exception, economic operators may offer only one remedy when other remedies would be impossible or would create disproportionate costs on the economic operators.11

In their guidelines, the European Commission elaborates as follows:12

  1. Remedies should be cost-free. Therefore, a consumer should not bear the costs of shipping or returning the product.
  2. When a company does not complete the repair or replacement within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience to a consumer, that consumer is entitled to a full refund.
  3. Companies can ask consumers to repair the product themselves as long as (i) consumers can do that easily and safely, (ii) this remedy is clearly described in the recall notice, (iii) clear instructions are given and (iv) free replacements parts or software updates are provided. Disposal of the dangerous product can be included in the instructions as long as such disposal is easy and safe. Disposal is, for instance, not allowed if the product could catch fire after disposal.

Furthermore, the European Commission explains the link between the GPSR and Directives (EU) 2019/770 and (EU) 2019/771. These Directives set out contractual remedies when products are not in conformity with the relevant contract with the consumer.13  The European Commission states that consumers can choose freely between remedies provided in a product recall or provided because of non-conformity with a contract: However:14

  • When a remedy has been provided because of a product recall, consumers cannot claim a remedy for non-conformity under the contract because the product was dangerous.
  • Once consumers have been provided with a contractual remedy, they cannot claim a remedy under the GPSR.
  • However, if a remedy has been provided to a consumer following a product recall for a dangerous product but other requirements for conformity are also not fulfilled, the seller will remain liable for the remaining non-conformities.

To close, the practical message for companies is straightforward: Companies should understand their GPSR profile on a product-by-product basis. Confirm the company’s role (or multiple roles) for each product it handles and align recall processes with the corresponding obligations for manufacturers, importers, distributors, service providers, or online marketplace operators.

The NRF team supports organisations both in pre-recall preparedness—including governance design, recall playbooks, and escalation frameworks—and in the management of live product recalls and related crisis situations, working closely with legal, compliance, communications, quality assurance and operations teams. We regularly assist boards and General Counsel in navigating regulatory expectations, engaging with authorities, and managing risk during high-impact product safety events.

If you would like to discuss how the GPSR guidance applies to your organisation, or how to strengthen your readiness for a potential product recall, we would be pleased to engage.

This content is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Every product recall presents unique challenges and requires a tailored approach based on the specific circumstances, regulatory requirements, and risks involved. Companies should seek guidance from experienced professionals to ensure an effective recall strategy and compliance with applicable laws.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Please see Guidelines on the application of the EU general product safety legislative framework by businesses.pdf (“Guidelines”), p. 3.

  2. 2

    Regulation (EU) 2023/988 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 May 2023 on general product safety, amending Regulation (EU) No 1025/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council and Directive (EU) 2020/1828 of the European Parliament and the Council, and repealing Directive 2001/95/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council and Council Directive 87/357/EEC (“GPSR”), Article 3 (14).

  3. 3

    Guidelines, p. 11.

  4. 4

    Guidelines, p. 11.

  5. 5

    Guidelines, p. 11

  6. 6

    Guidelines, p. 11.

  7. 7

    Guidelines, p. 11

  8. 8

    Guidelines, p. 11.

  9. 9

    GPSR, Article 37 (1).

  10. 10

    GPSR, Article 37 (2).

  11. 11

    GPSR, Article 37 (2).

  12. 12

    Guidelines, p. 46.

  13. 13

    Guidelines, p. 47.

  14. 14

    Guidelines, p. 47.

Contact