The High Court has refused an administrator’s application to strike out nearly 4,000 data protection claims arising from the 2023 cyber breach that exposed personal data, including that of pension scheme members. The claimants allege the administrator breached the UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018.
The administrator argued the claims were not brought in the right way because the claimant firm asked leading questions and filed almost identical pleadings that overstated or invented claims of distress.
The Court rejected this. It stressed the difference between pleadings, which lawyers draft and are therefore likely to be similar, and witness statements, which must reflect each claimant’s own account. It found the shared form of the pleadings did not amount to an abuse of process.
The administrator has already accepted that it breached some GDPR security obligations and has agreed a reduced ICO fine. It will be interesting to see the impact this has when / if this proceeds to trial.