The Pensions Regulator’s (TPR) Determinations Panel has ordered that the assets of a scheme must vest in the independent trustee under section 9 of the Pensions Act 1995.
TPR had already stepped in to appoint an independent trustee after finding serious gaps in the scheme’s governance: the scheme did not have the required number of trustees, and no trustee had the necessary knowledge and understanding without a conflict of interest.
The independent trustee took charge, but the scheme’s assets did not pass to it on appointment because only the Determinations Panel can make an order vesting a scheme’s assets.
After being appointed, the independent trustee met constant barriers when trying to work out what assets the scheme held and transfer these assets into its ownership. The TPR case team therefore referred the matter to the Determinations Panel, which ordered that all of the scheme’s assets vest in the independent trustee.
Comment
This decision shows that TPR will act where trustee knowledge and experience are not strong enough to run a scheme well.
It also highlights the practical limitations created by the legislative split between TPR’s power to appoint an independent trustee and the Determination Panel’s exclusive power to vest assets in a trustee. This split can delay a clean handover of control, as it did here.