On 28 September 2025, the New Towns Taskforce published its report recommending the short-listing of 12 new towns. These are:
- Tempsford in Central Bedfordshire
- Chase Park and Crews Hill in Enfield
- Leeds South Bank
- Adlington in Cheshire East
- A corridor development in South Gloucestershire across Brabazon and the West Innovation Arc
- Heyford Park in Cherwell
- An inner-city development in Manchester, Victoria North
- Marlcombe in East Devon,
- A 'renewed town' in Milton Keynes
- Plymouth evolving Britain’s Ocean City
- Thamesmead in Greenwich
- Worcestershire Parkway in Wychavon.
The government’s response was released simultaneously. It stated that the government would 'commence ' a strategic environmental assessment (SEA) the same day, and if required, an appropriate assessment (AA) under the Habitat Regulations would also be undertaken. Whether the SEA had already been scoped is unclear. It is assumed that each of the 12 proposals will have its own SEA / AA given the very different characteristics of the 12 short-listed sites. Some of the sites are green field or green belt, whereas others involve urban regeneration. It is difficult to see how a single SEA covering all 12 sites could otherwise, in the government’s words, “support final decisions on precisely which locations we take forward” given the differing site characteristics. It may open the door to judicial review (JR) challenge if designation decisions are based on a single high-level SEA.
The SEA(s)/AAs will be the subject of public consultation, although it is unclear precisely when, and how long the consultation period will be. The government has stated that it will “publish the draft proposals and final SEA for consultation early next year”. As a matter of law, the consultation responses will need to be taken into account before any sites are designated. The government has also advised that no final decisions will be made on new towns to be designated until the SEA(s) conclude, and it is understood that this is likely to be in Spring 2026. If the SEA(s) only commenced on 28 September 2025 and if decisions will be made in Spring 2026, it will be interesting to see how (in particular) the ecology baseline assessment(s) can have been robustly assessed given that (for example) bat emergence surveys are out of season between October and April, great crested newts eDNA surveys are out of season July to mid-April and terrestrial invertebrate surveys are out of season October to April. For other species, such as hazel dormice, although the survey period is April to November, there may be insufficient data recorded for reliable baseline assessments to be obtained. Again, this creates the risk of JR challenge if designation decisions are based on incomplete or sub-optimal data.
The government also stated that “all promising sites and reasonable alternatives [will be] assessed and considered through the SEA process”. Given that a number of local authorities already have a demonstrable 5 year housing land supply, for example the Greater Manchester Combined Authority has 6.2 years to March 2029, it will be interesting to understand if the “reasonable alternatives” to delivery of the tens of thousands of homes proposed by each new town will consider whether the housing need for an area is already identified and resourced in some areas. The designation of a new town for a significant number of homes in an area with no demonstrable need is likely to be contentious and could arguably be a ground of JR challenge if the “reasonable alternatives” have not been properly assessed.
It is also understood that ministers and officials will now work with local partners to “develop detailed proposals”. Given the current lack of detailed information about some of the new town proposals, it is expected that this information will also be publicly available, presumably this is the “draft proposals” referred to above, to inform the SEA(s).
The House of Lords Built Environment Committee (HoLBEC) on 31 October 2025, launched the second module of its inquiry into new towns and expanded settlements. The press release advised that “Over a series of short, targeted modules, the Committee aims to discover whether new towns and expanded settlements are an effective means of delivering housing and, if so, how to ensure they are successful.” It is unclear how any report produced by HoLBEC as an output from its modules will inform the government’s decision on new town designations. It seems logical that these would be taken into account, but there is no confirmation of this. This also has the potential to create risk in the designation process if HoLBEC’s modules and reports are directly relevant to designation decisions and yet are incomplete or not taken into account before designation decisions are made.
It is also unclear what, if any, criteria the government will use when choosing new town proposals, or ranking these, and if any criteria will be weighted. For example, is the level of government financial support for delivery a criterion that will be used to assess new towns to be designated, and if so, will this be given greater weight than say ecological harm, or harm to the green belt?
In the reported minutes of a meeting held on 11 November 2025 on the work of MHCLG Dame Sarah Healey advised:
“I will be chairing a new towns board with senior representatives from other Government Departments […] Every Department has identified one senior official who is the link point on new towns ….”.
At this stage, the remit of the board remains unclear. For example, if it will be responsible for the designations, and who the members of the board will be.
It is noted that local community groups are beginning to emerge entitled “stop xx new town” or similar, and certainly in the case of “Stop Adlington New Town” they are well prepared, well organised, and have the support of a coalition of 5 Town and Parish Councils called The Adlington New Town Task and Finish Group, which Norton Rose Fulbright has recently accepted an instruction to represent.
The planning team, including Sarah Fitzpatrick Head of Planning expect to be busy reviewing the “draft proposals and final SEA” in 2026, as well as assisting the Adlington New Town Task and Finish Group with its representations. If other “stop xx new town” groups, affected landowners, local authorities, or Town and Parish Councils need representation or a free informal and initial discussion on how Norton Rose Fulbright can support them in navigating the current legal landscape, new town proposals and how these could affect existing communities, and would like a free, no obligation, initial discussion to see how Norton Rose Fulbright can assist with new town proposals affecting their areas, then please contact Sarah Fitzpatrick on the details below.