Against a background of regulatory focus on individual accountability and enforcement outcomes involving individuals, this update for senior managers highlights current enforcement hot topics and lessons learned from recent enforcement cases to help them to avoid the common pitfalls, reduce personal risk and stay out of the regulatory spotlight. More detail on takeaways from Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and Prudential Regulation Authority cases is available in our Notices in a nutshell series.

  1. Updating the Board and others: Failure to report all material information to the Board and other internal committees is a common cause of issues going undetected and oversight being impeded. Those who had relevant information that was not shared may be singled out for regulatory criticism. Accordingly, it is important for senior managers to be able to demonstrate that the relevant internal stakeholders were kept updated with accurate data and corporate decisions made on a fully informed basis. To do so effectively, senior managers must maintain adequate oversight of their business areas and ensure that their teams provide them with sufficient management information to enable comprehensive reporting upwards. The Board should also keep in mind any regulatory reporting obligations and it is helpful for this to be built into the governance framework, such as through a rolling agenda item to prompt regular reflection.

  2. Targets: Whilst it may be appropriate to set challenging targets for the team, the FCA expects these to be supported by a robust control framework to mitigate the risks associated with the pressure on individuals to meet targets. Senior managers should consider the relevant risks and whether the firm has adequate safeguards in place to prevent and detect any inappropriate conduct. They must also be alert to any indication of issues arising and consider taking steps to address concerns. Recent FCA enforcement action has identified in particular: (i) significant pressure to meet targets; and (ii) a failure to recalibrate these in the face of evidence that performance was falling behind, which increased the risk of non-compliant behaviour.

  3. Staying informed about artificial intelligence (AI) & other new technology: The pace of technological change is relentless, with many firms exploring the use of AI and implementing new technologies. This presents a number of governance challenges, including in terms of ensuring deployments are adequately tested and kept under review with sufficient risk mitigation measures in place. Senior managers are expected to stay sufficiently informed so that they can provide the necessary degree of challenge and oversight. They should ensure that any deployments of new technologies are subject to adequate pre-implementation due diligence and testing, as well as ongoing monitoring. Individuals may wish to upskill themselves and their teams through training and recruitment and involvement in industry initiatives and knowledge sharing. The FCA has emphasised that ‘explainability’ is key for the safe adoption of AI, so where explanations of new models or their related risks are insufficiently clear, senior management should press for further clarification. Concerns should be documented and tracked to evidence the senior manager took reasonable steps. One recent case involved FCA criticism over a lack of understanding internally in relation to risk assessment software following staff departures and lack of internal records.

  4. Spotting the warning signs: Regulatory enforcement decisions often point to warning signs and opportunities to take action that were missed or went unnoticed or unheeded by senior managers. This can often feel like the benefit of hindsight to those who were involved at the relevant time with wide remits and busy workloads. Recent cases suggest that indicators may include:

    1. Discrepancies between different reports or inconsistent management information: Senior managers need to avoid being overly focused on one set of data (perhaps showing the most favourable picture) and ignoring other data which suggests something different. Making enquiries into discrepancies and getting to the bottom of any issues may be important in meeting regulatory expectations.
    2. Internal and external escalations: It is often the case that the regulator identifies concerns that were raised at various points by staff across one or more of the three lines of defence and/ or that external advisers provided input that was not actioned. Senior managers should therefore take steps to ensure that careful consideration is given to escalations that may, in retrospect, be treated by the regulator as ‘warning signs’ and that any actions are methodically tracked with a clear plan for implementation that is kept under review and appropriately resourced to avoid undue delay and balls being dropped.

    Managers should also take steps to ensure that staff understand escalation routes and how to recognise red flags or situations that need to be reported upwards and that practicalities are considered, such as updating contact numbers and access to out of hours crisis procedures.

  5. Record-keeping: In the event of an investigation, queries will inevitably arise around matters such as what information was available to individuals, their participation in the governance process and what actions they personally took. Not only can these become difficult to answer when clear contemporaneous records have not been kept but lack of documentation may itself become a failing for which individuals are held accountable. Senior managers have an important role to play, and a personal interest, in ensuring their firm’s record keeping is adequate including in terms of meeting minutes, action plans, decision trackers (including factors considered and rationale) and central filing.

  6. Non-financial misconduct: With the FCA’s new rule for non-banks and the guidance for all firms coming into effect in September 2026, there is a clear focus on non-financial misconduct, with at least one high profile case coming to the Upper Tribunal in March involving concerns regarding a lack of adherence to good governance. Senior managers need to be conscious not only of ensuring their own conduct does not amount to bullying, harassment or similar misbehaviour but also of their responsibility to take steps to prevent, and react appropriately to, misconduct by others. Individuals should understand and comply with their firm’s policies (updated to reflect the FCA’s guidance), complete any training being rolled out before September and ensure reporting channels, investigations and sanctions are effective and consistently applied, recognising implications for fitness and propriety.

  7. Check and challenge: Being a senior manager carries a degree of cabinet responsibility and the regulator’s ability to hold individuals responsible for being ‘knowingly concerned’ in a breach by their firm means that individuals cannot assume that misconduct by others is not their problem. Senior managers need to ensure they personally understand the basis for collective decisions and challenge others where appropriate on matters such as steps taken to verify information or seek external assurance. If they have concerns, these should be followed up as doing nothing could later be interpreted as turning a blind eye and being reckless.

  8. Conflicts: Identifying personal and other firm-related conflicts of interest can sometimes be harder than it sounds particularly when situations evolve and there is no trigger for considering any conflict issues. Also identifying the conflict is only the first step - further action will be needed to manage the conflict taking into account any relevant internal policies. Individuals may need to recuse themselves and ensure that clear records are maintained around the decision-making process.

  9. D&O Insurance: Enforcement cases where a number of senior individuals incur legal fees over a long period can quickly make a significant dent in the insurance cover available. Depending on the policy, it may be that those investigated first erode cover to the point where little is left for subsequent claimants. Senior managers may wish to ensure they understand the extent to which their firm has adequate protection and/ or will provide alternative indemnities in cases where these are needed.

  10. Independent advice: Senior managers should be ready to seek independent advice on complex matters and ensure that any advisers are properly instructed with access to all relevant information and that this advice is adequately considered and implemented where appropriate.

Contact