Introduction

The English High Court has handed down two important decisions for insolvency practitioners looking to contractually limit their liability – as well as for shareholders looking to pursue a claim against an office-holder. The cases concern members’ voluntary liquidations (MVLs), which are a form of solvent liquidation but where the liquidation can be converted to an insolvent one, where the insolvency practitioners had attempted contractually to limit - or exclude - their liability in their pre-appointment engagement letters. Both judges were clear that the liquidators could not contractually limit their personal liability, albeit their reasoning was somewhat novel and did not apply to the liquidators’ firms. Although the cases were before the High Court of England and Wales, it will be interesting to see if the decisions have wider cross-border relevance to other jurisdictions having similar office-holders.

Pagden v Fry [2025] EWHC 2316 (Ch)

The question before the court in Pagden v Fry was: “Can liquidators or their firms dealing with a members’ voluntary liquidation limit their liability?”

The judge, Mr Justice Thompsell, answered that question by affirming that limitation clauses in engagement letters may protect the liquidator’s firm and certain employees, but are ineffective against liquidators themselves. Interestingly, the judge based his reasoning on the statutory trust that arises in liquidations (as opposed to English administrations, where the assets do not vest in the insolvency practitioner).

The facts

The court’s preliminary ruling arose from lengthy litigation involving alleged breach of duty claims. Three solvent companies (the Companies) were wound up by MVLs and later restored to the register of companies so that new liquidators could pursue negligence claims against the former liquidators (the Former Liquidators) and their firm (the Firm) (together, the Defendants). Upon restoration, new liquidators were appointed and proceedings were issued alleging breaches of fiduciary and statutory duty in connection with the sale of the Companies’ assets.

Each engagement letter between the Firm and the Companies (which were entered into prior to the appointment of the Former Liquidators and the Companies being placed into liquidation) contained a limitation clause which purported to cap the Firm’s exposure and the liabilities of persons associated with it at £1 million per Company. This included any liability of the Former Liquidators. The Defendants argued that this clause protected both the Firm and the Former Liquidators against post-appointment claims.

The parties' submissions

The new liquidators argued that:

  1. There is no statutory provision in English law permitting the limitation of an office-holder’s liability;
  2. Allowing members or directors to limit the office-holder’s liability would deprive future claimants of remedies;
  3. It is a well-established principle in English law that parties cannot contract out of insolvency legislation (as held in Belmont Park Investments Pty Ltd v BNY Corporate Trustee Services Ltd [2012]); and
  4. The limitation of liability clause was void under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.This legislation restricts liability provisions in commercial contracts. Ultimately this particular issue was left undecided and will need to be determined subsequently.

In response, the Former Liquidators argued that:

  1. English law does not expressly prevent contractual limitation (arguably rooted in the traditional common law approach); and
  2. Parliament could have legislated to prohibit such practices, but it chose not to.

The decision: Can liquidators contract out of their statutory duties?

The judge was clear that liquidators cannot limit their personal liability in engagement letters. However, instead of basing the decision on public policy and the statutory duties and liabilities of a liquidator, the judge’s reasoning was rooted in the statutory trust that arises in liquidations and bankruptcies.

Essentially the logic was that liquidators hold assets on statutory trust and owe fiduciary duties, under the Insolvency Act 1986. The statutory trust is concerned with administering assets according to statute – but the assets are not held on trust for the company’s creditors or shareholders. The liquidator’s obligations are to administer the statutory trust and therefore any attempt to cap a liquidator’s liability is ineffective. The judge observed that the statutory trust (and therefore presumably the judge’s reasoning) does not apply to insolvency practitioners acting as administrators. This is because administrators are managers and agents of the company and no statutory trust is imposed.

What about the Former Liquidators’ Firm?

The Court distinguished the personal liability of the liquidators from the contractual liability of their firm.

Therefore: firms may contractually limit liability for services provided under engagement letters, so long as those services do not involve the statutory functions of liquidators in office. The contractual limitations may extend also to other employees of the Firm, provided their services are within the scope of the engagement letter.

Therefore: firms may contractually limit liability for services provided under engagement letters, so long as those services do not involve the statutory functions of liquidators in office. The contractual limitations may extend also to other employees of the Firm, provided their services are within the scope of the engagement letter.

Re Cedar Securities Limited (in liquidation) [2025] EWHC 2760 (Ch)

This case followed Pagden v Fry, with a similar set of facts but a slightly different question. In Re Cedar Securities, the court was asked to decide whether liquidators could exclude their liability altogether.

In this case, the engagement letter was dated September 22, 2016 and liquidators were appointed on September 29, 2016. The general terms and conditions accompanying the engagement letter contained the following clause:

“Our liability to you is limited to losses, damages, costs and expenses caused by our negligence or wilful default…You have agreed that you will not bring any claim in connection with services we provide to you against any of our partners or employees personally…”

The subsequently appointed replacement liquidators brought a claim against the former liquidators based on breach of fiduciary duties and obligations resulting from the late filing of a corporation tax return, 3 years after the former liquidators’ appointment. The former liquidators argued the exclusion of liability clause protected them from such claims.

The judge, Master Marsh, endorsed the statutory trust analysis in Pagden v Fry and held that the terms and conditions were not effective to exclude the liquidators’ liability. His reasoning was that in this context there was no meaningful difference between an exclusion of liability clause and a limitation of liability clause. Therefore, he was bound by – and in agreement with – the decision in Pagden v Fry.

Practical takeaways for insolvency practitioners

  1. Draft Engagement Letters carefully

Limitations on liability should differentiate between services provided by the firm and the statutory duties owed by office-holders.

  1. Understand fiduciary obligation

    Limitations on liability should differentiate between services provided by the firm and the statutory duties owed by office-holders.

  2. Obtain adequate insurance

    Personal liability for liquidators is uncapped. Obtaining appropriate professional indemnity insurance is therefore essential.

  1. Prepare for scrutiny under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 (“UCTA”)

Any firm-level limitation clause may be tested for reasonableness under UCTA.

  1. Apply for Court Directions Where Necessary

The judge in Pagden v Fry confirmed that liquidators can seek to mitigate risk by applying for court directions under s.112 of the Insolvency Act 1986.

Is change afoot?

The questions at the heart of these cases arise from a peculiarity of the law where insolvency practitioners as individuals – rather than their firms – are regulated and authorised to take appointments. Given the array of roles and responsibilities that insolvency practitioners often face, this could be seen as a somewhat out of date concept. The UK Government previously announced its intention to reform the law in this area, highlighting the disconnect between liability of individual insolvency practitioners and the way in which modern insolvencies are run. The proposals to reform the law would extend liability to the insolvency practitioner’s firm, although currently no draft legislation is tabled.

In the meantime, these two High Court decisions, unless successfully appealed, emphasise the nature of a liquidator’s role: they are fiduciaries operating under a statutory trust and therefore unable to contract out of - or limit – their personal liability in performing those functions.

The authors gratefully acknowledge the assistance of Foluke Onafowokan, a senior associate in our London office, for her invaluable assistance in preparing this article.

Contact