Introduction

Since its introduction some five years ago, the UK restructuring plan under Part 26A of the Companies Act 2006 has become the most widely used imported restructuring tool in continental Europe. Introduced in 2020, it entered the global restructuring stage at a time when EU Member States were still developing their own preventive restructuring frameworks, as mandated by the 2019 EU Restructuring Directive. Foreign companies are frequently drawn to the flexibility of the scheme as well as the highly professionalised judicial apparatus, which – building on decades of case law relating to the closely related Part 26 scheme of arrangement – has enabled swift and effective debt restructurings, including through the new cross-class cram-down mechanism.

But will a UK restructuring plan be recognised in continental Europe by the courts of EU Member States? So far, EU courts have not been required to answer that question.

The UK’s exit from the European Union has not prevented EU companies from benefitting from the restructuring plan. The “sufficient connection” test required by English courts to assume jurisdiction to sanction a scheme is a significantly lower entry barrier than the Centre of Main Interests (COMI) test applicable within the EU. However, without the benefits of mutual recognition afforded by the European Insolvency Regulation (EIR) in relation the question of recognition arises in EU Member States. Each Member State has their own rules on recognition.

As far as Germany is concerned, there are no explicit provisions governing the recognition of foreign pre-insolvency proceedings that permit the impairment of creditors’ rights without their consent. Academics and practitioners have debated intensely the basis for such recognition, but now the German court has had its say. In August 2025, a German court ruled on the issue for the first time, potentially resolving years of legal uncertainty.

Frankfurt Court says Nein

The Frankfurt Regional Court (Landgericht Frankfurt) issued a provisional judgment refusing to give effect to a restructuring plan sanctioned by the High Court of England and Wales in Project Lietzenburger Straße HoldCo S.a r.l. [2024] EWHC 563 (Ch) (Aggregate group).

The plan company is incorporated in Luxembourg and serves as the project and financing vehicle for the Berlin real estate project “FÜRST.” With the maturity of certain loans approaching, the plan company performed a COMI shift to the UK and subsequently requested the High Court to sanction its restructuring plan. Among other measures, this had the effect of extending the maturity of a German-law senior loan by two years.

Certain lenders under the senior loan - who had opposed the restructuring plan - exited the syndication and sued the plan company for repayment in the Frankfurt Regional Court. Their core argument was that the maturity extension was ineffective because the amendment is not recognised in Germany.

While the judgment does not address all of the issues that practitioners may have hoped for, the court did consider three potential routes for recognition under German law:

  • First, the court declined recognition under section 343 of the German Insolvency Code (InsO), which provides for the recognition of foreign insolvency proceedings. The court held that a restructuring plan does not qualify as an insolvency proceeding, as it targets only select financial creditors while excluding others, and is therefore not a collective proceeding for the purposes of the InsO. This aspect is particularly interesting as the English High Court has previously taken the opposite view: that a restructuring plan is an insolvency proceeding for the purposes of the EU Insolvency Regulation (Re Gategroup Guarantee Ltd [2021] EWHC 304 (Ch).
  • Second, the court refused recognition of the plan as a foreign judgment under section 328 of the German Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO). This provision requires reciprocity: recognition and enforcement of a corresponding German judgment must not face materially greater obstacles than recognition and enforcement of the foreign judgment in Germany. The court found the plan company’s expert evidence that the English courts would recognise comparable German judgments was inadmissible in this type of proceeding. The Frankfurt judgment did not address whether the old English law Rule in Gibbs1, frequently cited in this context as authority for the proposition that (in the absence of the creditor’s submission) English law governed debt can only be discharged under English law, would prevent recognition of a German StaRUG that alters the maturities of English law governed debt.
  • Third, the court found no legal basis for recognition under the pre-Judgments Regulation Brussels Convention (section 26 of the 1968 Brussels Convention on Jurisdiction and the Enforcement of Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters) as this convention has been replaced by the Brussels I Regulation and the court considered it could not assume that these historic provisions apply post-Brexit.

Not the final word

The judgment has faced significant criticism and is subject to appeal. It remains to be seen whether the Higher Regional Court Frankfurt (Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt), as the relevant appeal court, will confirm or overturn it. Notably, Professor Skauradszun, who had provided expert legal evidence at the Project Lietzenburger sanction hearing, serves as a judge at this very court. Consistent with the opinions expressed in his publications, he has openly opposed the prospect of the plan being recognised in Germany. However, this should not be taken as an indicator of the appeal’s outcome, as Professor Skauradszun will not preside over the case.

Whatever the appeal’s outcome, the final decision may ultimately rest with the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof). It is also possible that the German legislature may address the issue in the near future. The recognition of foreign restructuring proceedings outside of the European Insolvency Regulation is an issue that arguably should have been addressed in the German Corporate Stabilisation and Restructuring Act (StaRUG). The German Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection may, during its upcoming evaluation of the StaRUG, determine that this omission should be remedied, potentially prompting legislators to propose explicit recognition provisions.

Is the High Court all ears?

The uncertainties produced by the Frankfurt judgment may impact the English court’s decision to sanction future UK restructuring plans where recognition will need to be obtained in Germany. The English court will not act in vain and the likelihood of the plan achieving its purpose will be assessed on the balance of probabilities when the judge exercises their discretion to sanction a plan. The English court will only approve a scheme if there is a reasonable prospect that the scheme will be recognised in relevant jurisdictions.

This is usually determined by expert witness evidence, as was the case with the Adler plan (AGPS BondCo PLC [2023] EWHC 916 (Ch)) and the Aggregate plan. Reputable German law professors were questioned on the basis for recognition under German law. to the English court will decide, on the balance of probabilities, which evidence is more compelling and is a recurring theme in cross-border cases.

In Adler and Aggregate alike, the English court preferred the evidence of the expert witness who argued in favour of recognition in Germany and concluded that there was at least a reasonable prospect of recognition. Arguably, the fact that a German court has explicitly refused recognition based on the very provisions cited by those experts will require future plan companies to produce additional evidence and perhaps additional grounds for recognition.

Time beats triumph?

Until there is final clarity on the recognition of English restructuring plans in Germany, companies seeking a restructuring requiring recognition in Germany may be hesitant to choose a Part 26A restructuring plan. This consideration pre-dates the Frankfurt judgment and is compounded by other factors such the possibility of the plan being overturned on appeal by disgruntled creditors.

But in the context of financial distress, time is often the most important – and diminishing – resource. Time to negotiate with counterparties. Time to secure financing. Time to dispose of non-core assets. A restructuring plan that lacks recognition may still be considered successful if it provides the plan company with additional breathing space to address its financial difficulties.

The restructuring plans in Adler and Aggregate illustrate this point nicely. Neither fully achieved the effects set out in the respective plans. In Adler’s case, the High Court overturned the plan on appeal. In Aggregate, the plan was not appealed, but following the Frankfurt judgment, affected creditors in Germany arguably would not be bound by it as a matter of German law. Nevertheless, on a practical level, both plans purported extended maturity dates bought the respective corporate groups much-needed time.

This is not to say that restructuring plans may be used deliberately to decelerate creditors in asserting their rights, but to highlight how uncertainties surrounding cross-border recognition are only part of the story.

Outlook for cross-border restructurings

All criticism aside, the Frankfurt judgment on the non-recognition of the UK restructuring plan marks the Second Act in resolving the question of recognition. Although some may argue that the Frankfurt Regional Court may have given us stones instead of bread, a definitive answer is likely forthcoming: the Third Act is still to come.

The resolution of this issue will bring much-needed clarity to cross-border restructuring in Europe, providing companies and creditors alike with a firmer basis for planning and decision-making. Whether through appellate review, final judgment by the Federal Court of Justice, or legislative action, the outcome will shape the future of Part 26A restructuring plans and their continued relevance to the German restructuring market.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Antony Gibbs & Sons v La Société Industrielle et Commerciale des Métaux (25 Q.B.D. 399).

Contact