The EU Pay Transparency Directive ((EU) 2023/970) (the Directive) will significantly reshape German pay legislation. The deadline for implementation of the Directive expired on 7 June 2026, but Germany has not yet fully transposed it into national law, and implementing legislation is not expected before 2027. Employers should nevertheless not regard this interim period as a legal vacuum.
No full direct effect, but growing pressure to adapt
The Directive is founded on Article 157 TFEU, which requires Member States to ensure equal pay for women and men performing the same work or work of equal value. That principle has long been recognised as directly effective primary EU law. The Directive builds upon and gives practical effect to this obligation by introducing enhanced transparency, information, documentation and enforcement requirements.
For private-sector employers, however, not all provisions of the Directive are already directly applicable. As a general rule, directives do not impose direct obligations on private parties. It therefore remains to be seen whether, and to what extent, the Court of Justice of the European Union will take specific provisions of the Directive into account when deciding disputes between private employers and employees.
The position may differ for public-sector employers. To the extent that particular provisions of the Directive are sufficiently clear, precise and unconditional, they may, following the expiry of the implementation period, be capable of having direct effect against the State and public bodies.
Directive-conforming interpretation by the Courts during the transitional period
According to the Court of Justice of the European Union case law, national courts are required, so far as possible, to interpret domestic law in a manner consistent with EU directives to give full effect to their objectives. In practice, courts have repeatedly relied on the interpretative scope permitted by EU law to reach outcomes not readily apparent from the wording of national legislation alone. A notable example is the judgment of the German Federal Labour Court of 13 September 2022 on the recording of working time, in which the Court derived a general duty to record working time from the Occupational Health and Safety Act, despite the absence of an express statutory obligation to that effect.
Against this background, German courts may already consider certain provisions of the Pay Transparency Directive when interpreting existing national law. This may be particularly relevant in relation to the Directive’s provisions concerning the personal scope of application, the meaning of pay and the criteria for assessing work of equal value. Existing domestic rules governing the involvement of works councils (Article 7(2) PTD) and protection against retaliation (Article 25 PTD) may also acquire greater practical significance through a directive-conforming interpretation of national law.
The concept of pay and transparent remuneration systems
The most significant practical challenge arises from the requirement to maintain transparent and non-discriminatory remuneration systems. Employers will need to be able to demonstrate that their pay structures are based on objective and gender-neutral criteria.
Article 4(4) of the Directive further clarifies the long-established EU law principle of “equal pay for equal work”. German courts are already able to take these requirements into account when interpreting the German Pay Transparency Act (Entgelttransparenzgesetz – EntgTranspG) and the General Equal Treatment Act (Allgemeines Gleichbehandlungsgesetz – AGG).
Employers should therefore review their remuneration systems now to identify disparities and ensure that any pay differences can be objectively justified and appropriately documented.
Burden of proof: Poor documentation becomes a litigation risk
The burden-of-proof framework set out in section 22 AGG is likely to become greater importance in equal pay claims. Under the current regime, an employee need only establish facts giving rise to a presumption of sex discrimination. The employer must then demonstrate that the equal pay principle has not been breached.
In its landmark judgment of 23 October 2025 (ref. 8 AZR 300/24), the Federal Labour Court held that a comparison with a single higher-paid colleague of the opposite sex may establish a presumption of gender-based discrimination, provided that the work performed is the same or of equal value. The burden then shifts to the employer to rebut that presumption.
As a result, employers will face increasing difficulty in justifying pay differences unless remuneration decisions are properly documented and based on objective, gender-neutral criteria. This applies not only to base salary, but also to variable remuneration, allowances, bonuses, share schemes, benefits and occupational pension arrangements. Careful documentation of both remuneration structures and individual pay decisions will therefore become a key element of litigation risk management and defence strategy.
Likely expansion of employees’ information rights
Article 7 of the Directive provides employees, regardless of the size of the undertaking, with a right to request information about their own level of pay as well as the average pay of comparable employees, broken down by gender. Employers must generally provide this information within two months and remind employees annually of their right to request the information.
The right to information in sections 10 et seq. EntgTranspG is therefore likely to be interpreted in a manner consistent with the Directive. This could result in a broader interpretation of existing rights, particularly regarding the disclosure of comparator groups, transparency concerning the criteria used to determine pay, and the completeness and comprehensibility of employers’ responses.
By contrast, courts are less likely to expand the lower thresholds for information and reporting obligations set out in Articles 7 and 9(2) to (4) of the Directive. Article 7 gives employees information rights irrespective of the size of the workforce, while Article 9 introduces graduated reporting obligations depending on the employer’s headcount. Employers with at least 100 employees must disclose certain pay data, whereas organisations with more than 250 employees are subject to more extensive reporting obligations.
A judicial reduction of the existing national thresholds would interfere with fundamental legislative policy choices and would likely exceed the limits of interpretation. Nevertheless, employers should not assume that current thresholds will protect them against increasing transparency requirements.
Pay secrecy clauses under increasing scrutiny
Article 7(5) of the Directive generally prohibits contractual provisions that prevent employees from disclosing information about their remuneration. The rationale for preventing such pay secrecy clauses, is straightforward: where employees are unable to discuss their pay, meaningful comparison of remuneration and effective enforcement of the principle of equal pay for equal work or work of equal value become significantly more difficult.
Even before the Directive is formally implemented into German law, this policy objective may influence the Courts interpretation of existing law. As pay secrecy clauses are subject to review under section 307 of the German Civil Code, courts are more likely to examine whether such clauses place employees at an unreasonable disadvantage by hindering the identification and enforcement of equal pay claims. The greater the extent to which courts rely on the Directive as an interpretative aid, the greater the risk that broadly drafted pay confidentiality clauses will be held unenforceable.
Strengthening the position of works councils
The Pay Transparency Directive is also likely to increase the role of works councils. Under existing German law, works councils are already required, pursuant to section 80(1) of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG), to monitor compliance with statutory provisions and equal treatment principles. They also enjoy co-determination rights in matters relating to workplace pay structures under section 87(1) no. 10 BetrVG.
Employers should expect an increase in information requests, initiatives aimed at reviewing remuneration structures, and discussions concerning transparent and non-discriminatory pay systems. Employers would therefore be well advised to engage with works councils at an early stage, without prematurely conceding their legal position.
Collective bargaining agreements
Employers bound by collective bargaining agreements currently benefit from the provision under section 4(5) EntgTranspG, which states that collectively agreed remuneration arrangements are generally presumed to comply with equal pay requirements.
The Directive adopts a broader approach. Articles 4(1) and 4(4) require remuneration systems to be capable of objective review based on gender-neutral criteria. The Directive does not contain any equivalent protection for collectively agreed pay structures.
This may become particularly relevant where collective grading systems have evolved historically, are highly standardised or are insufficiently supported by analytical job-evaluation criteria. It remains unclear whether, and to what extent, the German presumption of appropriateness will withstand scrutiny under EU law.
This tension between the German legislative framework and the Directive’s broader regulatory approach is likely to place collective pay structures under increased examination, particularly where job classifications reflect historical assumptions, broad categorisations or limited analytical assessment. German courts may will seek guidance from the Court of Justice of the European Union before resolving these issues and are unlikely to automatically assume that collectively agreed remuneration systems are free from discrimination.
Provisions likely to take effect only once implementing legislation is enacted
Not all aspects of the Directive can be applied in advance through judicial interpretation. Where the Directive introduces new organisational, reporting, procedural or compliance obligations, German law often lacks a sufficient legal basis to comply with these obligations. In such cases, courts seeking to introduce those obligations would risk crossing the line into impermissible law-making.
This applies in particular to:
- new transparency requirements during the recruitment process, such as disclosing starting pay or salary ranges;
- the prohibition on asking applicants about their pay history;
- detailed reporting obligations concerning the gender pay gap;
- joint pay assessments;
- reporting obligations towards public authorities; and
- statutory thresholds, deadlines and procedural requirements.
There are strong arguments for concluding that the recruitment-related obligations under Article 5(1) cannot readily be applied to private-sector employers before national implementing legislation enters into force. To date, the German legislature has deliberately chosen not to include job applicants within the scope of the EntgTranspG, despite being fully aware of the importance of pay transparency (see Bundestag Printed Paper 18/11133, pp. 21, 49 and 76). Any attempt by the courts to apply the Directive’s requirements in full would therefore be open to significant legal challenge.
Practical take away
Even in the absence of German implementing legislation, the Directive is already having a practical impact. In particular, the principle of directive-conforming interpretation of existing law is increasing expectations regarding the transparency, consistency and documentation of pay decisions. Employers should therefore use the transitional period to review their remuneration systems against objective and gender-neutral criteria. Those who act proactively may reduce litigation and compliance risks while at the same time laying the foundations for the effective and legally compliant implementation of the forthcoming statutory requirements.