The Regulated Asset Base (RAB) model has long been a cornerstone of economic regulation in the UK. It is well established across core utility sectors such as water and energy networks, where it has provided a stable framework for attracting long-term investment while protecting consumers through regulatory oversight.
More recently, the UK government has shown itself to be increasingly willing to turn to the RAB model to support investment in large, capital-intensive infrastructure projects. Having experimented with other funding approaches, policymakers now view RAB as a credible means of lowering the cost of capital, enabling recovery of revenues during construction and sharing risk across investors, consumers, and the public sector. This shift is evident in its application to new nuclear projects, emerging sectors such as carbon capture and storage, and its potential application for heat networks in future.
However, while the RAB model is often presented as “tried and tested”, its extension into new sectors raises a range of complex economic, regulatory and legal issues. For companies and investors alike, careful consideration of these issues is critical.
Below we highlight some key themes – based on our experience across regulated sectors – that require close attention when RAB models are adapted for new contexts.
A central tension: Certainty versus flexibility
At the heart of any RAB regime lies a fundamental challenge: how to design a framework that offers sufficient legal certainty to underpin major long-term investment, while retaining enough flexibility to respond to evolving conditions over that long term.
Investors need clarity on the rules of the game, particularly on how returns will be determined and protected over time. At the same time, regulators and governments require adequate tools to adapt the regime to changing circumstances, including shifts in policy priorities or external shocks. It is neither desirable nor possible to precisely specify outcomes in a RAB model; investors need to be confident that outcomes will be fair, given they need to recover costs over long periods.
The regime also needs to ensure an appropriate apportionment and sharing of risks between consumers on the one hand, and developers and investors on the other.
Striking the right balance between these competing requirements is not straightforward. In our experience, this tension plays out in at least the following areas.
1. The overarching regulatory framework
The starting point is the design of the regulatory framework itself.
The approach is likely to be driven by the nature of the assets, including whether they involve a single, high-capex build or a more gradual capital investment programme over time, the length of the construction period, and the extent of likely user demand or utilisation risk. Cost control will also be a critical consideration. Depending on the specific capex issue, key areas of debate are likely to include the treatment of cost overruns and disallowance risk, the mechanics for assessing and validating costs, and the allocation of risk for cost increases, delays, and other construction-related impacts.
Key questions will include:
- Who is the regulator? The identity, expertise and credibility of the regulator will be central to investor confidence.
- What are its statutory duties? In particular, how are consumer protection duties balanced against wider objectives (e.g. net zero, resilience, or growth)? The role and scope of any “financeability” duty has been the subject of increasing legal scrutiny in recent times.
- What procedural safeguards apply? Consultation processes and transparency around decision-making are key to ensuring legitimacy and predictability.
- How independent is the regulator? Perceived or actual political influence can materially affect the risk profile of the regime.
The clarity and robustness of these elements will significantly influence whether a RAB framework is viewed as investible.
2. Appeal rights and dispute resolution
Appeal mechanisms are an important component of the overall risk allocation, although in the early stages of engaging on design of a regime all participants will naturally want to play down their importance.
Past practice suggests however that participants may, in time, need to rely on formal challenge routes. The available mechanisms are not always straightforward:
- Judicial review is generally limited in scope, and courts tend to defer to regulators on matters involving complex economic judgment.1
- Appeals to the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) have traditionally provided a more substantive avenue for review. The CMA has shown a willingness to engage closely with detailed questions of financeability, incentives, outputs and risk allocation.
That said, it should not be assumed that the CMA will remain the default route in all future models. The government has recently issued its consultation “Swifter and simpler competition redress, regulatory appeals and competition enforcement.” Among other things, this proposes a transfer of regulatory appeals currently heard by the CMA to the Competition Appeal Tribunal, in addition to harmonisation of the appeal standard and eligibility criteria across sectors. Such harmonisation is argued to benefit investors by removing inconsistency. The justification for shifting to a narrower, and inherently more legalistic route for challenging regulatory decisions which involve investment in critical infrastructure is less obvious. The consultation is open until 25 September 2026 with a final decision on approach to follow.
3. Scope of appealable decisions
Closely linked to appeal rights is the question of which decisions fall within the scope of challenge.
In many regimes, formal appeal rights are limited to changes to licences or similarly defined instruments. However, some of the most economically significant elements of the framework can be designed to sit outside the licence itself, within subsidiary documents or methodologies.
For example:
- Key financial parameters - such as the allowed rate of return - may be determined through separate methodologies or frameworks.
- In some sectors, these documents have historically been subject to appeal rights, but there have been attempts in more recent models to limit or dilute such rights.
This raises important questions about the effective reach of legal protections and the extent to which core economic assumptions can be challenged.
4. Long-term adaptability: length of price determination periods and reopeners
Given the long-term nature of RAB-based investments, periodic reviews will need to be undertaken of the desired outcomes, incentives and, ultimately, acceptable returns.
Even within relatively short periods of five years there can be uncertainty about the future developments. Some of these can be addressed through uncertainty mechanisms
while more significant issues may justify reopener mechanisms.
These provisions allow aspects of the regulatory settlement to be revisited in defined circumstances. Their design requires careful calibration:
- Scope: Reopeners should be clearly defined by reference, for example, to specified triggers such as changes in law or material unforeseen events. It is also important to clarify, once triggered, the boundaries of the matters which can be reviewed.
- Thresholds: The degree of materiality required to trigger a reopening should be explicit.
- Process: The procedural steps, timelines and evidential requirements should be transparent.
Poorly designed reopeners can create uncertainty and undermine investor confidence; overly rigid frameworks, by contrast, may fail to accommodate genuine changes over time. This is therefore core to the tension between flexibility and certainty as outlined above.
5. Enforcement and regulatory approach
Another important area concerns the regulator’s approach to enforcement.
Where a regulated entity fails to meet its commitments, a spectrum of responses may be available:
- Incentive-based mechanisms, including financial penalties or adjustments within the price control framework (i.e. the “stick” that goes with the potential upside “carrot” for outperformance);
- More formal enforcement action for breach of licence conditions, which may carry significant legal and reputational consequences.
The boundary between these approaches is not always clear. In some sectors, there has been an increasing focus on more intrusive forms of oversight, including scrutiny of governance arrangements and the “fitness” of senior management.
Clarity on enforcement philosophy, process and procedural safeguards is therefore essential.
6. The wider public law and political context
Finally, RAB regimes do not operate in a vacuum. Their effectiveness is shaped by the broader legal and political environment.
Key considerations include:
- Legal certainty and property rights: Unlike contractual frameworks2, RAB regimes are grounded in public law. Protections for investors may therefore be more limited.
- Subsidy control: The interaction between RAB support mechanisms and subsidy control rules may be relevant in certain sectors.
- Government involvement which in the form of revenue support, for example, has been key to the recent RAB models: Where the state plays a direct role (e.g. through guarantees or equity participation), additional public sector rules and constraints may apply.
- Transparency and information access: Regulated entities may be subject to disclosure obligations, including under environmental information regimes.
These factors can materially affect both the risk profile of an investment and the practical operation of the regulatory regime.
Conclusion
The RAB model remains a powerful and flexible tool for financing essential infrastructure. Its expansion into new sectors reflects a broader policy shift towards mobilising private capital to deliver large-scale investment.
However, its successful deployment depends not simply on replicating existing models, but on carefully adapting them to new contexts. Legal and regulatory design will be central to that process, particularly in relation to certainty, flexibility, and the allocation of risk.
This note has provided a high-level overview of some of the key issues. Each project and sector will raise its own specific challenges, and early engagement with these questions will be critical to ensuring a robust and investible framework.
This article is intended as a whistle-stop overview. Please get in touch if you would like to discuss any of these issues in more detail.
While responsibility for any errors in, or omissions from, this article remain ours alone, we would like to thank David Black, Managing Director at Berkeley Research Group, and Rebecca Barnett, Partner at Flint Global for sharing their insight and input on an earlier draft.
Footnotes
-
See our study of the trends in regulatory judicial reviews here: https://connections.nortonrosefulbright.com/post/102mijt/judicial-review-trends-the-rising-tide
-
To which the principles of Article 1 of Protocol 1 (peaceful enjoyment of possessions) of the European Convention on Human Rights have been found to apply.