What happened?
Germany's Federal Fiscal Court (the Bundesfinanzhof, or "BFH") has issued a landmark ruling on March 11, 2026 (case ref. I R 13/23) confirming that a US S-Corporation is entitled to full exemption from German withholding tax on dividends received from a German subsidiary under the Germany–US tax treaty. The decision is of considerable practical importance because it directly addresses the interplay between the US S-Corporation election and the German treaty-based dividend withholding tax relief, an issue that has been the subject of controversy between taxpayers and Germany's Federal Central Tax Office (Bundeszentralamt für Steuern, or "FCTO") for more than a decade.
The BFH held that, although an S-Corporation is not itself subject to US federal income tax and its income is instead taxed at the shareholder level, Article 1(7) of the Germany–US tax treaty creates a residency fiction that treats the S-Corporation's income as having been derived by a US-resident person for treaty purposes. As a result, the S-Corporation qualified as the beneficial owner of the dividends under German law, and the so-called participation exemption (Schachtelprivileg) under Article 10(3) of the treaty applies, reducing the German withholding tax to zero.
Background: How dividend withholding tax works between Germany and the US
When a German subsidiary pays a dividend to its US parent company, Germany imposes a withholding tax at a standard rate of 26.375 percent. The Germany–US tax treaty allows this rate to be reduced to 15 percent in the standard case, to 5 percent where the US parent holds at least 10 percent of the voting shares, or to 0 percent under the participation exemption where the US parent holds at least 80 percent of the voting shares and meets certain additional conditions under the treaty's limitation-on-benefits provisions. To benefit from these reduced rates, taxpayers must apply to the FCTO either for an exemption certificate in advance or for a refund of the excess tax withheld.
A complication arises when the US recipient of the dividend is treated differently for US and German tax purposes. Under US tax law, an S-Corporation is a corporation that has elected pass-through treatment under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC §§ 1361–1378), meaning that its income is not taxed at the corporate level but instead flows through to its shareholders. From a German perspective, however, the S-Corporation remains a corporation (Kapitalgesellschaft). This mismatch, known as a "hybrid entity" situation, has given rise to uncertainty about whether the S-Corporation can claim treaty benefits, particularly the full participation exemption under Article 10(3).
What did the BFH decide?
The case concerned a US S-Corporation that held a 100 percent interest in a German GmbH. In 2013, the GmbH distributed a dividend to the S-Corporation, and German withholding tax was withheld at the full rate. The S-Corporation applied to the FCTO for a full refund, but the FCTO granted only a partial refund, reducing the withholding tax to 15 percent rather than to zero. The FCTO took the view that, because of the application of Section 50d(1) sentence 11 of the German Income Tax Act (Einkommensteuergesetz, or "EStG"), the participation exemption could not be claimed by the S-Corporation.
The BFH rejected the FCTO's position and confirmed the taxpayers' entitlement to full relief, making the following key findings:
Article 1(7) creates a residency fiction. The BFH confirmed its prior decision (I R 48/12 of 26 June 2013) that Article 1(7) of the Germany–US tax treaty substitutes for the ordinary residency requirement under Article 4(1). Under Article 1(7), income derived by or through a person that is not itself taxable under the law of a contracting state is deemed to have been derived by a resident person of that state, to the extent that such income is treated as income of a resident person under the tax laws of that state. Because the S-Corporation's income is taxed at the shareholder level in the US, and all shareholders are US-resident persons, the fiction is satisfied.
The S-Corporation is the beneficial owner under German law. The BFH held that the concept of "beneficial owner" (Nutzungsberechtigter) under Article 10(3) of the treaty is to be interpreted under the domestic law of the source state — in this case, Germany. Since the S-Corporation is treated as a corporation under German law, it is the beneficial owner of the dividends for treaty purposes, and Article 1(7) does not alter this conclusion.
Section 50d(1) sentence 11 EStG has only procedural effect. Perhaps the most contentious aspect of the case was the interpretation of Section 50d(1) sentence 11 EStG, which was introduced in 2013 and provides that, where the recipient of income is not the person to whom the income is attributed under the tax law of the other treaty state, the refund claim belongs to the person to whom the income is attributed. The FCTO argued that this provision had a substantive, treaty-overriding effect, effectively shifting the beneficial ownership determination to the shareholders. The BFH disagreed, holding that Section 50d(1) sentence 11 EStG has only a procedural effect: it determines who may assert the refund claim, but it does not alter the underlying substantive entitlement to treaty relief. In practical terms, this means that the refund claim must be filed by the S-Corporation's shareholders, but the scope of relief, including the participation exemption, is determined by reference to the S-Corporation itself
What does this mean in practice?
The BFH's ruling provides clarity for US S-Corporations with German subsidiaries and is directly relevant in several respects.
Clear entitlement for S-Corporations. US S-Corporations that hold qualifying participations in German subsidiaries are entitled to full withholding tax relief under the participation exemption in Article 10(3) of the Germany–US tax treaty, provided the other conditions of the treaty are met (including the limitation-on-benefits tests under Article 28). The refund claim must be asserted by the S-Corporation's shareholders, not by the S-Corporation itself.
Potential impact on FCTO practice. The FCTO's practice of denying full withholding tax relief in comparable cases appears to be at odds with the BFH's ruling, at least insofar as US S-Corporations are concerned. It remains to be seen whether the FCTO will formally adjust its administrative practice in response to the decision. In the meantime, US S-Corporations that have been denied full treaty relief should be in a strong position to challenge those denials.
Potential impact on FCTO practice. The FCTO's practice of denying full withholding tax relief in comparable cases appears to be at odds with the BFH's ruling, at least insofar as US S-Corporations are concerned. It remains to be seen whether the FCTO will formally adjust its administrative practice in response to the decision. In the meantime, US S-Corporations that have been denied full treaty relief should be in a strong position to challenge those denials.
What should US companies do now?
The BFH's decision is a positive development for US companies with German subsidiaries, particularly those structured as S-Corporations. The following steps should be considered:
First, US S-Corporations that have pending refund claims or have been denied withholding tax relief by the FCTO should review those cases in light of the BFH's ruling and, where appropriate, file or pursue formal appeals. The ruling significantly strengthens the position of S-Corporation shareholders in asserting full treaty relief.
Second, US companies that are not structured as S-Corporations but hold German subsidiaries as disregarded entities under the check-the-box rules should be aware that the ruling does not resolve their situation. These companies should continue to monitor the legal debate regarding the FCTO's position on disregarded entities and consider whether protective measures, such as changing the US tax classification of the German subsidiary, may be appropriate. Although the BFH's reasoning regarding the procedural nature of Section 50d(1) sentence 11 EStG and the residency fiction under Article 1(7) may provide helpful arguments by analogy in check-the-box cases, the differences between the two scenarios mean that certainty can only be achieved through further litigation or legislative clarification.
Finally, US companies should consult with their tax advisors to assess the specific impact of the ruling on their structures and to develop a tailored response. We will continue to monitor this area and provide updates as the legal position develops.
This article was co-authored by senior associate Christian Klein (Tax, Frankfurt).