What happened?
Germany's Federal Central Tax Office (the "FCTO") has quietly changed how it handles requests for reduced tax rates on dividend payments made by certain German subsidiaries to their US parent companies. Specifically, where the German distributing GmbH is treated as a "disregarded entity" for US tax purposes, the FCTO is now frequently denying treaty‑based relief (both exemption certificates and refunds). This change does not result from a new law or regulation. Rather, the FCTO has adopted a stricter reading of existing rules, and it is rejecting requests that would previously have been approved as a matter of course. While it remains uncertain whether this will become a permanent position, the practical consequences for affected US companies are significant enough to warrant immediate attention.
Background: How dividend withholding tax works between Germany and the US
When a German subsidiary pays a dividend to its US parent company, Germany imposes a withholding tax on that payment at a standard rate of 26.375%. However, the tax treaty between Germany and the United States allows that rate to be reduced, in many cases to 15%, 5%, or even 0%, depending primarily on the level of ownership the US parent holds in the German subsidiary, along with certain other conditions. To benefit from these reduced rates, taxpayers must apply to the FCTO either for an exemption certificate (obtained in advance) or for a refund of the excess tax withheld. In practice, additional eligibility and anti abuse rules can apply.
For many years, this process worked relatively smoothly, and the FCTO routinely granted relief under the treaty without raising concerns about how the German subsidiary was classified for US tax purposes.
What has changed?
The issue centres on the "check-the-box" election. Under US tax rules, a US parent company can elect to treat a foreign subsidiary, such as a German limited liability company (a "GmbH"), as a so-called "disregarded entity." When this election is made, the German subsidiary is essentially ignored for US federal income tax purposes. It is treated as if it does not exist as a separate entity, and its income and expenses are reported directly on the US parent company's tax return. This is a standard and widely used structure and does not affect how the German subsidiary is treated under German law, where it remains a fully separate legal entity.
The FCTO has now taken the position that if a German GmbH is treated as a disregarded entity for US tax purposes, the distributions it makes do not qualify for the reduced withholding tax rates under the Germany–US tax treaty. In other words, where the German payer is disregarded for US purposes, the FCTO views the payment as not being recognised as dividend income at the level of the US recipient for US federal income tax purposes and therefore outside the scope of treaty relief.
As a result of this new interpretation, the FCTO is now requiring applicants to disclose how the German distributing company is classified for US tax purposes and whether the distributions are treated and taxed as dividends at the level of the US recipient. If the German subsidiary is treated as a disregarded or "flow-through" entity, the FCTO will deny the request for reduced withholding tax rates.
Impact on the exemption and refund procedure
In many US inbound structures, the FCTO now appears to treat the US tax classification of the German distributing company as decisive for relief. Where the German GmbH is treated as a disregarded entity for US purposes, the authorities increasingly decline to issue exemption certificates and reject refund claims on the view that the distribution is not recognised as income in the United States.
What does this mean in practice?
If the FCTO's position holds, the consequences for affected US companies are straightforward but potentially costly. Treaty relief, whether obtained through an exemption certificate or a refund, would only be available where the German subsidiary is treated as a separate, standalone entity (in other words, not disregarded) for US tax purposes. In all other cases, specifically where the German payer is treated as a disregarded entity, the full German withholding tax of 26.375% would apply and would become a final, non recoverable cost that cannot be reduced or reclaimed.
It is also worth noting that this revised interpretation may not be limited to dividends. The FCTO's reasoning could extend to withholding tax on other types of cross-border payments, such as royalties, giving the issue broader practical significance for US companies with German operations.
What should US companies do now?
The FCTO's new position is the subject of active debate among tax practitioners, and it is too early to say whether it will become a settled, permanent interpretation. No formal legal or administrative guidance has been issued to support the change, and there are strong arguments that the FCTO's reading is not consistent with the purpose of the treaty. That said, the practical reality is that the FCTO is already applying this position to pending applications, and US companies should not assume the issue will resolve itself.
US Companies that currently hold German subsidiaries as disregarded entities for US tax purposes should consider the following steps. First, review existing structures to understand potential exposure to increased German withholding tax where the German payer is disregarded. Second, if an application for an exemption certificate or refund has been denied under this new interpretation, consider filing a formal appeal and keeping proceedings open while the legal debate continues. Third, evaluate whether any protective measures, such as changing the US tax classification of the German subsidiary prospectively, may be appropriate to preserve treaty benefits going forward. Fourth, where a valid exemption certificate is already in place, consider whether to accelerate planned distributions or adjust distribution amounts while relief is still available under the certificate, taking account of the specific facts and risk profile. Finally, US companies should consult with their tax advisors to assess the full scope of the issue and to develop a tailored response based on the particular facts and circumstances.
We will continue to monitor this development and provide updates as the situation evolves.
This article was co-authored by senior associate Christian Klein (Tax, Frankfurt).