In the recent case of Uber London Ltd & Ors v White & Ors (Re Disclosure) [2026] EWHC 1610 (Comm), the Commercial Court held that litigation privilege will not apply where documents were created for the dominant purpose of enabling a litigation funder to assess the commercial viability of a claim and decide whether to fund it, even if those documents included an assessment of the merits of the case. Litigation privilege protects communication made for the dominant purpose of conducting litigation. While the decision whether to litigate is part of the conduct of litigation, the Court distinguished a prospective litigation funder's position from that of a claimant. The funder was deciding whether to fund someone else's litigation, not whether to conduct it themselves and therefore the test for litigation privilege was not met.
Careful thought should be given to communications with prospective funders, particularly where a prospective funder is seeking to originate a claim and is communicating with third parties to gather information. While legal advice privilege may protect some communications if there is the necessary lawyer-client relationship between a law firm and funder, or if communications evidence previous legal advice between a law firm and their claimant client, it will not protect all communications, and those relevant to the issues in dispute could become disclosable.
Background to the case
The underlying case concerns a claim by a group of London black cab drivers and private car hire companies (the Claimants) arising out of the way Uber obtained its licence to operate. The Claimants allege the tort of unlawful means conspiracy, including on the basis of alleged deliberate wrongdoing and fraudulent misrepresentation relating to Uber’s operating system. The Claimants issued their claims in 2024, after the 6-year limitation period had expired. However, the Claimants argue that they did not and could not reasonably have discovered the alleged fraud and/or deliberate concealment until after 25/26 June 2018, the dates that Uber’s licensing appeal was made public in Westminster’s Magistrates’ Court. A preliminary issue trial was listed for 25 June 2026 to determine this point.
The application for documents and the claim to privilege
Shortly before the preliminary issue trial, Uber made an application (the Application) for disclosure of specific documents by the Claimants which it argued were relevant to the limitation issue and the Claimants’ knowledge at the relevant time. The Claimants resisted the Application on various grounds, including privilege, control and proportionality.
This is an example of a claim that was originated by a litigation funder. In December 2017, the litigation funder retained a law firm to investigate the potential claim by black cab drivers against Uber. As part of this investigation, the law firm and the funder communicated with the Licensed Taxi Drivers’ Association (LTDA), the trade association for black cab drivers. Various of the members of the LTDA later became the Claimants in this case, having become clients of the law firm in October 2018.
In the Application, Uber sought correspondence between the law firm, the funder and the LTDA prior to October 2018 which had been saved to the funder file (the Funder Communications), which the law firm had previously refused to disclose due to privilege. The parties agreed that communications between the law firm and the Claimants after 2018, and communications between the funder and the law firm were covered by legal advice privilege. However, legal advice privilege did not apply to the Funder Communications, as these were communications with a third party (save to the extent they evidenced previous legal advice). Uber argued that litigation privilege also did not apply to the Funder Communications as they were for the purpose of the funder deciding whether to fund the litigation, and not directly in relation to the conduct of litigation.
Decision
The Court decided based on the evidence before it that the Funder Communications were created for the dominant purpose of enabling the funder to decide whether it would fund the claim, and not for the purpose of enabling them or others to conduct the litigation. As the Judge emphasised, litigation privilege applies to communications with the sole or dominant purpose of conducting litigation. He considered previous cases which had held that the terms on which litigation funding is secured are not protected by litigation privilege as this test for litigation privilege was not satisfied.
The Claimants argued that the current case was different as a funder’s decision whether to fund a claim is part of the conduct of litigation, but the Judge disagreed. He drew a distinction between a prospective claimant deciding to pursue their own claim which is part of the conduct of litigation, and a prospective funder deciding whether to fund someone else’s claim, which is not – in the latter case a claimant must still decide whether to proceed with their claim. The Judge was not persuaded by arguments that the Funder Communications related to assessing the merits and quantum of the claim and therefore should be protected by litigation privilege. He refused to draw a distinction between communications that go to the merits and communications that deal with matters such as the terms of a funding arrangement. “The test for litigation privilege in the authorities does not refer to whether the content of the communications in question deals with the merits or quantum… but to the purpose for which the communication was created. I can see that the content of documents may inform the analysis of purpose. But it is not determinative of it.” There was no evidence that the funder would play any role in the litigation other than funding. As such, the Judge held that the Funder Communications were not covered by litigation privilege.
The Court also rejected the Claimants’ argument that the Funder Communications were not within their control, but instead were in the funder’s control and therefore the law firm owed a professional obligation to the funder to keep the documents confidential. The Funder Communications were in the physical possession of the law firm; when the Claimants became the law firm’s clients they were entitled to all information material to their engagement. While there is an exception when a client has given informed consent to information not being disclosed to them, this was not satisfied here. The Court found that standard wording in a retainer agreement did not amount to informed consent to give up rights to information relevant to their claims.
Key takeaways
It is often assumed that litigation privilege extends to any document or communication that relates to litigation. Under English law, this is not the case: it will only apply where the dominant purpose of a document is the conduct of litigation. Documents created for the dominant purpose of enabling a prospective litigation funder to assess a claim and decide whether to fund it will not satisfy this test.
Funders, lawyers and potential claimants should be mindful of this limitation and think carefully about the form and content of communications regarding litigation strategy and merits which may not be protected by privilege. This decision underlines the potential pitfalls of not doing so in the situation where funders are seeking to originate a claim and are conducting investigations. While not all such communications would be relevant to the issues in dispute or potentially damaging if disclosed to the other side, many may be, for example where, as here, there are arguments over limitation and the claimants’ knowledge. Legal advice privilege will not protect all such communications. Similarly, defendants facing funded claims should carefully consider assertions of privilege.
The same issue arises in relation to communications with insurers where parties are seeking to put in place After the Event (ATE) insurance. The dominant purpose of such communications will be for the insurer to decide whether to issue an ATE insurance policy rather than for the conduct of litigation, so again litigation privilege will not apply, and a cautious approach should be taken to the content of such communications.
With thanks to Emma Torok for her assistance in preparing this post.
Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.