Introduction

On 19 November 2025, the OECD released an update to its Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital (the Model). The Update provides new and detailed guidance on the taxation of income from natural resource extraction as well as in respect of mobile and remote working. This brief focusses on the introduction of a new optional provision to deal with income from activities connected with the extraction of natural resources. Many of the new provisions take the form of a recommended new provision to be incorporated into new or existing treaties by bilateral agreement; to this extent, the provision will generally not become effective until incorporated. However, there are some less fundamental changes that are reflected in revised guidance, which is likely to influence the view taken by some jurisdictions as to how the provisions of existing treaties should be applied.

Why change existing provisions?

There is some thought within the OECD that existing international treaties do not accurately reflect an appropriate balance of the taxing rights relating to natural resources between the source jurisdiction (ie the jurisdiction where the resources are located) and the residence jurisdiction (ie the jurisdiction where the multinational companies undertaking the work are in fact located).  This is particularly the case in relation to more mobile activities, such as exploration and mobile drilling. These new provisions are intended to redress that balance to some extent, although it is explicitly recognised that this will generally only form part of a package of measures that a source jurisdiction may implement to ensure it obtains appropriate value from its natural resources; other measures may include royalties, ring-fenced tax regimes and production-sharing contracts.

A new provision for the taxation of income arising from natural resource extraction

The update to the Commentary suggests that, to the extent not already in place, Contracting States consider adopting a “a free-standing alternative provision on the taxation of activities carried out in connection with the exploration and exploitation of extractible natural resources (…)”. This new provision establishes a lower permanent establishment threshold which would be crossed where a non-resident enterprise carried out relevant activities in a State for longer than a bilaterally agreed period. This removes the requirement for there to be a fixed place of business, or a degree of permanence. This would mean that the enterprise would be deemed to carry on relevant activities through a permanent establishment in that other State if such activities lasted, in aggregate in any 12-month period, longer than that specified period of time.

Why is the new provision needed? The Update explains this in the newly inserted paragraph 174:

174 (…) The point is that under Article 7 a State may generally tax the profits of non-resident enterprises (which may be disproportionately involved in the extractive industries, especially in small countries) only if those enterprises carry on business in that State though a permanent establishment. That condition will likely be fulfilled for onshore exploitation activities – a mine, for example, will generally constitute a permanent establishment – and the same might be true for offshore exploitation activities themselves. But offshore exploration and various service activities connected with offshore exploration or exploitation may be of short duration and may not take place at a geographically fixed place of business (…).

Similar provisions are already in place in numerous bilateral tax treaties. The OECD is now publishing this standard provision because it is looking to bring greater consistency and certainty of interpretation for States agreeing to such an approach. The new standard provision offers an alternative so that “relevant activities” can incorporate either offshore activities only or both offshore and onshore activities.

Key characteristics of the new provision

The new provision has four paragraphs which we discuss in turn below.

Paragraph 1

Paragraph 1 states that the new provision applies notwithstanding the provisions of Articles 5 and 13 of the Convention.  This has the effect of establishing that that the taxing rights of a State extend to all income and gains derived in connection with the exploration and exploitation of finite natural resources by a non-resident person. This means that even though existing provisions of the treaty may allocate the taxing right to the residence State, this new provision will override that to allow the source State to tax the activity.

The provision encompasses the extraction of non-renewable commodities such as hydrocarbons, precious metals, metal ores, rare earth elements and other minerals. However, it does not cover, for example, the harnessing of renewable resources such as hydroelectric, wind, wave, tidal or solar power. [New par 187 of the Model].

Paragraph 2

Paragraph 2 defines the term “relevant activity” and has two forms: one for States that wish to confine the scope of the article to offshore activities, and one for those that wish to include onshore activities.

Onshore activities can give rise to a permanent establishment for a non-resident enterprise under Article 5(1) of the Model.  The example given in the guidance is of a mine, as a result of which   the non-resident enterprise may have a permanent establishment engaged in mining under existing provisions.  The guidance also recognises that short duration and mobile services may be more prevalent in the offshore than onshore sector.  For these reasons, it suggests that a State might consider that a new provision restricted to offshore activities is sufficient. The extension of the provision to onshore activities is designed to pick up activities of enterprises carrying out work such as installation of infrastructure, engineering or consultancy services of seismic surveys which might otherwise fall below the permanent establishment threshold.

  • In the “Offshore only” version of paragraph 2, the reference to activities carried on “offshore” means, for a Contracting State, activities carried on within the area of its internal or archipelagic waters, its territorial sea, and any area beyond its territorial sea in which, in accordance with international law, it may exercise its sovereign rights with respect to the seabed and subsoil and their natural resources. The above terms have the meaning ascribed to them in the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1982.
  • The “Offshore and onshore” version of paragraph 2 does not limit the concept of “relevant activities”. Here, the concept of “relevant activities” also includes activities performed onshore in connection with the offshore exploration and exploitation activities.

In both cases, the term “relevant activity” includes not only the activities of exploration and exploitation themselves, but through the use of the expression “in connection with” also the performance of certain related services. This includes services performed offshore, including saturation diving on the seabed and the laying of pipelines.

For onshore activities, the use of the qualifying word “specialised” restricts the coverage of related services to those that are tailored to the onshore exploration and exploitation activities. [New Par 183 of the Model] For instance:

  • Examples of specialised activities include the assembly, installation and maintenance of specialised mining infrastructure and equipment, the performance of engineering and consultancy services relating to the onshore exploration and exploitation activities, and the carrying out of seismic surveys.1
  • However, catering services would typically be considered generic (non-specialised). This also applies to the supply of electricity, water or Internet access to a mine operator – or even a monthly delivery by road of provisions from a cross-border supplier. These are generic (non-specialised) services that fall outside the scope of the provision.

For offshore activities there is also a specific exclusion for the activities of certain vessels. The operation of ships or aircraft used for the primary purpose of (i) transporting supplies or personnel, or (ii) towing or anchor handling, or the operation of other vessels whose function is auxiliary to the exploration or exploitation of the seabed and its subsoil and their natural resources, does not constitute a “relevant activity”. Such activities should remain covered under Article 8 (international traffic)2 or under Articles 5 (permanent establishment) or 7 (business profits).

  • Towing services include those services performed by tugboats and encompass services that assist in the moving of ocean vessels in and out of port and between berths, towing (pushing) of barges, and transporting port pilots to ships waiting to enter a ship channel or port. Vessels performing auxiliary functions include those used for firefighting and rescue support.
  • But, for example, the following types of vessels carry out core activities to natural resource exploitation and are hence not covered by the exemption: oil production vessels; rigs or platforms (including those used for accommodation); floating storage production and offloading vessels used for hydrocarbon resources; dredging vessels; pipe-laying vessels; seismic or underwater survey vessels; and heavy-lift vessels.

Paragraph 3

Paragraph 3 deems the relevant activities to be carried on through a permanent establishment in a Contracting State where an enterprise of the other State carries on relevant activities in the Contracting State for more than a minimum agreed period. Existing bilateral treaties that contain a similar provision use a range of different thresholds (that include 30, 90, and 183 days and other periods). There is no requirement that the activities are attached to the same project or performed for the same customer; the test is only one of duration in the source State.

Paragraph 3 does not contain an anti-contract splitting rule; however, States may bilaterally agree to include this and the Update provides for draft language [see the suggested drafting at para 193 of the update]. This rule would not require the relevant activities to be performed at the same location but only that the relevant activities carried on by one or more closely related enterprises were “substantially the same”.

Once a permanent establishment is deemed to exist, the source State may tax the non-resident enterprise’s profits attributable to the deemed permanent establishment in accordance with Article 7 and the residence State will eliminate double taxation in accordance with Article 23.

Paragraph 4

Paragraph 4 deals with the taxation of gains, assigning to the source State the primary right to tax gains from the disposal of certain assets (immovable property, certain movable property, and shares and other comparable interests). It brings together the rules governing the treatment of each category of extractives-related income and gains, thereby providing transparency and clarity. However, it does make clear that a source State is entitled to tax gains on disposals of shares which derive their value from relevant activities in the source State. This is likely to create some difficulties in M&A activity in the future.

While the proposed provision deals with the taxation only of the enterprise that performs relevant activities, some bilateral treaties also enlarge the taxing right of the source State over income from employment (beyond that permitted by Article 15). As such, States may bilaterally agree to include this, and the Update provides for two draft provisions [see new par 199 and 201 of the Model]. Under this provision, the State where the employment was exercised could tax the remuneration of a non-resident employee even if the employer did not have a permanent establishment, provided the employment was exercised there for more than a bilaterally agreed period in the relevant twelve-month period.

Other considerations

The Update explains the potential different tax treatment of natural resource extraction versus natural resource exploitation. [Para 30 of the Update / Para 47 and 48 of the Commentary on Article 5] It sets out clearly that there is currently no common view on the basic questions of the attribution of taxation rights and of the qualification of the income from exploration activities. On this basis, the Model is now taking the approach that Contracting States should (bilaterally) agree upon the insertion of a specific provision dealing with this.

Reservations: As with any Update, there are several reservations made by States. These have now been included in paragraphs 204-259. In any specific situation, it is very relevant to consider whether a State has actually agreed to follow the (amended) Commentary or provision.

Our views

  • Offshore provisions have been included in various existing treaties, however, there are many differences between the relevant provisions used and this requires careful consideration – especially when comparing case law of different jurisdictions with each other. In light of those differences, the proposed harmonization of the offshore provisions is a sensible step.
  • Many existing treaties with European States (e.g. the UK, Norway, Denmark and the Netherlands) have included a 30-day threshold for recognizing a (taxable) permanent establishment. It will be interesting to see whether other States will apply the same approach.
  • In order for the new provisions to come into force, the relevant Contracting States need to agree and include this new wording in their tax treaty updates. This generally means a long political process of getting parliaments and senates to approve the new provision.
  • The new explanations around the in-scope “relevant activities” and the out of scope “use of vessels” is a helpful addition to the Model.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    A service is not considered specialised merely because it is performed at the site where onshore exploration and exploitation activities are also taking place; however, if the site is especially remote and difficult to access or operate in, this could suggest that most services performed at that site are specialised.

  2. 2

    This provision deals with profits from the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic that shall be taxable only in Resident State.\

Contact