Key takeaway
Cross-border recognition and assistance is now available in Hong Kong for foreign liquidators in solvent as well as insolvent compulsory liquidations. However, recognition and assistance is unlikely to be provided in the context of a creditors’ voluntary liquidation.
The case
In Re Forever Winner International Limited (in liquidation) [2026] HKCFI 5108, Forever Winner International (BVI) (Company) held a 49 percent stake in a HKEX-listed Cayman company, SPHL, as well as a HK $83.3 million unpaid dividend and UBS bank accounts in Hong Kong.
After a deadlock between the shareholders and directors, the BVI Court wound the Company up on just and equitable grounds (while the Company remained solvent) and appointed three joint liquidators (JLs).
The share registrar of SPHL refused to accept instructions regarding the Company’s shareholding from the JLs, and likewise UBS refused to transfer the Company’s account balances or add the JLs as authorised signatories of the Company’s accounts, unless a sealed recognition order was obtained from the Hong Kong Court.
The problem
Hong Kong has not adopted the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency (Model Law) and there is also no alternative statutory basis to provide recognition and assistance in relation to a foreign insolvency process under Hong Kong law. Recognition therefore depends on common law principles, as enumerated by the Hong Kong Court of Appeal in Re USUM Investment Group Limited [2026] 3 HKC 528.
Previous authorities in Hong Kong, notably the decisions of Justice Harris in the Hong Kong Court of First Instance in Re Supreme Tycoon Ltd (in liq) [2018] 1 HKLRD 1120 and Re Seahawk China Dynamic Fund [2022] 3 HKLRD 469, held that common law recognition and assistance in Hong Kong only applies to insolvent liquidations. The Court of Appeal confirmed in Re USUM that one of the criteria for the Court to grant recognition under common law ‘is that the foreign proceeding is a collective insolvency proceeding’.
The decision
In interpreting the scope of common law recognition and assistance in Hong Kong, The Honourable Madam Justice Linda Chan began with the “golden thread” of cross-border insolvency: modified universalism. Practically, this requires the court of a local jurisdiction to, as far as possible, recognise and provide assistance to a foreign insolvency process and foreign insolvency representative, with the goal of enhancing consistency and coordination under a single insolvency process.
Justice Chan held that recognition in Hong Kong under the common law approach requires the foreign insolvency proceeding to be a collective proceeding conducted in the debtor’s place of incorporation or COMI, and for recognition not to conflict with Hong Kong public policy, law or natural justice.
Further, Justice Chan extended the common law power of recognition and assistance, holding that it can and should apply to compulsory liquidation where the company concerned is solvent. Justice Chan noted the view of Justice Harris in Re Supreme Tycoon and Re Seahawk that a solvent liquidation is not a collective insolvency process and is more akin to a “private arrangement”. Justice Chan noted that, while Hong Kong has not adopted the Model Law, the development of the common law power of recognition and assistance should be informed by international thinking, including that reflected in jurisdictions which have adopted the Model Law. Accordingly, Justice Chan conducted a survey of the scope of which proceedings attracted recognition under the Model Law in various jurisdictions, including the UK, Singapore, Australia, the US, and New Zealand. These jurisdictions have all recognised foreign solvent liquidations on the basis that it is consistent with the modified universalist approach embedded in the Model Law. Justice Chan held that this was a “powerful reason” in favour of the Hong Kong Court extending the common law power of recognition and assistance to compulsory liquidation in respect of a solvent company.
Having surveyed the Model Law jurisdictions mentioned above, Justice Chan then decided that there were additional powerful reasons for the common law in Hong Kong to extend its position:
- the public interest in the ability of foreign courts exercising insolvency jurisdiction in the place of the company’s incorporation to conduct an orderly winding up of its affairs on a worldwide basis, which is at the core of the principle of modified universalism, applies equally to insolvent and solvent compulsory liquidation; and
- having, as far as possible, a single, worldwide insolvency process advances the interests of the company’s stakeholders. The same principle applies to insolvent and solvent companies – it is just that in the former case, the stakeholders are the company’s creditors, and in the latter case, the stakeholders are the company’s shareholders. There is no principled reason to deny recognition and assistance where the company is solvent.
As a result, recognition was provided to the appointment of the Joint Liquidators (JL) to the Company, and orders were granted providing the JLs with powers to act on behalf of the Company in Hong Kong.
A continued limitation
In obiter comments, Justice Chan, again differing to the view of Justice Harris in Re Supreme Tycoon and Re Seahawk, held that there are material distinctions between voluntary and compulsory liquidation which mean that it would not be appropriate for the Hong Kong Court to provide recognition and assistance in relation to a creditors’ voluntary liquidation.
Notably, Justice Chan identified that voluntary liquidation, unlike compulsory liquidation, is not conducted under the supervision of the foreign court but rather the supervision of creditors. Even if foreign laws permit the liquidator to apply to the court at various points during the voluntary liquidation, there is no requirement to do so (and often this is not in fact resorted to as a matter of practice), meaning that a voluntary liquidation is akin to a private arrangement. It is not the practice of the Hong Kong Court to recognise such arrangements. This is consistent with the Court’s finding that a fundamental reason behind the extension of the scope of recognition and assistance at common law is modified universalism: it is courts, as extensions of the sovereign, assisting each other and ensuring comity which provides the rationale for this power, not the sovereign assisting a foreign, private party.
Final thoughts
Foreign liquidators of solvent entities with assets in Hong Kong now have a powerful tool via the ability to seek recognition and assistance from Hong Kong courts. The shift in Re Forever Winner means that Hong Kong now falls into line with the US, Singapore, Australia and New Zealand (breaking from the UK's more restrictive stance).
The approach in Hong Kong may also influence the development of the common law approach to recognition in other countries yet to adopt the Model Law that follow the common law tradition, such as India, Guernsey, the BVI, Jersey and the Cayman Islands.
Read the judgment
You can access the full judgment (as at the time of publication of this post) here.
This publication was authored by Scott Atkins and Sam Gorman.