Complex commercial disputes are often cross-border, meaning parties may need to pursue or defend claims concerning the same or related subject matters in different jurisdictions. This raises strategic considerations regarding how to most effectively manage cross-border proceedings as well as issues such as the costs of defending or pursuing litigation simultaneously in multiple jurisdictions and the risk of inconsistent judgments.

The Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH), an organisation that aims to harmonise private international law and has facilitated international conventions, is currently considering whether to introduce a convention designed to address parallel proceedings and related actions in cross-border civil and commercial disputes. A consultation process on a draft convention completed in March 2026. The consultation responses have since been reviewed by the HCCH’s Permanent Bureau, with a decision on whether to progress the draft convention expected in March 2027.

The framework proposed by the HCCH broadly aims to identify the most appropriate jurisdiction to decide the claim when proceedings are commenced in multiple states, thereby aiming to improve predictability, reduce costs, and mitigate inconsistent judgments.

Why introduce a convention on parallel proceedings?

There is no unifying multi-state framework that governs how different national courts should manage concurrent proceedings (the Brussels Regulation contains various rules relating to civil and commercial matters, but it only applies to EU states).

The HCCH has previously issued two conventions that address cross-border jurisdiction related issues (the UK is a contracting state to both conventions):

  1. 2005 Choice of Court Convention, which regulates jurisdiction and enforcement where an exclusive choice-of-court agreement exists (i.e. an exclusive jurisdiction clause).
  2. 2019 Judgments Convention, which provides a framework for the recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments (i.e. does not address jurisdiction or apply to ongoing parallel proceedings).

However, these conventions do not apply to a situation in which there is no exclusive jurisdiction clause and parties initiate proceedings concurrently in multiple states.  This leaves a gap in the current international framework for managing parallel proceedings.

This highlights that one of the most effective ways for commercial parties to reduce the risk of parallel proceedings is to include a clearly drafted exclusive jurisdiction clause in a contract. Such clauses can provide greater certainty and predictability by helping to ensure that disputes are determined in the agreed jurisdiction. For example, the English courts will generally enforce them unless there are strong reasons not to. However, approaches to exclusive jurisdiction clauses are not consistent across jurisdictions, so their effectiveness may vary depending on where proceedings are brought.

In the absence of a multi-state framework governing concurrent proceedings, national courts apply their national laws and civil procedure rules to determine whether they should proceed with a claim, which can lead to greater uncertainty and expense.  In England and Wales, the courts apply the common law doctrine of forum non conveniens to determine whether proceedings should be stayed in favour of a different jurisdiction. In practice, this means that the court will consider whether there is another available jurisdiction which is clearly more appropriate for the resolution of the dispute. Even if a party can show this, the court may refuse a stay if it can be shown that justice requires the claim to continue in England and Wales.

Scope and definitions in the draft convention

Where there is no exclusive jurisdiction clause, the draft convention on parallel proceedings is intended to address the resulting gap by introducing a set of rules outlining the steps that should be followed by courts of contracting states where multi-state proceedings relating to civil and commercial matters are commenced concurrently. In doing so, the convention intends to improve legal certainty and efficiency in international litigation.

Central to the draft text, is a dual-track structure which distinguishes between two categories of multi-state proceedings:

  1. Parallel proceedings: These are proceedings before courts in different contracting states between the same parties on the same subject matter.

  2. Related actions: These are proceedings in different contracting states that are not parallel proceedings but involve:

    1. Substantially the same or connected parties;
    2. Facts arising in whole or in material part from the same transaction; and
    3. One or more common questions of law or material fact creating a risk of inconsistent findings.

A further element central to the scope of the convention is identifying when a court becomes seised, as this determines the chronological order of the proceedings. Article 4 of the draft convention clarifies that a court is deemed seised when the initial procedural document is lodged or, once the document is served on the respondent.

Framework for parallel proceedings (Chapter II)

Where parallel proceedings are commenced, the draft convention sets out a hierarchy to determine which court should proceed with the litigation:

  1. Rights in rem in immovable property: where the dispute concerns rights in rem in immovable property, priority is given to the courts of the state in which the property is situated (Article 6).
  2. Party autonomy and consent: if the dispute does not concern immovable property, the convention gives precedence to the parties’ own choice, specifically through agreements (not covered by the 2005 Convention) and express consent (Article 7).
  3. Other specified jurisdictional bases: if neither of the preceding steps apply, the draft convention relies on a series of additional jurisdictional grounds considered sufficiently strong to justify priority (listed in Article 8(2)).

If only one court satisfies the criteria at any stage of the hierarchy, the proceedings continue in that jurisdiction. However, if multiple courts qualify at a certain step in the hierarchy, the draft requires identification of the “more appropriate court”, guided by certain factors in Article 10.

Under Article 5, once the more appropriate court has been identified, the non-appropriate court may be required to suspend the proceedings promptly, dismiss them if there is a foreign judgment issued, or resume the proceedings if it is unlikely that the other court will render a judgment within a reasonable time.

Where related actions are commenced in different states, the draft convention adopts a less strict set of rules.

Under the draft text, each seised court must, on application and within a reasonable time, determine whether the interests of justice require that a single court hear all or part of the related actions. In making the determination, the court must apply the factors set out in Article 11. If the court concludes that consolidation in one court should apply, they are provided with three options:

  • Full consolidation in one court (Article 12);
  • Partial consolidation (Article 13); and
  • Continuation of separate proceedings where no determination is made in time (Article 14).

The draft expressly encourages courts to cooperate and exchange information in applying the convention. This is facilitated by a communication mechanism that supports direct inter‑court contact.

The draft encourages cooperation through four methods: direct court-to-court communication; indirect communication via a central authority; combination of direct/indirect communication; or, through the parties.

The draft also includes safeguards to protect procedural rights and ensure fairness through provision aimed at mitigating the following: avoiding denial of justice; preventing abuse of process; public policy exceptions; declarations and reservations for states; and uniform interpretation provisions.

Implications

If the convention is implemented and widely adopted by contracting states, we expect it to have significant practical implications. However, it may also face some fundamental issues, as noted in the consultation feedback process:

  1. Enhancing commercial certainty: the overarching purpose of the convention should enhance certainty for commercial parties in parallel proceedings that are subject to the convention by establishing and enforcing a more defined procedural roadmap.
  2. Adoption by states: many states may be reluctant to ratify an instrument that introduces rigid procedural obligations that undermine domestic doctrines, or risk undermining other regional frameworks (e.g., the Brussels Regulation). This may lead to an uneven application of the convention.
  3. Risk of non-contracting state parties involvement: the convention would not apply to parallel proceedings in non-contracting states. Where some parties involve courts in non-contracting states, courts may be forced to apply a fragmented approach to the convention.
  4. Encouragement of tactical behaviour: for example, there is a risk that parties could take advantage of Article 8(2) which may incentivise defendants to commence parallel proceedings in a court with a listed connection, to displace the first seised court.

We await the decision of the HCCH in March 2027 on whether to progress the draft convention.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post