On October 23, the Competition Bureau updated its Environmental claims and the Competition Act guidelines to reflect the federal government’s amendments to the Competition Act’s greenwashing provisions. As we discussed previously, claims about the environmental benefits of a business or business activity still require “adequate and proper substantiation,” but no longer need to follow an “internationally recognized methodology.”
The updated guidelines explain what substantiation involves, what evidence can support a claim, and what the Bureau expects from future-looking commitments.
Substantiation: What it means
Simply put, in the context of environmental claims, substantiation means having evidence that establishes the environmental benefit claimed. The Bureau defines the standard as “establishing by proof or competent evidence”; it expects the evidence to be both relevant to the claim and sufficiently rigorous such that the claim is supported. Often, scientific evidence will be needed. Businesses should also account for Canadian conditions, including geography and climate, where relevant to the claim. Crucially, claims must be substantiated before they are made.
The updated guidelines recognize several ways to substantiate a claim, including standards, regulatory frameworks, industry practices and a business’s own methods. The Bureau’s focus is whether the evidence adequately supports the claim, rather than whether it follows a prescribed methodology. In particular:
- Substantiation is not necessarily testing. Laboratory testing is not always required. Operational data or other evidence may suffice if it adequately and properly supports the claim made.
- No particular standard is prescribed. Substantiation does not require compliance with a Canadian or an international standard. Following a standard may help support a claim, but does not by itself establish adequate and proper substantiation.
- Supporting evidence need not be published. The substantiation provision does not require public disclosure of supporting information. Businesses must nevertheless be able to produce evidence if the Bureau challenges the claim.
- Product testing requirements remain. Claims covered by the product performance or product environmental-benefit provisions still require adequate and proper testing before they are made.
- Substantiation does not resolve whether a claim is misleading. A substantiated claim may still be false or misleading in a material respect. Both its literal meaning and the general impression it conveys must be considered.
Private parties can no longer challenge business claims before the Competition Tribunal under the substantiation provision. With leave, however, they may still challenge claims under the product-testing provisions (which require that claims about a product’s performance, or about a product’s environmental benefits, be based on adequate and proper testing), and may challenge any claim, including a business claim, under the general prohibition on materially false or misleading representations.
A clear plan: What the Bureau expects
Future-oriented environmental claims, such as claims about progress toward a net-zero target, are different from product performance claims. They are typically claims about a business or its activities, rather than about how a product performs, and so are assessed under the substantiation provision and the general prohibition or misleading representations, rather than the product-testing provisions.
For these claims, the updated guidelines retain the Bureau’s expectation that environmental claims be supported by substantiation and a clear plan to achieve the future-oriented goal before the claims are made. The Bureau warns against claims that are “little more than wishful thinking.” Under Principle 6 of the guidelines, the Bureau identifies three elements a business should have in place before making this type of claim:
- A clear understanding of what it needs to do to achieve the goal.
- Aconcrete, realistic and verifiable plan, with interim targets.
- Meaningful steps already underway.
The Bureau’s existing examples illustrate the distinction. A business that says it is “on its way” to net-zero by 2050 without substantiation or a concrete plan is unlikely to meet the requirement. By contrast, a delivery company with a plan to replace an average of 20 per cent of the fleet each year, a replacement project already underway, a schedule for the remaining vehicles and an emissions calculation using the GHG Protocol for Project Accounting has substantiation and a clear plan supporting its claim.
What should you do now?
- Revisit claims you withdrew or softened because of the international methodology requirement. Some may now be supportable.
- Keep the evidence and document your reasoning. Retain the supporting evidence and explain how it supports each claim, including relevant assumptions, limitations and Canadian conditions.
- Assess future-looking claims against the Bureau’s three elements of a clear plan set out above. Confirm that interim targets are credible and meaningful steps are underway.
- Be specific. Say whether a claim covers the whole business or only part of it and avoid vague terms like “eco-friendly.”
While the updated guidelines are not binding, they provide a clear view of how the Bureau intends to approach greenwashing enforcement in Canada. Using the guidelines to shape claims and assess supporting evidence is therefore a good starting point for compliance.
As Matthew Boswell, former Commissioner of Competition and now a partner at Norton Rose Fulbright Canada, notes: “Businesses in Canada need to remain vigilant when making environmental claims about their business or business activities. Violations of the greenwashing provisions of the Competition Act can result in very significant financial penalties, even where the claim is not false or misleading. Liability can flow simply from making the claim without adequate and proper substantiation.”