The federal government has tabled legislation that will substantially reform the law of collective bargaining and labour disputes for federally regulated employers and unions.
Bill C-39, An Act respecting certain measures to strengthen the economy, was introduced for first reading on September 21. It is omnibus legislation impacting a broad range of federal legislation. This update focuses on proposed changes to the Canada Labour Code.
Measures aimed at reducing labour disruptions
Part 3 of Bill C-39, labelled “Canada Strong for All,” focuses primarily on Part I (Industrial Relations) of the Code. These amendments would come into force upon proclamation of Bill C-39.
The proposed changes to federal collective bargaining are primarily aimed at reducing the likelihood of strikes and lockouts in federally regulated industries, including aviation, rail transport and port facilities operations. In recent years the federal government has intervened to end economically disruptive strikes and lockouts in these industries. Bill C-39 aims to further reduce the occurrence of work stoppages through the following changes to the federal collective bargaining framework.
Early bargaining for contentious bargaining units
Bill C-39 will require that bargaining begin between 200 and 180 days (approximately six months) before the prior collective agreement’s expiry. This is an increase from the current bargaining period, which opens four months prior to expiry of the current agreement, and only begins at the election of one of the parties.
The mandatory early bargaining period applies if:
- The prior agreement is the result of a binding method of dispute resolution (e.g. binding arbitration).
- A strike or lockout occurred after the parties commenced the bargaining that resulted in the prior agreement.
- The prior agreement has a term of five years or more.
This early bargaining period will trigger rules that normally apply when the parties elect to begin bargaining under the existing rules:
- The employer will not be permitted to alter terms or conditions of employment without the union’s agreement beginning on the 200th day prior to expiry of the prior agreement.
- Future prohibition on use of existing employees as replacement workers during a strike or lockout will be in reference to those employees’ roles as of the 200th day prior to expiry of the prior agreement.
- The minister may order a vote to be held on the employer’s last offer if it is rejected by the union, beginning as of the 200th day prior to expiry of the prior agreement.
- The parties must enter into a maintenance of services agreement as a component of the bargaining that begins during the 200- to 180-day period prior to expiry of the prior agreement.
Longer conciliation period
Bill C-39 proposes to extend the mandatory conciliation period from 60 days to 90 days. This will not only allow for an extra month of assisted bargaining between the parties, it will also delay the timing of a lawful strike or lockout by at least one month.
Under the Code, conciliation is a formal step in the collective bargaining process when negotiations between a union and an employer reach an impasse. It is facilitated by the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) and is intended to provide for neutral third-party assistance to help resolve bargaining disputes. The parties are not in a lawful strike or lockout position until at least 21 days have elapsed after the end of the conciliation period.
Party-driven first contract binding arbitration
At present, an order for first contract binding arbitration is at the minister’s discretion. Bill C-39 would require the Canada Industrial Relations Board (CIRB) to direct first contract binding arbitration upon application of either the employer or union. Such application may be made if a collective agreement has not been reached within nine months of the notice to bargain.
Special mediator
Bill C-39 would create a special mediator role. This individual would not only assist the parties in concluding a collective agreement but may also author a report publicizing outstanding issues in dispute and serving as the basis for future government intervention.
At any time before the 75th day of the conciliation period the minister will be empowered to appoint the special mediator for a period of 21 days. The special mediator will confer with the parties to assist them in settling issues in dispute. Unless the parties enter into a collective agreement or reach a tentative agreement, the special mediator will provide a report to the minister detailing issues in dispute, the parties’ positions, an assessment of the parties’ participation, the likelihood of agreement and the special mediator’s views and recommendations.
The special mediator’s report will be released to the public five days after the end of the 21-day period, with appropriate redactions for personal information or confidential business information. It will also be a mandatory consideration for the minister in any exercise of the minister’s discretionary power to order binding arbitration (described further below).
Minister’s additional powers
Bill C-39 elaborates on the minister’s discretionary powers under section 107 of the Code. This is the section the federal government relied upon on several occasions in 2024 and 2025 to direct the CIRB to end prominent labour stoppages – typically by directing the parties to binding arbitration.
The new section 107 elaborates on the minister’s authority to avoid or end labour disruptions. The minister will be empowered to direct the CIRB to order an end to a lawful strike or lockout, order an extension of a collective agreement or order binding arbitration between an employer and union only if:
- The minister has considered the special mediator’s report.
- The minister believes the strike or lockout underway adversely affects or may adversely affect the national interest.
The minister may take into account relevant considerations in assessing the national interest, including impacts on the Canadian economy, serious social disruption and any impact on the freedom of association.
Mandatory post-bargaining mediation
Bill C-39 will require mandatory post-bargaining mediation if the parties enter a new collective agreement after either binding arbitration or a strike or lockout. The minister must appoint a mediator to assist the parties in improving their relationship within six months of the parties entering into their new collective agreement.
Additional changes to the Code
Beyond changes to federal collective bargaining, Bill C-39 proposes additional changes to the labour relations and minimum standards regimes under the Code:
- Bad faith unfair labour practice complaints. Government would have regulatory authority to prohibit frivolous, vexatious or bad faith unfair labour practice complaints, including those made by unions.
- Expansion of administrative monetary penalties (AMPs). Government would have regulatory authority to create AMPs for a party’s failure to participate in mandatory early bargaining or for making bad faith unfair labour practices.
- Multi-employer certification. Multi-employer bargaining units would be available upon application by employers and may be expanded to new industries (currently the Code provides for multi-employer bargaining units in the longshoring industry).
- Successor employers. Collective bargaining rights would transfer across the retendering of service contracts, such that new service providers would be bound to any collective agreement applicable to workers performing the services.
- Enforcement of settlements. The government will have greater powers to compel payment of settlements of wage complaints under the Code, including the ability to compel employer creditors to pay a settlement amount.
- No stacking paid medical leave. The Code will be revised to clarify that the medical leave of absence with pay under Part III of the Code will not apply where a collective agreement provides for a similar paid leave.
Moving forward
If Bill C-39 is adopted as currently drafted, federally regulated employers will need to adjust their bargaining procedures and strategies accordingly. In particular:
- Anticipate earlier and longer mandatory bargaining periods. Between the mandatory early bargaining period for some parties, and the extended conciliation period for all, the timeline in all bargaining rounds will now be longer before the parties are in a lawful strike/lockout position. These extended timelines will also mean the consequences of bargaining – including freezes on working conditions and restrictions on later redeployment of employees during a work stoppage – will begin earlier and last longer.
- Anticipate increased public scrutiny. The special mediator’s role is not only to assist in resolving disputes, but also to publicize the nature of disputes that lead to strikes or lockouts. There will be a government appointee at the bargaining table with the discretion to communicate the parties’ positions to the government and the public.
- Anticipate more government intervention. Bill C-39 doubles down on the federal government’s commitment to section 107 as a tool to forestall or end strikes or lockouts. While unions have defied back-to-work orders in the recent past, and there are ongoing constitutional challenges to this tool, its elaboration in Bill C-39 signals the government’s intention not only to preserve the mechanism, but to include it as a possible outcome in any bargaining round that threatens the government’s perception of the national interest.
The Norton Rose Fulbright team will continue to track Bill C-39 as it moves through Parliament. If the bill is adopted, as proposed or as revised, we will be available to assist federally regulated employers in adapting and preparing for upcoming collective bargaining rounds.