When will the Ontario Court of Appeal grant leave to hear an appeal from a Divisional Court decision?
In the recent decision Knauff v Ontario (Human Rights Tribunal), the Court of Appeal for Ontario settled recent uncertainty surrounding the longstanding legal framework first set out in Re Sault Dock Co. Ltd. And City of Sault Ste. Marie.1
Sault Dock and changes to the legal landscape
For over 50 years, Sault Dock, has been the leading case on motions seeking leave to appeal Divisional Court decisions. The Sault Dock framework identified the overarching consideration on a motion seeking leave to appeal from a Divisional Court decision as the importance of the question in issue viewed from the development of Ontario law and the public interest.2
While the overarching message of Sault Dock remains good law when properly interpreted, the Court of Appeal in Knauff identified several reasons to warrant updating the framework, including underdeveloped case law and a lack of elaboration on the meaning of public importance since reasons are rarely given on motions seeking leave to appeal, and uncertainty as to how the framework applies to exercises of original jurisdiction or appellate jurisdiction by the Divisional Court.
Perhaps more importantly, recent Court of Appeal decisions have unsettled the test described in Sault Dock. In West Whitby Landowners Group Inc. v. Elexicon Energy Inc.,3 the Court of Appeal suggested reformulated guidance, but shortly thereafter, in Davis v. Aviva General Insurance Company4 the Court of Appeal indicated that Sault Dock governed absent a five-judge panel decision settling the issue.
Knauff is the decision that settles the issue.
The Knauff framework
In Knauff, the applicant was seeking leave to appeal a Divisional Court decision dismissing his application for judicial review. He alleged his employer, the Ministry of Natural Resources, failed to provide vegan meals while he was on active duty as a forest firefighter, and that failure constituted discrimination against him under the Human Rights Code.5 The Court of Appeal dismissed the application for leave to appeal for failing to raise an arguable question of public importance.6
In reaching this conclusion, the Court of Appeal revisited the framework for hearing an application for leave to appeal Divisional Court decisions. The key consideration in the Knauff framework is whether the proposed appeal raises an arguable question of law or mixed law and fact that is of sufficient public importance to warrant consideration by the Court of Appeal.
Arguability focuses on whether there is a real, arguable question of law or mixed law and fact to be debated between the parties arising in the circumstances of the case. Arguability must be determined before proceeding to consider public importance, because a question that is important in the abstract will not be of public importance unless it arises from an arguable question in the case at hand.7
If there is an arguable question of law or mixed law and fact, the public importance of the question is then considered. There is no finite or closed category of question that can qualify as being of public importance. Public importance is assessed from two perspectives: (1) by asking who would be affected by a disposition of the question, and how they would be affected; and (2) by asking how Ontario law is affected by a disposition of the arguable question.8
The Court of Appeal clarified here that there are no more “special circumstances” for public importance as described by Sault Dock. Any circumstance alleged to make a matter one of public importance is to be considered within the public importance component of the framework.
The Court of Appeal also clarified that the same approach applies to motions seeking leave to appeal a decision of the Divisional Court exercising its original jurisdiction and those in which the Divisional Court exercises appellate jurisdiction.9
Key takeaways
In Knauff, the Court of Appeal maintained the crux of Sault Dock, but provided modern guidance to litigants and their counsel seeking or resisting leave to appeal Divisional Court decisions. When considering an appeal of a Divisional Court decision, parties should consider the arguability of their cases and whether the question raised by the appeal raises an issue of public importance.
The authors would like to thank Elisar Haydar, articling student, for their contribution to preparing this legal update.