Over the past five years, the prosecution of federal environmental offences in Canada has resulted in large fines and prominent headlines. However, a closer review of public data from the Environmental Offenders Registry (EOR), and from Environment and Climate Change Canada’s (ECCC) own reporting, provides a more qualified picture.
Fewer convictions, higher penalties
There are good reasons to avoid placing undue weight on claims that federal environmental enforcement in Canada is becoming more aggressive based on a few landmark prosecutions in recent years.1
- The data suggests administrative monetary penalties (AMPs) are increasingly displacing criminal prosecutions, save for the most serious cases. In 2017, AMPs were introduced to the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA) as an intermediate enforcement tool, along with other alternative compliance measures (e.g. warnings). Since their introduction, the number of reported CEPA criminal convictions has fallen from 62, between 2015 and 2020, to just 9, between 2021 and September 2026. Under the Migratory Birds Convention Act (MBCA), a similar downward trend in criminal convictions has occurred.2
- The increase in the median penalty is consistent with introduction of AMPs and minimum sentences. While the EOR data indicates the median sentence amount for environmental convictions has increased from about C$72,500, between 2015 and 2020, to around C$125,000, between 2021 and September 2026, mega-fines (over C$10 million) remain outliers in the environmental context.3 There were three mega-fines between 2021 and September 2026 compared to one between 2015 and 2020. Outliers aside, the moderate increase in the median penalty for convictions, adjusting for inflation, is largely consistent with a trend toward less serious offences being dealt with administratively (where possible) and with the fact that in 2017, at the same time as AMPs were introduced, the Environmental Enforcement Act was amended to establish minimum sentences for summary conviction and indictable environmental offences.
- Criminal prosecutions under the Fisheries Act have declined considerably. There were about 39 per cent fewer convictions between 2021 and September 2026 than between 2015 and 2020. This is notable because AMPs are not available to address pollution prevention offences under the Fisheries Act, suggesting the drop in convictions may be the result of enforcement strategy decisions or other factors.4 In other words, while the Fisheries Act has remained the mainstay of federal environmental prosecutions over the past five years (far exceeding convictions under CEPA, MBCA and other statutes), federal law enforcement appears to be taking a more targeted approach to such offences.
Expect targeted enforcement ahead
In July 2026, ECCC published its 2026–2027 Departmental Plan, which confirmed significant budget cuts and a material reduction in personnel. These operational constraints may result in fewer federal inspections, investigations and prosecutions in the coming years, contributing to what appears to be a trend toward using AMPs for lesser offences and targeted criminal enforcement for more serious offences.
While industry participants should remain wary of headline-driven conclusions, it would be a mistake to treat declining conviction rates as a reprieve from environmental compliance. Provincial enforcement and civil litigation remain active in Canada, and as noted above, the federal data appears to reflect a shift in enforcement tools rather than a reduced concern for protecting the environment.
Businesses operating in Canada should continue to maintain robust compliance programs. There may be fewer targets of federal environmental prosecutions in today’s enforcement landscape, but that is little comfort if you are one of them.
The author would like to thank Jaden Love, articling student, for her contribution to preparing this legal update.
Footnotes
-
The fact environmental prosecutions typically take years to reach a resolution provides another reason for approaching claims of more aggressive enforcement with caution, as recent convictions often reflect enforcement decisions from an earlier period.
-
Although the number of convictions under the Species at Risk Act (SARA) increased about fivefold during that timeframe, this was largely due to a cluster of prosecutions concerning the Western Chorus Frog habitat in La Prairie and Longueuil, Quebec, rather than a sustained, nationwide intensification of SARA prosecutions.
-
The median sentence amount is preferred over the average amount, as it reduces the statistical effect of the mega-fines.
-
The ECCC has acknowledged the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, for example, on monitoring, compliance and enforcement.