In Reference re iGaming Ontario, the Ontario Court of Appeal issued a significant ruling on Ontario’s proposed model that would allow online players in the province to participate in peer‑to‑peer games with players located outside Canada.
In a 4–1 decision, the Court confirmed that such a structure would remain lawful under section 207(1)(a) of the Criminal Code, provided Ontario continues to “conduct and manage” the Ontario component of the gaming scheme through iGaming Ontario (iGO).
The Court concluded that the Criminal Code does not require all players to be physically situated within the province. What matters is that Ontario retains operational control over the gaming activity offered to Ontario users, something achieved through iGO’s role as a provincial agent, its standard form operating agreements with private operators and the continued application of Ontario’s regulatory framework.
The ruling removes a major legal constraint on Ontario’s ability to adopt an international “pooled liquidity” model for peer‑to‑peer games such as online poker and daily fantasy sports.
While the decision does not itself implement cross‑border pooling, it authorizes Ontario to proceed if it chooses and is likely to influence how other provinces evaluate their own regulated iGaming models.
Whether and when pooled liquidity will be launched remains a policy decision for the province. Parties may still seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, and any such application could affect the timing of implementation pending further judicial direction.
The authors would like to thank Bilal Ak, articling student, for his contribution to preparing this publication.