On May 5, 2026, the Federal Court of Appeal released its decision in Therme Development (CY) Ltd. v. Nordik Spa Village Chelsea Inc. This case concerned the expungement of various trademark registrations owned by THERME Development. In dismissing the appeal, the Federal Court of Appeal affirmed various aspects of the Federal Court’s decision and offered guidance on the expungement of the marks for being clearly descriptive and confusing on separate grounds, one based on the French pronunciation of the mark and the other based on the English pronunciation.

Background

In 2024, the Federal Court (FC) issued a decision on the application by Auberge & Spa Le Nordik Inc. and Nordik Immobiliers Winnipeg Inc. (Nordik) under the Trademarks Act1 to expunge certain registered services from trademark registrations owned by THERME Development (CY) Ltd. (TDev), a resort developer based in Toronto.

Two word marks (THERME, TMA1110500; THERME GROUP, TMA1110501) and two design marks (THERME WOMAN, TMA1110061; THERME WOMAN’S HEAD, TMA1110502) were at issue.

The services at issue from TDev’s mark registrations related to hotel management, health and wellness spas and centers, thermal baths, hotels, swimming baths, restaurant services, salons, and similar.

Notably, the FC considered the validity of the marks under subsection 12(1)(b), (c), and (d) of the Trademarks Act, which specify that a mark, when written or sounded, cannot be either clearly descriptive or deceptively misdescriptive, in English or French, of the character or quality of the goods or services in association with which it is used, cannot be the name in any language of any of the goods or services it is to be used in connection with, and cannot be confusing with a registered trademark.2

TDev appealed the FC’s findings that: 1) the THERME WOMAN and the THERME WOMAN’S HEAD marks were clearly descriptive of certain services, 2) the THERME mark was deceptively misdescriptive of the character of some of its listed services, and 3) the THERME mark and the THERME GROUP mark were confusing with Nordik’s registered marks, THERMËA & DESSIN (TMA897306) and THERMËA (TMA897305).

The FCA dismissed the appeal.

Clearly Descriptive

The FC found that the THERME mark was clearly descriptive, as sounded, of services related to health spas and thermal baths and so invalid in respect of those services. This was based on the finding that “thermes” is a French word that means “thermal baths” or the name of an establishment where thermal treatments or cures are performed, and that it sounds identical to THERME. For the design marks THERME WOMAN and THERME WOMAN’S HEAD, the FC held that the word elements dominated over the design elements of the mark and were therefore held to be descriptive of the same services as the THERME mark.

As the word THERME without an “s” is not the name of any of the services, the marks were not held invalid under subsection 12(1)(c) of the Trademarks Act.

The FCA disagreed with the FC’s reasoning that the word elements of the design marks were dominant because the design elements would not be sounded. Rather, considering the visual impression created by the word and design elements, the FCA reasoned that a prospective consumer, as a matter of first impression, would have the word THERME at the front of their mind when viewing both marks.

The FCA agreed that, when sounded, each of the THERME, THERME WOMAN, and THERME WOMAN’S HEAD marks is clearly descriptive in the French language of the services related to health spas and thermal baths.

Deceptively Misdescriptive

The FC considered whether the THERME mark would mislead the general public as to the character or quality of the services in issue. THERME was found to be deceptively misdescriptive of services related to health spas and wellness centres that do not include thermal baths, as an average French-speaking consumer would be led to believe thermal baths would be at a THERME spa.

On appeal, TDev argued that, because the FC found the THERME mark was clearly descriptive of certain services, it could not be deceptively misdescriptive of these same services. The FCA clarified that, while a mark must first be found to be descriptive of something before it can be found to be misdescriptive, clear descriptiveness and deceptive misdescriptiveness are alternative findings which cannot both apply to the same services.

Confusion

The FC also found that there was a likelihood of confusion between the THERME and THERME GROUP marks and Nordik’s THERMËA mark. The marks, as sounded with English pronunciation, were found to have a moderately high degree of resemblance. The FCA found no reviewable error in this conclusion.

No Paradox

The FCA rejected TDev’s argument that the FC’s finding of confusion created a paradox: on the one hand, the word THERME is descriptive such that anyone should be able to use it, and on the other, the THERME and THERME GROUP marks are confusing with Nordik’s THERMËA marks such that TDev may not use them. The FCA clarified that these findings were based on separate analyses of the marks’ pronunciations in different languages: the word found to be descriptive in French is not the same as the word found to be confusing in English.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Federal Court: Auberge & Spa Le Nordik Inc. v. THERME Development (CY) Ltd., 2024 FC 1765

  2. 2

    Federal Court of Appeal: Therme Development (CY) Ltd. v. Nordik Spa Village Chelsea Inc., 2026 FCA 85

Contact