The recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision of CHU de Québec-Université Laval v Tree of Knowledge International Corp1 affirms that officers and directors may be held personally liable for civil fraud where they have participated in the corporation’s fraud, even if the court has not “pierced the corporate veil.”
This decision should serve as a reminder that the protection afforded by the corporate shield is nuanced and even sincerely held misrepresentations can give rise to liability, if such representations are made recklessly.
Background
In late March 2020, at the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic, CHU de Québec-Université Laval (CHU) contracted with Tree of Knowledge Inc. (TOKI), which agreed to supply three million certified N95 masks for over USD 11 million. Michael Caridi was an officer and the sole director of TOKI, who negotiated the agreement with CHU on behalf of TOKI.
TOKI failed to deliver certified N95 masks by the required date. A few weeks later, TOKI delivered a small quantity of KN95 masks not fit for medical use. CHU brought an action against several defendants, including TOKI and Mr. Caridi. By the time of trial, CHU had settled with all defendants, except for Mr. Caridi.
The trial decision
At trial, the judge found Mr. Caridi personally liable for civil fraud and ordered him to pay over USD 11 million in damages, less some amounts that CHU had been able to recover from other parties, plus over $1.2 million in costs.2
The trial judge found that, among other things, Mr. Caridi had misrepresented his ability to supply the N95 masks and overstated his certainty that they would be properly certified. He also misled CHU into believing the export declaration form (which described “KN95 masks”) was only done so the masks (which were really N95 masks) could clear Chinese customs. The trial judge found that although Mr. Caridi may have been “sincere” in his intentions and reliance on others, he had acted recklessly, which satisfied the knowledge requirement for civil fraud.
Mr. Caridi appealed the decision, arguing the court applied too low a threshold for recklessness and ought not to have found him personally liable for the corporation’s failure to deliver the N95 masks.
Ontario Court of Appeal decision
Understanding “recklessness” in cases of civil fraud
To establish civil fraud, a plaintiff must prove:
- The defendant made a false representation.
- The defendant had some level of knowledge the representation was false, whether through actual knowledge or recklessness.
- The false representation caused the plaintiff to act.
- The plaintiff’s actions resulted in a loss.
In response to Mr. Caridi’s argument that the trial judge had improperly conflated “carelessness” and “recklessness,” the Court of Appeal determined that the trial judge had been careful to distinguish between the type of behaviour required to ground a claim in fraud, as opposed to negligence:
- To prove civil fraud, the knowledge requirement will be met where persons making the misrepresentation did not have an honest belief that the statement was true, were indifferent or did not care if the statement was true, or close their eyes to (or purposefully abstain from inquiring about) the facts.
- In contrast, simply having an honest but mistaken belief in the truth of the statement is not enough to meet the knowledge requirement for fraud, though it may (in combination with other elements) be enough to establish negligent misrepresentation.
In this case, even though Mr. Caridi was found to have been “sincere” in his reliance on others and on his intention to source the masks, he was reckless in his representations to CHU, given that he had not sourced any N95 masks and had no reliable information he would be able to. As such, he had no subjective belief in these representations, nor any factual basis for them.
Personal liability for participating in corporate fraud—without piercing the corporate veil
Directors and officers can be held personally liable for the tortious conduct of a corporation where a court “pierces the corporate veil” to hold the “directing mind” liable in their personal capacity. However, even where the corporate veil is not pierced, officers or directors may still be held personally liable for tortious acts of the corporation in certain situations, including where: (i) the conduct is “independently tortious” or “tortious in itself”; or (ii) the director acts pursuant to a “separate identity or interest” from the corporation.3
On appeal, Mr. Caridi urged the Court of Appeal to clarify when officers and directors can be held personally liable for the tortious conduct of a corporation, arguing the case law in this area was unclear and ought not to extend to claims for pure economic loss. However, the court declined to do so on the basis it was not necessary to decide this case.
In this case, Mr. Caridi was not facing liability merely due to his status as officer and director, but rather, due to his own fraudulent conduct. The court held that where a director or officer personally engages in fraud, even on behalf of the corporation, the director “makes the fraud their own” and cannot use the corporate shield to avoid personal liability.
Key takeaways
Officers and directors should take note that good intentions will not shield them from personal liability for misrepresentations made in deliberate disregard of the truth. Officers and directors who act honestly, in good faith, and on an informed basis, are likely at little risk of finding themselves in Mr. Caridi’s situation but should nonetheless exercise caution as the law in this area continues to develop.
The real value of the case will be for victims of fraud, particularly in cases where the corporate defendant has been stripped of its assets by the time the fraud has come to light. Although this decision may chart a more straightforward path to personal liability, timely and decisive action will still be required to maximize chances of meaningful recovery.
The author would like to thank Matteo LeClair, articling student, for his contribution to preparing this legal update.
Footnotes
-
CHU de Québec-Université Laval v Tree of Knowledge International Corp., 2026 ONCA 209.
-
CHU De Québec-Université Laval v Tree of Knowledge International Corp., 2024 ONSC 3541 (trial decision); CHU de Québec-Université Laval v Tree of Knowledge International Corp., 2024 ONSC 5193 (costs endorsement).
-
For a further discussion on personal liability for corporate fraud, please see our previous legal update.