In the first quarter of 2026, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) released one judgment of interest to property insurers and policyholders: Emond v. Trillium Mutual Insurance Co.1 This update highlights the key takeaways from that decision and previews what’s on the SCC’s docket in spring 2026.
Emond v. Trillium Mutual Insurance Co.
Key takeaway:
This decision is of significance particularly to property insurers and policyholders as the SCC provided guidance on the principles applicable to interpreting insurance contracts, including where there is an endorsement.
The SCC also clarified the conditions for applying the nullification of coverage doctrine, which prevents an insurance policy from being applied in a way that would defeat the very purpose of the relevant coverage. While the doctrine can override even unambiguous contractual language, it applies only in the extreme and specific scenario where coverage is nullified, such that the insured enjoys virtually no benefit and the insurer bears no material risk.
Summary:
The two issues before the SCC were (1) whether a guaranteed rebuilding cost endorsement entitled the insured to full rebuilding costs despite an exclusion clause in the base policy and (2) whether the nullification of coverage doctrine should prevent the application of the exclusion clause.
Justice Rowe, writing for the majority, reaffirmed the order in which to interpret insurance contracts, as articulated by the SCC in Ledcor Construction Ltd. v. Northbridge Indemnity Insurance Co.2:
- The insured bears the onus to establish that the damage or loss falls within the initial grant of coverage.
- The insurer may then establish that an exclusion to coverage applies; and, if the insurer does so successfully.
- The insured may then invoke an exception to the exclusion.
Justice Rowe also reaffirmed the principles applicable to interpreting insurance policies. Where the insurance contract language is unambiguous, effect should be given to that clear contractual language. The contract must be read as a whole and by giving the words of the contract their ordinary and grammatical meaning.
Regarding the first issue, Justice Rowe emphasized that an endorsement (also known as a rider) is an amendment to an existing policy; it is not a self-contained and standalone contract, but, rather, a part of the underlying insurance policy. As such, the exclusion clause applied to the provision amended by the endorsement.
As for the second issue, Justice Rowe confirmed there is a high bar to establishing nullification of coverage. The doctrine was found not to apply given that the insured, despite the exclusion of extra compliance costs, enjoyed a benefit from the endorsement, namely being able to recover amounts exceeding the limit set under the base policy.
What’s on the docket?
In March, the SCC heard English Montreal School Board, et al. v. Attorney General of Quebec, et al.3 — the highly anticipated constitutional challenge of Quebec’s Bill 21, the secularism law that prohibits wearing visible religious symbols or clothing while working in certain public‑sector positions. The SCC will consider the Quebec government’s pre-emptive use of the notwithstanding clause, which allows legislatures to override certain Charter rights.
The SCC also recently heard St. John's International Airport Authority v. Michel Thibodeau,4 and is anticipated to provide further guidance on the obligations of airport authorities under the Official Languages Act (OLA), including clarifying the definition of “travelling public” in the context of a communication of service, and determining who is entitled to damages under the OLA.
The court also recently heard an appeal in which it will provide guidance on organizations’ safeguarding and consent obligations under the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act.5
In May, the SCC will hear Cynthia Prescott, et al. v. Benchwood Builders Inc., et al., wherein it will consider how defamation defenses and the Canadian principles against strategic lawsuits against public participation, also known as anti-SLAPP, are to be applied in the context of online consumer expression.6
The SCC has also recently granted leave in significant matters relating to vicarious liability, consumer protection in Quebec, and the availability of judicial review.
- In H.N. v. Board of Education of School District No. 61 (Greater Victoria), et al., the SCC will clarify the test for vicarious liability in the context of a sexual assault case. The SCC’s ruling will be relevant more broadly for institutions such as schools, insurers, and sports associations.
- In Consumers’ Union, et al. v. Air Canada, et al., the SCC will decide whether Quebec’s Consumer Protection Act creates a contractual obligation for merchants to honour prices as advertised and, if so, what remedies flow from a breach of that obligation.7
- In Canadian National Railway Company v. Alberta Pacific Forest Industries Inc., the SCC will address whether, and in what circumstances, Canadian Transportation Agency decisions are subject to judicial review.8
Follow the firm’s insights on appellate law to stay informed of the SCC’s latest activity. Should you have any questions about any of the above appeals, please contact a member of our appellate team.
The authors would like to thank Manreet Brar and Thomas Roussel, articling students, for their contribution to preparing this legal update.