The Supreme Court of Canada recently heard the appeal in R. v. Arapakota, marking the court’s first opportunity to weigh in on the interpretation of the bribery offence under the Corruption of Foreign Public Officials Act (CFPOA).

Our October 2025 update reported on the Ontario Court of Appeal's decision, which provided significant guidance on the meaning of “as consideration for” and “advantage in the course of business,” two core elements of the CFPOA foreign bribery offence.

Background

Mr. Arapakota was the founder and former CEO of Imex Systems Inc., a Canadian software development company. While pursuing a multi-million-dollar contract with the Government of Botswana, he organized and prepaid, in late 2015, an approximately $40,000 family vacation to the United States for Dr. Kereteletswe, a senior Botswanan government official.

In December 2015 and January 2016, Dr. Kereteletswe signed three letters confirming Botswana’s intention to award Imex a three-year US$30 million contract. Although no such contract ever materialized, the expenditures on the US trip came to light and led Imex to conduct an internal investigation into Mr. Arapakota’s expenses. The matter was reported to the RCMP, resulting in a single charge under s. 3(1)(a) of the CFPOA against Mr. Arapakota.

The first instance and appeal decisions

The Ontario Superior Court acquitted Mr. Arapakota, marking the first acquittal in a prosecution under the CFPOA. The trial judge found that Mr. Arapakota had conferred a material benefit on a foreign public official by organizing and prepaying various expenses associated with the US trip. However, the trial judge concluded the Crown failed to establish that the benefit was provided as a quid pro quo for the letters issued by the Government of Botswana, i.e. a reciprocal exchange of benefits. The trial judge further found that those letters did not constitute a material economic advantage for Mr. Arapakota’s business interests, as required under s. 3(1)(a) of the CFPOA.

A majority of the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the acquittal. The majority held that, while the trial judge erred in requiring proof of a link between the benefit offered or given to a foreign public official and a specific act or an omission by that person, s. 3(1)(a) of the CFPOA nonetheless "unequivocally requires that the Crown prove that the person offering the bribe to a foreign official intended to benefit from an act or omission in return" – that is, a contemplated quid pro quo within the scope of the official’s duties.

The majority further upheld the trial judge’s conclusion that the letter did not constitute a material economic advantage. Justice Monahan, dissenting, would have allowed the appeal, set aside the acquittal and ordered a new trial.

Quid pro quo as a necessary element of the offence under s. 3(1)(a) cfpoa

Given Justice Monahan’s dissent, the Crown appealed as of right to the Supreme Court of Canada, affording the country’s highest court its first opportunity to provide guidance on the interpretation of s. 3(1)(a) of the CFPOA.

The principal issue before the Supreme Court of Canada concerns whether the Crown must establish a contractual-type quid pro quo – a "something for something."

The Crown characterizes the appeal as presenting the court’s first opportunity to correct what it describes as an overly strict and technical interpretation of the CFPOA bribery offence. In its view, s. 3(1)(a) of the CFPOA does not require proof of a contractual-type quid pro quo; rather, it is sufficient that the person offering the benefit intended, or at least contemplated, that the foreign public official would exercise his or her influence in some manner to advance the accused’s business interests.

The relevance of the OECD convention in interpreting the CFPOA

This appeal permits the court to examine the relevance of the OECD Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions (the OECD Convention) in interpreting the CFPOA.

The CFPOA was enacted in 1999 as a result of Canada’s ratification of the OECD Convention. Where a statute implements a treaty without qualification, the interpretation of the statute needs to be wholly consistent with Canada’s obligations under the treaty. In its appeal, the Crown argues that interpreting s. 3(1)(a) of the CFPOA as not requiring proof that the public official accepted, acted upon, or conferred a benefit in return constitutes a purposive interpretation that accords with both the clear legislative intent and Canada’s treaty obligations.

Potential consequences and significance

As this will mark the Supreme Court’s first interpretation of the CFPOA, its decision will define the threshold for the principal foreign bribery offence in Canadian law. A Crown-favourable reading would significantly expand the scope of prosecutorial reach by capturing benefits conferred with only a generalized expectation that the official will advance the briber’s business interests, while also easing the evidentiary burden in cases that turn on circumstantial proof of intent, which is often the case in corruption cases (both domestic and foreign).

For regulatory and compliance teams, companies with international operations may need to recalibrate their anti-corruption policies, including those governing gifts and donations, particularly in jurisdictions where relationship-based business development is prevalent. In this context, internal investigations will remain central to identifying and managing CFPOA-related risk.

Whatever the outcome, the Arapakota case will be the foundational appellate authority on the CFPOA's principal offence. We continue to monitor the appeal closely and will provide a further update once the Supreme Court of Canada releases its decision.

Contact