On April 13, the Alberta Court of King’s Bench released a significant decision in 1951789 Alberta Ltd. v Britannia Block General Partnership Inc., overturning a lower court ruling and reinstating a security that had been posted in lieu of a builders’ lien. The decision offers important guidance on the scope and application of sections 46 and 48 of the Prompt Payment and Construction Lien Act (PPCLA), and in particular, the distinction between a lien and the security that replaces it.
For owners, contractors, and lien claimants alike, this case is a timely reminder that not all statutory remedies are interchangeable — and courts should look at the full picture before disturbing a posted security.
Background
The dispute arose from a residential project in Alberta. The appellant, 1951789 Alberta Ltd., operating as Urban Interiors Group (UIG), supplied materials and labour to Britannia Block General Partnership Inc. and claimed it was not being paid.1 In February 2020, UIG registered a builders’ lien for $1.47 million (the Lien), followed by a statement of claim and certificate of lis pendens (the CLP)2 — a notice registered on title to alert third parties the property is the subject of litigation.
The parties subsequently agreed to discharge the Lien and CLP. In exchange, Britannia posted $1.6 million in security with the clerk of the court (the Security).3 Years of litigation followed, but the underlying dispute remained unresolved. Britannia eventually applied to vacate or reduce the Security.4
At a hearing in 2025, the applications judge (the Hearing Judge) considered two questions: first, whether the facts justified reducing the Security, and second, on the Hearing Judge’s own motion, whether section 46(2) of the PPCLA authorized vacating the Security entirely.5 The Hearing Judge concluded a reduction was not warranted but found section 46(2) could be applied by analogy, reasoning the parties were well past the statutory two-year mark for setting this matter for trial.6 UIG appealed, and the Court of King’s Bench allowed the appeal, reinstating the Security in the amount of $1.41 million.7
Strict statutory interpretation: Liens are creatures of statute
A central theme of the decision is that builders’ liens are creatures of statute — meaning their creation, enforcement, and discharge are governed entirely by legislation, not common law.
Relying on Factors Western Inc. v DCR Inc., the court emphasized the PPCLA provisions “should be interpreted strictly.”8 The statute’s provisions operate collectively, not in isolation, and must be given a practical interpretation that balances the interests of all parties.9 Extending those provisions by analogy, the court held, would undermine the strict nature of the statute and run contrary to its intended purpose.10
The court also noted a significant procedural concern: neither party had relied on section 46(2) as a basis for relief. The Hearing Judge raised it on their own motion, without notice, depriving UIG of a fair opportunity to respond. Accordingly, the court concluded that the Hearing Judge erred in applying section 46(2) to vacate the Security.
The critical distinction: Lien vs. security
At the heart of the appeal was the distinction between a lien and the security that replaces it. Section 46(2) of the PPCLA empowers a court to vacate a CLP and discharge a lien if no trial has been held within two years of registration.11
However, the court found this provision does not extend to a security posted in lieu of a lien under section 48.12 The reasoning is straightforward: once the Lien and CLP had been discharged and replaced by the Security, there was simply no lien or CLP remaining for section 46(2) to operate upon.13 The court drew a bright line between these instruments, holding that statutory mechanisms designed to govern liens under section 46(2) cannot be applied — even by analogy — to a security posted under section 48 of the PPCLA.
Discretion requires a holistic assessment of delay
Even assuming section 46(2) applied, the court confirmed it confers a discretionary power, not a mandatory one.14 When the provision is triggered — which the court noted is rare — the parties must be given a meaningful opportunity to explain any delay.15
As observed in 1361556 Alberta Ltd. v Ristorante Cosa Nostra Inc., the threshold “generally does not require too much in way of explanation, but there must be some explanation.”16 Here, UIG was afforded no such opportunity.17 The court examined the procedural record and found it provided sufficient proof that the delay was not the result of inaction or abandonment.18 Citing Whitson Contracting Ltd. v Pacific West Systems Supply Ltd., the court concluded, “To the extent that the convoluted procedural history makes this a borderline delay case, the default should be to let it continue.”19
In other words, where litigation has been genuinely complex, courts should be slow to penalize parties for delays that arise from the inherent difficulties of the dispute itself.
Key takeaways for lien claimants and property owners
This decision reinforces several critical principles under the PPCLA. First, security posted in lieu of a lien under section 48 is not automatically subject to the two-year timeline in section 46(2). Once a lien and CLP have been discharged and replaced by posted security, section 46(2) ceases to apply — the security stands as a distinct instrument governed by its own statutory framework, namely the Rules of Court.
Second, this ruling does not give lien claimants carte blanche to delay. Courts retain broad discretion to assess and weigh the reasons for delay, and the mere passage of time will not, on its own, be sufficient to vacate a security. Courts will take a holistic view, examining the full procedural record to distinguish genuine inaction or abandonment from delays attributable to the inherent complexities of the dispute.
For industry participants, the message is clear: understand the distinct legal treatment of liens and their securities and ensure claims are advanced diligently — even when the litigation becomes complex. Where delays are unavoidable, maintaining a clear procedural record will be essential to demonstrating that the claim remains actively pursued.
The author would like to thank Claire Han, articling student, for her contribution to preparing this legal update.
Footnotes
-
1951789 Alberta Ltd v Britannia Block General Partnership Inc, ABKB 2026 283 at para 1.
-
Ibid at para 2.
-
Ibid.
-
Ibid at para 22.
-
Ibid at para 24.
-
Ibid.
-
Ibid at para 4.
-
Ibid at para 40.
-
Ibid at para 39.
-
Ibid at para 40.
-
Prompt Payment and Construction Lien Act, RSA 2000, c P-26.4 at s 46(2).
-
Supra note 1 at para 43.
-
Ibid at para 41.
-
Ibid at para 44 citing Whitson Contracting Ltd v Pacific West Systems Supply Ltd, 2023 ABKB 309 at para 34 [Whitson Contracting].
-
Ibid at para 45.
-
1361556 Alberta Ltd v Ristorante Cosa Nostra Inc, 2021 ABQB 157 at paras 34-37.
-
Supra note 1 at para 46.
-
Ibid at paras 49 and 52.
-
Ibid at para 52 citing Whitson Contracting at para 36.