Using hateful, harassing, derogatory, discriminatory, and otherwise hurtful language (collectively referred to as “hateful speech” in this update) in the workplace1 harms not only the individuals targeted but also the broader workplace. Hateful speech can be traumatic for individuals and is corrosive to overall psychological safety and inclusion in an organization.
When hateful speech is used, employers have a range of duties to fulfill. These include investigating the incident to determine what occurred, assessing and mitigating the impact on those subjected to or who witnessed the speech, and imposing appropriate discipline on the speaker. These obligations arise under occupational health and safety legislation, human rights legislation and the common law.
Employees who engage in hateful speech at work often attempt to minimize or justify their conduct. However, these excuses do not relieve employers of their duty to respond appropriately when such speech has been used in the workplace.
Use of hateful speech in the workplace should attract disciplinary consequences, but the appropriate degree of discipline is context specific. This legal update examines factors influencing appropriate discipline.
Discipline for hateful speech
Judges and adjudicators are increasingly treating hateful speech in the workplace as a serious offence that can justify summary dismissal in both unionized and non-unionized workplaces.
For example, in the arbitration context such conduct has been grouped alongside other egregious workplace offences such as theft, sexual assault, and deliberate sabotage. These forms of misconduct so seriously undermine the essential trust in the employment relationship that termination without notice may be appropriate even for a first offence by a long-service employee.
However, summary dismissal is not automatic even where some discipline is justified. The employer’s disciplinary response should reflect the severity of the incident in issue.
How egregious was the speech in issue? Can others feel safe and respected if the employee remains in the workplace after suitable discipline and training?
Adjudicators are clear on one point – intention to hurt is not a prerequisite to discipline or termination of employment. The absence of an intention to offend does not negate the impact a comment may have on those who hear it. It is the act of using hateful language that warrants discipline, regardless of the speaker's motive.
Lack of insight by employees into the impact of their speech is a significant aggravating factor. Similarly, a lack of accountability in the form of refusal to sincerely apologize also weighs in favour of summary dismissal. Both these factors indicate the employee cannot be trusted to work safely and respectfully.
While summary dismissal, or “just cause,” may be a reasonable response, decision makers have also found that discipline short of dismissal is appropriate in some cases. For example, in one decision an arbitrator suggested lesser discipline may be appropriate where:
- The act arises in the context of a “momentary flare up”.
- The employee has no similar prior incidents.
- The employee makes a timely and genuine apology to those impacted.
- The employee demonstrates genuine remorse that restores confidence the employee is unlikely to reoffend.
In all cases, an employer’s response to any reported incident of hateful speech should be determined after an investigation has determined what was said, the context in which it was said, the state of mind of the person who uttered the words, and the impact the words have had on others in the workplace. A zero-tolerance policy that dictates summary dismissal in all cases will not be blindly adopted by an adjudicator.
Hateful speech cannot be explained away
Employees who engage in hateful speech at work often attempt to minimize or justify their conduct. However, the days of characterizing such speech as mere “shop talk” are long gone. There are no excuses for hateful speech in the workplace and employers should not accept attempts to explain away this type of misconduct.
Employers are typically supported by adjudicators in rejecting attempts to minimize incidents of hateful speech:
- "It was a private conversation." Discipline is appropriate when hateful speech is used in a manner that allows it to be overheard in the workplace. Employee claims that they did not intend for others to hear the speech is not a valid defense.
- "I was just quoting song lyrics" or "I was criticizing offensive content." Using a slur at work can be misconduct—even when quoting or criticizing something from TV, music, or other media. Whether the slur is directed at someone or simply repeated during discussion, discipline can follow.
- "I am a member of a minority group, so it's acceptable for me to use these terms." The concept of "linguistic reappropriation," whereby minority groups reclaim previously offensive terms, does not extend to members of other groups. Adjudicators have explicitly rejected the argument that being a member of one minority group entitles an individual to use slurs offensive to another group.
- "I didn't say the actual slur; I used a similar but less offensive word." Adjudicators have rejected this argument, holding that variations among slurs do not diminish the severity of the misconduct.
- “It was a joke” or “…that is the workplace culture.” A permissive environment does not insulate employees from being culpable for use of hateful speech. Even in workplaces where coarse humour or vulgar language is normalized, conduct directed at individual employees may still constitute harassment or discrimination—particularly when such conduct is degrading or racial in nature.
Recommendations for employers
Disciplining employees for using hateful speech in the workplace is only one component of fostering a safe work environment free from hateful language. Other measures include:
- Adopting respectful workplace policies.
- Training employees on respectful workplace conduct and reporting procedures.
- Training management on setting expectations and responding to incidents of hateful speech when they occur.
- Adopting reporting mechanisms and investigation procedures.
- Investigating incidents of hateful speech and applying appropriate disciplinary consequences.
- Taking steps following incidents of hateful speech to address the harms caused, to educate employees on the impacts of such speech, and to train employees against using such speech in the future.
By taking these proactive and responsive measures, employers can better fulfill their legal obligations while fostering a workplace culture where all employees are treated with dignity and respect.
If you are an employer dealing with an incident of hateful or discriminatory speech in your workplace and would like guidance on investigation, discipline, or managing human rights risk, please contact the authors of this update or another member of our employment and labour team.
Footnotes
-
Although a detailed analysis is beyond the scope of this update, the definition of "workplace" can be expansive depending on the circumstances. “Workplace” may include work-related social events, business travel, and online communications between colleagues. As a result, employers may bear responsibility for addressing hateful speech in settings that extend well beyond the company's primary physical premises.