Earn-outs help bridge valuation gaps but often fuel post-closing disputes, especially over acceleration when the buyer sells or reorganizes assets during the earn-out period. Ontario’s Project Freeway decisions1 declined to accelerate an earn-out where the buyer completed sale-leasebacks and receivables factoring, emphasizing that “materiality” depends on whether the transaction affects the earn-out metrics, not simply the size of the assets involved. This legal update analyses what these decisions mean for Québec M&A.
See our legal update summarizing the Ontario Court of Appeal’s decision in Project Freeway Inc. v ABC Technologies Inc. and our takeaways.
What Ontario’s Project Freeway decisions signal for deals governed by Québec law
Although the decision is not binding in Québec, the reasoning is consistent with Québec’s contractual interpretation rules and good-faith obligations. In practice, the same analytical framework would very likely apply.
Québec’s interpretation rules point to an effects-based reading
In Québec, courts are required to seek the common intention of the parties and interpret clauses in light of the nature of the contract, the circumstances in which it was formed, the interpretation that has already been given to it by the parties or that it may have received, and usage. Contracts must be read as coherent economic instruments and the context must be relied upon where text alone is insufficient.
These rules support an effects based analysis for M&A provisions such as earn out clauses. Ambiguous terms (such as “material” in this case) are resolved contextually. This supports an interpretation focused on whether a transaction impairs the earn-out mechanism, not its simple monetary magnitude.
Good faith in performance is a powerful Québec overlay
In Québec, parties must act in good faith at all stages of performance. Courts may intervene where a party takes steps that undermine the intended economic balance of the earn-out. This framework supports refusing acceleration where ordinary-course financing steps do not harm the performance metrics, and conversely, supports remedies where a buyer’s actions undermine the seller’s ability to achieve the earn-out.
Entire agreement clauses do not bar surrounding circumstances
If the share purchase agreement (SPA) is ambiguous, Québec courts may examine letters of intent (LOI), term sheets and negotiations to determine common intention, despite an entire agreement clause. This mirrors how Ontario courts considered the LOI in Project Freeway.
Practical implications for Québec law deals
- Define “material” precisely: If the trigger is meant to be size based, specify thresholds. If it is effects based, tie materiality expressly to the earn-out metrics.
- Enumerate included/excluded triggers: List transactions that do or do not cause acceleration, such as sale-leasebacks, receivables factoring, inventory monetization or internal reorganizations.
- Align (or consciously depart from) the LOI: Ensure the SPA either confirms or expressly departs from LOI language to avoid unintended reliance on preliminary documents.
- Consider express good-faith guardrails: Add tailored provisions reinforcing that steps intended to circumvent earn-out attainment breach the bargain.
- Expect persuasive influence from Project Freeway: While not binding, the decision reflects modern interpretive trends consistent with Québec methodology.
Bottom line
Unless the SPA clearly makes the size of a transaction effected during the earn-out period determinative, Québec courts are likely to ask whether the transaction in question and the buyer’s post-closing actions impair the seller’s ability to achieve the earn-out. Sale-leasebacks and receivables factoring that leave earn-out metrics intact should not trigger acceleration. Clear thresholds, detailed trigger lists and thoughtful integration of LOIs can significantly reduce disputes.
The NRF team is available to assist you in drafting clear and precise contracts that achieve your business objectives.
Footnotes
-
Project Freeway Inc v ABC Technologies Inc, 2025 ONSC 1048 and Project Freeway Inc v ABC Technologies Inc, 2025 ONCA 855.