In Afan Valley Ltd & Ors v Lupton Fawcett LLP [2026] EWCA Civ 2, the Court of Appeal unanimously held that a solicitor’s negligent advice did not cause the claimant’s loss. The judgment illustrates the principle that a professional is not liable for all the losses which a claimant sustains as a result of acting on their negligent advice, but only for those within the scope of their duty. Liability is limited to losses sufficiently connected with the advice provided and does not extend to wider issues such as commercial risks or the viability of a transaction if the professional was not instructed to advise on such matters.

Background and High Court decision

The claim for professional negligence was brought by the joint administrators of 43 insolvent companies (the Claimants) against a firm of solicitors, Lupton Fawcett LLP (the Defendant). The companies were involved in investment schemes involving the sale of units in hotels, care homes and student accommodation; they were special purpose vehicles incorporated to receive the funding for each scheme. The schemes all failed and in 2019 the Claimants went into administration. It was alleged by the Claimants that the schemes had been operating as a dishonest ‘Ponzi’ scheme.

The Defendant had been instructed to advise on whether the schemes constituted collective investment schemes (CISs) under s.235 and s.417(1) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA). The Claimants alleged that the Defendant had negligently failed to advise the Claimants that the schemes were CISs. CISs can only be carried out by a business authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), as to do so is a regulated activity. As the Claimants were not FCA-authorised, the consequences under s.26 FSMA applied and the Claimants were required to reimburse the money they had received from investors. The Claimants argued that they would not have gone ahead with the investments had they been advised sooner that the schemes were, or could have been, CISs and would not have incurred a liability to investors under s.26 FSMA totalling around £63 million.

The Defendant applied to strike out the claim against it on the basis that, even if negligence were established (which it denied), the Claimants would be unable to prove any recoverable loss. The High Court agreed with the Defendant, struck out the claim and granted summary judgment against the Claimants. The Claimants appealed.

Court of Appeal decision

As this was an application for summary judgment, the Court of Appeal proceeded on the assumption that the underlying facts were as the Claimants alleged. The Claimants advanced three grounds of appeal, namely that the High Court was wrong to:

  1. decide that the claims should be struck out on the basis that the Claimants failed to establish any recoverable loss;
  2. decide that the Claimants’ losses were not attributable to the Defendant’s alleged negligence; and
  3. apply the test for summary judgment, rather the Claimants had a real prospect of demonstrating that there were relevant losses.

Recoverable loss

The Court of Appeal struck out the claim on the basis that there was no loss caused by the breach. The Court of Appeal accepted the Defendant’s central “£ in £ out” argument, i.e. that the Claimants had to return the same amount of money to their investors as they had received to make the investments and were therefore no worse off. The payment of commissions to sales agents and legal and professional fees, which the Claimants argued left them in a worse position, had nothing to do with whether the schemes were CISs or not. The Court of Appeal confirmed that the fact that the Claimants might (or would, to the knowledge of the Defendant) make these payments did not mean that the costs to the Claimants of doing so were within the risks of harm for which the Defendant was responsible.

The scope of duty

The Court of Appeal considered the rules around the scope of the duty of care in negligence. A defendant found to be in breach of a duty of care is not liable for all the losses which the claimant sustained as a result of acting on their advice, but only for those within the scope of their duty (known as the “SAAMCO test”). Applying the scope of duty analysis as most recently set out in Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton [2021] UKSC 20, the Court of Appeal confirmed that the fact that the Defendant had been asked to advise if the schemes were CISs only meant that a duty of care was owed in respect of that question.

The Defendant argued that its duty did not extend to advising on the wider commercial benefits, the risks of pursuing the investment schemes, or whether the schemes were dishonest or operated as a ‘Ponzi’ structure. Nor was it liable for any losses caused by commissions, professional fees or scheme failure. As the consequences of the schemes being CISs were limited to those under s.26 FSMA, the “£ in £ out” argument discussed above applied and the remaining losses flowing from the schemes did not fall within the scope of the Defendant’s duties.

The Court held that the “sufficient nexus” test set out in Manchester Building Society could be dealt with through a counterfactual analysis: whether the loss would have been suffered if the advice had been correct. Here, the payment of commissions and fees would still have been incurred under this counterfactual and so were not recoverable.

Summary judgment

The Court of Appeal held that the claim had no real prospect of success, dismissed the professional negligence claim and upheld the High Court’s decision to strike out on the basis that the Claimants had failed to demonstrate any recoverable loss.

Key takeaways

This case illustrates the application of the scope of duty test in professional negligence claims and that professional liability is limited to losses with a “sufficient nexus” to the legal advice sought. Courts will look at the net economic position and not at isolated liabilities, which limits the attempts of insolvent companies shifting responsibility for failed or fraudulent investment schemes onto professional advisers. Professional advisers will not be held generally responsible for the commercial risks taken by a client.

With thanks to Megan Lyttelton for her assistance in preparing this post.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post