The Court of Appeal of the Unified Patent Court (Court of Appeal) has clarified in Belkin v. Philips fundamental principles for interpreting the term “infringer” under Article 63 of the Agreement on a Unified Patent Court (UPCA). At the heart of the decision lies the question of under which conditions managing directors of a company accused of patent infringement may be held personally liable as infringer. The Court of Appeal formulates stringent requirements for individual responsibility and draws a clear distinction between personal liability and a mere corporate office.
Facts of the case
The claimant brought infringement proceedings before the Munich Local Division against the defendant companies and their managing directors, alleging infringement of European Patent 2 867 997 concerning an inductive power transfer system (for example, charging stations for mobile devices). The defendants filed a counterclaim for revocation.
The Munich Local Division issued an injunction against the companies and found the companies liable for rendering of accounts and damages and published the judgment. The managing directors were held liable as intermediaries for injunctive relief.
On appeal, the defendants sought dismissal of the action and revocation of the patent. The claimant additionally sought to hold the managing directors liable for damages and rendering of accounts.
Legal background
Article 63(1) UPCA permits the court to issue injunctions against an “infringer”, and likewise against intermediaries whose services are used by third parties to infringe a patent. No fault requirement is required. However, the UPCA does not define either “infringer” or “intermediary.”
Article 25 UPCA entitles a patent proprietor to prohibit third parties from using the invention – for example, by making, offering, or placing infringing products on the market. In combination, Articles 25 and 63 UPCA aim to prevent all unauthorised use of the invention.
Neither the UPCA nor EU law contains rules on the personal liability of managing directors. By contrast, under established German case law, managing directors may be held personally liable due to their organisational responsibilities and duties to safeguard third‑party rights.
Decision of the Court of Appeal
In its judgment of 3 October 2025 (Case No. UPC_CoA_534/2024), the Court of Appeal rejected automatic personal liability of managing directors as infringers or intermediaries.
Definition of “Infringer”
The Court of Appeal first undertook a detailed analysis of the concept of the primary patent infringer and the various possible forms of participation in an infringement. In doing so, it interpreted these terms autonomously under European Union law – that is, without reference to national legal sources.
According to the Court, a primary infringer within the meaning of Article 63(1) UPCA is any third party under Article 25 UPCA who directly or indirectly exercises control over the infringing use and is therefore in a position to terminate the use and comply with a court order.
The Court further clarified that the term infringer is not limited to the acts of use listed in Article 25 UPCA. It also encompasses any person to whom the acts of the primary infringer can be attributed as an instigator, joint perpetrator or aider and abettor.
With respect to joint perpetration, the Court of Appeal said that this concept required that those responsible for the patent‑infringing act co-operate on the basis of a shared plan, executing the infringing conduct in a co-ordinated and complementary manner. A person qualifies as an aider and abettor if they support the infringing acts of a third party and have knowledge of the patent infringement. The requisite knowledge is not satisfied merely by awareness of the factual circumstances (for example, the offering of an infringing product) from which the infringement arises. Instead, there must also be an awareness of the illegality of the conduct - namely, that the act in question (such as offering the product) constitutes a patent infringement.
No automatic liability of managing directors
With respect to the personal liability of managing directors, the Court of Appeal found that a managing director does not become a joint perpetrator or aider and abettor of a patent infringement merely by virtue of holding office in the infringing company, particularly where the director has no control over the relevant acts.
According to the Court, the decisive question is whether the patent‑infringing acts under Article 25 UPCA can be attributed to the managing director as an instigator, joint perpetrator or aider and abettor. Such attribution cannot be based solely on the director’s general duties of conduct in commerce, as these obligations attach to the legal entity (here, the GmbH), not to the director personally. A personal duty to answer for the infringement therefore does not arise merely from general managerial, supervisory or organisational responsibilities.
However, the Court considered that personal liability is possible where the director’s conduct goes beyond ordinary managerial functions. This may be the case where the director deliberately uses the company to commit patent infringements, or where the director has actual knowledge of the infringement and it is both reasonable and feasible for the director to prevent it. Such knowledge requires both awareness of the factual circumstances giving rise to the infringement and awareness of the illegality of the conduct. If the director has obtained legal advice on the infringement issue, the director may rely on that advice until a first‑instance infringement judgment is issued against the company.
The Court further rejected personal liability of managing directors as intermediaries, holding that a director is not a “third party” in relation to their own company and therefore cannot qualify as an intermediary under Article 63 UPCA.
Observations and the future
The Court of Appeal’s decision provides clear guidance on the conditions under which managing directors may be held personally liable for patent infringement. Managing directors will no longer be deemed liable per se by virtue of their corporate position; liability now requires actual knowledge of both the patent infringing act and its unlawfulness.
In future proceedings before the Unified Patent Court, it will therefore be essential - where a managing director is sued alongside the company - to present detailed submissions establishing the director’s personal involvement or knowledge. The Court of Appeal has set a very high threshold, particularly because a managing director may rely on competent legal advice to disclaim responsibility until a first instance infringement judgment is issued against the company.
If the patent proprietor nonetheless has a heightened interest in securing a judgment against the managing director personally, alternative strategic avenues must be considered. One option may be to initiate separate national proceedings, for example before a German civil court based on a corresponding German national patent. As there is no prohibition on double protection between a unitary patent and a national German patent, parallel enforcement based on a substantively identical patent remains possible - provided the proprietor has adopted an appropriate filing strategy in advance.