Declared, but not managed
Probity, and in particular the management of conflicts of interest, is an important consideration in Commonwealth Government procurement, where transparency, accountability and ethical conduct are essential to maintaining public confidence within procurement processes.
Probity in procurement has several elements, including the equitable treatment of suppliers, appropriate management of conflicts of interest, the protection of confidential information and the proper use of public resources. Of these, the identification, disclosure and continued management of conflicts of interest throughout the procurement lifecycle is among the most significant, because a conflict goes directly to whether a decision was made on its merits. It is also the element on which this article focuses.
Having probity processes in place is not, however, the same as having processes that work. Probity arrangements need to be tailored to the scale and risk of the procurement, grounded in the Commonwealth procurement framework and capable of showing how each risk was dealt with. A ‘tick a box’ approach, where declarations are collected and filed but never adequately assessed, will not meet those expectations. Recent findings of the Australian National Audit Office (ANAO) suggest many Commonwealth entities have some way to go. In one department’s procurement activities, 13 of the 14 engagements the ANAO examined in detail had no probity plan, and in at least five procurements, declared conflicts had no documented management strategy.Australian National Audit Office, Procurement and Contract Management by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade for its Security Enhancement Program (Auditor-General Report No 25 of 2025–26, 18 March 2026)
The Commonwealth Procurement Rules (CPRs), together with the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth) (PGPA Act) and other relevant legislation and policies, establish a framework for ethical procurement and the proper management of conflicts of interest. As the ANAO’s findings show, complying with that framework requires entities to move beyond disclosure, to actively assessing and managing identified conflicts.
Understanding probity and conflicts of interest in Commonwealth procurement
The Department of Finance describes probity as ‘the evidence of ethical behaviour’ and as ‘complete and confirmed integrity, uprightness and honesty in a particular process’, and emphasises the importance of identifying and managing conflicts of interest.Department of Finance, 'Ethics and Probity in Procurement' A conflict of interest arises where an individual’s personal interests conflict, or have the potential to conflict, with their responsibilities. Conflicts may also arise where circumstances create a perception that an individual’s impartiality may be compromised.
Conflicts are generally categorised as:
- Actual conflicts: situations where an individual’s private interests presently conflict with their official duties.
- Potential conflicts: situations where an individual’s private interests have the capacity to conflict with their official duties.
- Perceived conflicts: situations where a reasonable person might perceive that an individual’s private interests could improperly influence the performance of their official duties.
Conflicts may arise through an individual’s previous employment with a tenderer, financial interests in a supplier, close personal relationships, or offers of gifts, hospitality or future employment. For example, an official involved in evaluating tenders might have previously worked for a tenderer or may have a close personal relationship with a supplier representative. The existence of a conflict does not, of itself, indicate misconduct. However, failing to disclose it can prevent timely assessment and management of the associated risks. It can also create a perception that a relevant interest has been deliberately concealed, even where no improper influence has occurred. Early disclosure allows the conflict to be assessed transparently and appropriate safeguards to be put in place.
For Commonwealth procurement, the key issue is whether the interest creates a risk to the integrity of the procurement and, if so, what measures are necessary to manage that risk.
What the Framework requires
Commonwealth Procurement Rules
-
The CPRs, issued by the Finance Minister under section 105B(1) of the PGPA Act, establish the Commonwealth’s procurement policy framework and require officials to act ethically throughout the procurement process. Ethical behaviour under the CPRs encompasses honesty, integrity, probity, diligence, fairness and consistency, and includes identifying and managing conflicts of interest.
Department of Finance, Commonwealth Procurement Rules (17 November 2025) [6.5]. -
The CPRs were updated in 2026 and the Department of Finance issued four procurement policy notes in June 2026.
-
The CPRs include:
- dealing with potential tenderers and suppliers equitably (including by seeking internal or external advice when probity issues arise),
- carefully considering the use of public resources;
- complying with all directions in relation to gifts or hospitality,
- abiding by the Australian Privacy Principles (APPs) in the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) and the security provisions of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth).
-
Officials undertaking procurement must also seek to prevent corrupt practices by recognising and dealing with actual, potential and perceived conflicts of interest and not accepting inappropriate gifts or hospitality.
Ibid [6.7]-[6.8].
Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth)
- Section 29 of the PGPA Act requires officials to disclose material personal interests relating to the affairs of their entity. This sits alongside the general duties in sections 25 to 28, including to act with care and diligence, to act honestly, in good faith and for a proper purpose, and not to misuse their position or information.
Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth) ss 25–29. - Section 16 of the PGPA Act also requires accountable authorities to establish and maintain appropriate systems of risk oversight, management and internal control.
- In addition, section 10 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Rule 2014 (Cth) (PGPA Rule) requires accountable authorities to take all reasonable measures to prevent, detect and deal with fraud and corruption relating to their entity, including through fraud and corruption risk assessments and control plans. Conflict of interest management forms part of those control plans.
Ibid s 16; Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Rule 2014 (Cth) s 10. - Other relevant instruments include section 13 of the PGPA Rule, which requires officials who are not members of the accountable authority to disclose material personal interests in accordance with instructions issued by the accountable authority.
Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Rule 2014 (Cth) s 13.
Public Service Act 1999 (Cth)
- Section 10 of the Public Service Act 1999 (Cth) sets out the APS values, which include objectivity, ethical behaviour, accountability, and impartiality.
- Section 13 of the Public Service Act sets out the APS Code of Conduct. Subsection 13(7) expressly obliges APS employees to take reasonable steps to avoid real or apparent conflicts of interest and to disclose material personal interests connected with their employment.
Public Service Act 1999 (Cth) s 13(7).
National Anti-Corruption Commission Act 2022 (Cth)
- This Act defines corrupt conduct as including a public official’s breach of public trust or abuse of office~~National Anti-Corruption Commission Act 2022 (Cth) s 8(1)(a)-(c).~~, as well as conduct of any person (including a supplier) that could adversely affect the honest or impartial exercise of a public official’s powers or functions.
- The Commissioner’s investigative function is directed to corruption issues that could involve corrupt conduct that is serious or systemic. A declared but unmanaged conflict will not of itself amount to corrupt conduct; however, an unmanaged conflict that influences a procurement outcome may attract scrutiny.
Government Procurement (Judicial Review) Act 2018 (Cth)
- The Government Procurement (Judicial Review) Act 2018 (Cth) (GPJR Act) allows a supplier whose interests are affected to complain to the accountable authority about a contravention of the ‘relevant Commonwealth Procurement Rules’ in a covered procurement~~GPJR Act s 18.~~ , and to apply to the Federal Court or the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) for an injunction or compensation.
GPJR Act ss 9, 16.On receiving a complaint, the accountable authority must investigate and, unless a public interest certificate is in force, suspend the procurement.GPJR Act ss 19–20, 22. - The CPR obligation to recognise and deal with actual, potential and perceived conflicts of interest is declared to be a relevant provision for these purposes, as is the obligation to maintain documentation commensurate with the scale, scope and risk of the procurement.
Department of Finance, Commonwealth Procurement Rules (17 November 2025) [6.11], declaring [6.8] and [7.2] (among others) to be relevant provisions for the purposes of GPJR Act s 4.A poorly managed or undocumented conflict may result in a supplier complaint, suspension of the procurement and court proceedings.
Department of Finance Guidance
- The Department of Finance publishes guidance on ethics and probity in procurement to assist Commonwealth entities in applying the CPRs.
Department of Finance (n 1). - Depending on the scale, complexity and risk profile of a procurement, appropriate probity arrangements will typically include a procurement-specific probity plan, conflict of interest declarations, confidentiality undertakings and protocols governing communications with suppliers.
- For complex or sensitive procurements, entities should consider whether independent probity advice is appropriate, weighing the benefit of advice independent of the process against the additional cost and whether the necessary skills exist within the entity.
Australian National Audit Office, Procurement and Contract Management by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade for its Security Enhancement Program (Auditor-General Report No 25 of 2025–26, 18 March 2026) [3.33], quoting Department of Finance (n 1).Probity advisers may assist in identifying risks, developing management strategies and reviewing compliance with processes. While engaging a probity adviser is beneficial, responsibility for ethically conducting the procurement remains with the Commonwealth entity and its officials.
Recent ANAO findings: Lessons from a Departmental procurement audit
The importance of actively managing probity and conflicts of interest was highlighted in a recent ANAO performance audit.Ibid [1.15]–[1.16]. The audit examined whether a Commonwealth government department had effectively conducted procurements associated with a significant capital program, and whether it had complied with the CPRs.
The ANAO concluded that the department had not conducted procurements to the ethical behaviour standards required by the CPRs.Ibid [18].
Key findings
Of the 14 engagements the ANAO examined in detail:
- Probity plans were absent for 13 engagements (93 per cent).
- Probity advisers were appointed for only five engagements.
Ibid [18]. - There were insufficient conflict of interest declarations covering evaluation processes for 13 of the 14 engagements.
The ANAO also identified instances where conflicts had been declared but the department’s records did not demonstrate whether any steps had been taken to manage the associated risks.
In at least five procurements, the ANAO found no documented management strategies for declared conflicts. These included evaluation panel members who had existing dealings or previous employment relationships with potential suppliers.Ibid [3.41]–[3.42].
What can Commonwealth entities learn?
The common thread is a gap between declaration and action. Without documented management action, an entity will struggle to show that a conflict was considered at all, particularly where the individual has an existing relationship with a supplier or significant influence over the outcome.
The findings suggest a question Commonwealth entities should ask at the outset of every procurement: if this procurement were subject to audit, would our records demonstrate how each identified conflict was assessed and managed.
The ANAO findings provide an opportunity for Commonwealth entities to review whether their probity arrangements extend beyond obtaining declarations to documenting assessments, assigning responsibility for management measures and monitoring their effectiveness.
A declaration is not a decision
Disclosure of a conflict of interest allows an entity to identify circumstances that might affect an official’s impartiality. What the entity then does with that information is what matters.
Consider an evaluation panel member who discloses a longstanding personal relationship with a senior employee of a tenderer. Although the panel member might consider themselves capable of assessing all submissions impartially, their continued participation might create a reasonable perception that the tenderer could receive preferential treatment. Simply recording the relationship would not necessarily address this concern.
The Commonwealth entity would need to assess the significance of the relationship, consider the panel member’s responsibilities and determine whether additional management measures are appropriate. Depending on those circumstances, those measures might include restricting access to particular information, excluding the individual from certain evaluation activities, introducing independent oversight or removing the individual from the evaluation panel. Department of Finance guidance provides that entities should, in the first instance, seek to eliminate actual, potential and perceived conflicts of interest and, where this is not possible, implement effective management strategies.Department of Finance (n 1), quoted in Australian National Audit Office (n 15) [3.38].
The important distinction is that disclosure identifies the risk, while management determines how that risk will be addressed. Entities should document the assessment undertaken, the management measures adopted and the reasons those measures were considered appropriate.
The department that was the subject of the ANAO audit has advised it now ensures that all conflict-of-interest declarations are assessed and panel members that have a personal or professional relationship with a candidate is removed from assessing that candidate.
Practical Steps for Commonwealth Entities
Effective probity management requires Commonwealth entities to establish processes that support early identification, appropriate assessment and ongoing oversight.
Identifying conflicts throughout the procurement lifecycle. Conflicts may arise at different stages of procurement and should be considered as circumstances change.
- Procurement planning. Officials and advisers who develop specifications, procurement strategies or evaluation criteria can predetermine the final outcome before any supplier is approached. Entities should obtain conflict declarations from these individuals before they commence relevant activities.
- Approach to market. Once potential suppliers or tender respondents are identified, officials should review their declarations to determine whether any new conflicts have arisen. Supplier communications should also be managed consistently with the procurement’s probity arrangements to reduce the risk of inappropriate information sharing or preferential treatment. Request documentation should also require tenderers to declare their own conflicts of interest, and require contracts to incorporate the Commonwealth Supplier Code of Conduct~~Department of Finance, Commonwealth Supplier Code of Conduct (1 July 2024).~~, which relevant entities must include in all Commonwealth forms of contract.
- Tender evaluation. Evaluation panel members, advisers and other individuals involved in evaluation activities should disclose relevant interests before assessing tender submissions. Where conflicts are identified, entities should assess and document appropriate management measures before the affected individual participates in relevant evaluation activities.
- Negotiation and contract award. Officials involved in negotiations and delegates responsible for procurement decisions must also recognise and deal with relevant conflicts. Conflict management arrangements should extend to those who influence or approve procurement outcomes, not only evaluation panel members.
- Contract management. Conflicts can emerge after contract award through ongoing supplier relationships, offers of hospitality or employment, or changes in an official’s responsibilities. Consider a contract manager who, six months before an extension decision, is approached by the incumbent supplier about employment in a senior role with the supplier. Unless that approach is disclosed and the manager steps back from the extension decision, the entity may be unable to show that the extension was assessed on its merits. Entities should ensure that contract managers understand their continuing disclosure obligations, particularly when considering contract variations, extensions or renewals.
Assessing and managing identified conflicts
Once a conflict has been disclosed, Commonwealth entities should assess its nature, significance and potential impact on the procurement process.
Relevant considerations include the nature of the interest, the official’s responsibilities, their access to confidential information and their ability to influence procurement outcomes. Depending on the circumstances, management measures might include:
- recording the interest and documenting why no further action is required;
- introducing independent oversight or restricting access to specified information; or
- excluding the individual from the procurement process or from relevant decisions.
Documenting conflict assessments and management measures
Effective record-keeping is essential to demonstrating that conflicts have received appropriate consideration. Contemporaneous records assist entities in demonstrating compliance with their procurement obligations and responding to internal reviews, audits or external scrutiny. As we have already noted however, record-keeping alone is not sufficient to manage conflicts of interest.
Ongoing monitoring and review
Conflict management should not be treated as an administrative exercise completed at the beginning of a procurement. Declarations and management arrangements should be revisited when circumstances change, including where new suppliers become involved, evaluation panel membership changes or officials develop new personal or professional interests. Departments should consider whether spot audits of conflict processes should be undertaken.
Protecting declaration and procurement information
Conflict declarations, management plans and evaluation records will often contain personal information. Commonwealth entities must take reasonable steps, including technical and organisational measures, to protect that information from misuse, interference, loss and unauthorised access, modification or disclosure.Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) sch 1 APP 11.1, 11.3. APP 11.3 was inserted by Privacy and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2024 (Cth) Schedule 1 Part 5 Item 34. Eligible data breach involving personal information must be notified under the Notifiable Data Breaches scheme in Part IIIC of the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth).Ibid pt IIIC. Where probity advisers or other contractors handle that information, entities must take contractual measures to ensure they do not breach the APPs.Ibid s 95B. Entities should also manage procurement security and cyber security risk in accordance with the Protective Security Policy Framework,Department of Home Affairs, Protective Security Policy Framework (Release 2026, 1 July 2026); see also Department of Finance, Commonwealth Procurement Rules (17 November 2025) [8.3].and protect tender submissions as confidential.Department of Finance, Commonwealth Procurement Rules (17 November 2025) [7.23]
Questions to ask before the auditor does
Effective probity processes throughout a procurement require more than obtaining declarations and maintaining conflict registers.
Commonwealth entities should consider whether their existing arrangements:
- require relevant officials and advisers to disclose interests at appropriate stages of the procurement;
- provide clear processes for assessing conflicts and adopting proportionate management measures;
- maintain records demonstrating how identified conflicts were assessed, managed and reviewed;
- allocate responsibility for monitoring conflicts throughout procurement and contract management; and
- address supplier conflicts through appropriate procurement documentation and contractual arrangements.
The ANAO’s recent findings reinforce the importance of these measures and demonstrate the risks of relying on declarations without documenting how identified conflicts have been addressed. Conflicts of interest are a recognised feature of Commonwealth procurement, but inadequately managed conflicts can undermine supplier confidence, compromise procurement integrity and expose Commonwealth entities to legal and reputational risk.
The identification and disclosure of actual, potential or perceived conflicts of interest by Commonwealth officials is only the starting point. The question every entity should be able to answer, for every procurement, is the one an auditor will ask: do the records show how each identified conflict was assessed and managed?
Norton Rose Fulbright has extensive experience providing probity services to Commonwealth entities and advising on the identification, management and mitigation of conflict of interest risks across the procurement lifecycle. If your entity would like assistance reviewing its probity arrangements or managing conflicts in a current or upcoming procurement, please contact one of the authors.