A subcontractor may have as much to lose from a flawed procurement as the head contractor who submitted the tender, yet the Government Procurement (Judicial Review) Act 2018 (GPJR Act) was not designed with the subcontractor in mind. That asymmetry creates a legal grey area: one that is rarely litigated, poorly understood, and increasingly relevant as subcontractor participation in Commonwealth procurements deepens.

This article maps the terrain and provides a general overview of whether, and in what circumstances, a subcontractor may bring a procurement dispute under the GPJR Act.This article addresses Commonwealth procurements subject to Division 2 of the Commonwealth Procurement Rules and the GPJR Act. It does not address State or Territory procurement regimes. It is intended as a general reference and is not tailored to any specific procurement.

Can a subcontract bring a procurement dispute under the GPJR?

Not automatically. A subcontractor is only a ‘supplier’ for the GPJR Act if it “supplies, or could supply, goods or services”Government Procurement (Judicial Review) Act 2018 (Cth) s 4 (definition of ‘supplier’ para (a)–(b)) to the Commonwealth in the relevant covered procurement. Since a downstream subcontractor supplies to the head contractor, not the Commonwealth, it will generally fall outside this definition. The Act’s standing, complaint, and remedy provisions all converge on the same class of person: one who directly participated, or could have directly participated, in the covered procurement.

This conclusion is reinforced by the compensation remedy under s 16, which ties compensation to the expenditure incurred in preparing a tender for the procurement. A downstream subcontractor has not prepared such a tender, at most it has prepared a quote or proposal for the head contractor and it is therefore presumed not to have standing.

Further, even where the ‘supplier’ threshold is met, standing also requires that the subcontractor’s interests are affected by an alleged contravention of the relevant Commonwealth Procurement Rules (CPR).Ibid s 18(1) An indirect, contingent interest via a head contract is unlikely to suffice — nor will a mere commercial expectation of a downstream subcontract. By analogy with the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) standing test and general administrative law principles, the supplier’s legal, economic or practical interests must be directly and materially affected by the alleged CPR contravention.See for example, Australian Conservation Foundation Inc v The Commonwealth (1980) 146 CLR 493, 547 (Stephen J)and Right to Life Association (NSW) Inc v Secretary, Department of Human Services and Health (1995) 56 FCR 50, 65

When may a subcontractor have standing?

Despite the difficulties outlined above, a subcontractor may have standing to bring a claim if it can show it was a tenderer, consortium member, a potential direct supplier whose interests were directly affected by a CPR breach, or a party that was practically excluded from supplying the Commonwealth directly by an allegedly non-compliant specification.

Before standing can be assessed, the subcontractor must also satisfy the relevant jurisdictional threshold questions: the procurement must be a covered procurement under Division 2 of the CPRs and must not fall within an exempt class.

Whilst the Act is silent on timeframes, Finance guidance sets out an expectation that complaints are to be made promptly upon the supplier becoming aware of the alleged breach.

Department’s should be alert to one immediate and significant consequence that arises regardless of the merits of a complaint. Under s 20 of the GPJR Act, lodging a complaint automatically suspends the procurement until the complaint is resolved, withdrawn, or a Public Interest Certificate (PIC) is issued.

This means a complaint with low prospects of success can still halt a live procurement and disrupt contract timelines. Where a PIC is issued, the suspension lifts, though the supplier retains the right to seek other relief.

If standing is established, once a complaint is lodged under s 18, the accountable authority is obliged to investigate and prepare a written report. The available judicial remedies are:

  1. injunctions for restraint or performance under s 9; and
  2. compensation under s 16, which is deliberately limited to reasonable expenditure incurred in preparing a tender and in making or resolving the complaint, reflecting a policy choice to leave tenderers without a remedy for loss of the contract itself.

There is no compensation for lost profits, lost opportunity, or expectation damages. Relevantly, s 16 of the GPJR Act does not specify the supplier’s timeframes for making an application for compensation.

Practical takeaway

A subcontractor's prospects of establishing standing under the GPJR Act are slim. Where a department receives a complaint from a subcontractor, the preferred approach is to encourage the head contractor (as the party who tendered) to pursue any complaint, given its clearer standing.

Nonetheless, each complaint should be assessed on its individual merits in accordance with the department's ordinary standards and practices.

Departments should also be aware that where a complaint does not succeed under the GPJR Act, it may remain open to the subcontractor to pursue other means of compensation, notably through Commonwealth discretionary payment schemes.

Stay connected with our Commonwealth Government team

Contact us to receive further insights from our team and information on upcoming CLE events.

Contact