This article was co-authored with Jess Taylor and Jack Churchward.

On 17 February 2026, in a judgment by Justice Markovic, the Federal Court dismissed claims brought by the Australian Centre for Corporate Responsibility (ACCR) against Santos Ltd (Santos) in relation to statements Santos had made about its environmental impact and climate transition.

In this legal update, we consider ACCR’s claims and the insights provided by Justice Markovic’s judgment in relation to how organisations should navigate increasingly complex expectations around their climate-related disclosures and sustainability claims.1

The facts

In 2021, ACCR commenced proceedings against Santos in the Federal Court alleging misleading and deceptive conduct in breach of section 1041H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) and sections 18 and 33 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).

ACCR’s claim concerned representations made by Santos in its 2020 Annual Report, 2021 Climate Change Report and 2020 Investor Day presentation, including that:

  • Santos produced “clean energy”, referring to natural gas as a “clean energy” source.
  • Santos had a “credible and clear plan” to achieve a 26–30 per cent reduction in scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2030 (against its 2019-2020 baseline) and net zero scope 1 and 2 GHG emissions by 2040.
  • Santos could, in future, deliver a “zero emissions” or “clean” form of hydrogen.

ACCR argued that Santos’s representations were misleading because:

  • Its net‑zero strategy relied heavily on carbon capture and storage (CCS) and blue hydrogen – technologies that ACCR argued were unproven and unlikely to be technically or commercially viable for reducing/capturing future scope 1 and 2 GHG emissions.
  • Santos’s emissions targets failed to account for additional emissions from its CCS and blue hydrogen projects and its planned growth in hydrocarbon production beyond 2025.
  • Santos’s transition plan relied on undisclosed and unreasonable assumptions.
  • Santos mischaracterised natural gas and “blue hydrogen” (which is produced by burning natural gas) as “clean” or “zero‑emissions”, including obscuring the fact that the extraction and use of natural gas has a material adverse effect on the environment.

ACCR asked the Court to: (i) make declarations that Santos had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct; (ii) grant an injunction prohibiting Santos from engaging in the same misleading and deceptive conduct in the future; and (iii) grant an injunction requiring Santos to issue a corrective statement.

The matter proceeded to a 13-day trial in late 2024. Following receipt of the judgement, the ACCR have lodged an appeal.

Why the Federal Court found in favour of Santos

Context and the target audience

Whether conduct is misleading turns on its likely effect on the relevant target audience. At trial, Justice Markovic found that the target audience of Santos’s claims consisted of a large and diverse group of institutional and individual investors with varying levels of expertise, sophistication and knowledge. The audience was assumed to have some understanding of climate change and the impact of fossil fuels. The audience was not assumed to have “scientific training” in the matter.

The Court found this audience would read the allegedly misleading statements alongside Santos’s other representations about its long-term goals and strategy, such as that its emissions reductions would be dependent on the use of CCS and that Santos would achieve its emissions reduction targets and ultimately “net zero” at least partly by surrendering offsets.

Viewed in that context, the Court concluded that investors would interpret: (i) terms such as “clean fuel” or “clean energy” as comparative and forward looking; and (ii) “zero emissions” (in the context of blue hydrogen) as describing net zero outcomes (as achieved through CCS and offsets).

This reasoning underscored that context will be central in determining whether a statement will be misleading for the purposes of the ACL and Corporations Act.

Emissions targets must have “reasonable grounds”

The Court rejected each of ACCR’s challenges to Santos’s emissions targets. It held that Santos describing those targets as “clear, credible and tangible” did not suggest that they were certain. It found that a reasonable investor would recognise these as long term, aspirational aims to be achieved over a 20-year period, as acknowledged in Santos’s 2021 Climate Report.

The Court then addressed ACCR’s claim that Santos lacked “reasonable grounds” for key elements of its Net Zero Roadmap, particularly its projected emissions reductions from “Hydrogen with CCS” and “CCS Expansion.” This claim is grounded in the ACL and Corporations Act, which require statements as to future matters to be based on “reasonable grounds”.

The Court concluded that Santos had a rational basis for each component and that the figures were not merely nominal or speculative, as claimed by ACCR. In doing so, it recognised that plans which are to be achieved over several years will involve an inherent degree of uncertainty.

Finally, the Court rejected ACCR’s argument that Santos misled investors by using the term “reduction” when it relied heavily on purchasing offsets. The Court considered that Santos had openly disclosed its reliance on offsets and that a reasonable investor would understand offsets are commonly used to achieve emissions reduction targets, in addition to emissions mitigation.

Terminology assessed against industry use

The Court rejected ACCR’s challenge to Santos’s description of blue hydrogen as “clean” or “zero emissions,” emphasising that neither term had a universally accepted meaning in the Australian energy industry at the time that the representations were made.

Expert evidence showed that government and industry publications routinely used the same language to describe hydrogen without implying that it produced no emissions. The Court accepted that, in their contemporaneous usage, statements about “clean” or “zero emissions” hydrogen had referred to hydrogen produced with the support of CCS or offsetting strategies, as part of a broader transition plan.

The decision underscores the evolving nature of climate-related terminology. Companies must ensure their disclosures remain consistent with credible industry and government language as standards and expectations continue to shift.

Litigation risk after ACCR v Santos

This case has been closely followed, especially by others looking to initiate their own greenwashing claims, however it is unclear if this decision will deter other climate litigants.

The Court’s reasoning turned closely on the specific disclosures Santos made, the state of industry terminology at the time, and the evidence it could produce to demonstrate reasonable grounds.

Moreover, the groundswell of climate litigation has continued to grow since ACCR filed its claim in 2021. The GRI, which tracks climate litigation trends, provided in its most recent report that “climate-washing cases remain the most widely used strategy in corporate litigation” and “High success rates suggest [this strategy will] remain effective … for holding companies accountable”.2

Companies, especially those in target areas like the energy or financial sectors, should remain vigilant, particularly as mandatory climate-related financial reporting evolves. For further assistance on mitigating the risk of potential climate-related claims, please contact a member of our litigation or climate change teams.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Australasian Centre for Corporate Responsibility v Santos Limited [2026] FCA 96 (17 February 2026). Accessible here.

  2. 2

    GRI, “Global trends in climate change litigation: 2025 snapshot” (July 2025). Accessible here.

Contact