Overview
Ten years after their introduction, the UK government has conducted a new consultation on the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016, as well as the Insolvency (Scotland) (Company Voluntary Arrangements and Administration) Rules 2018 (the Rules). Rather than present a preferred package of reforms, the UK government has sought views on whether the Rules remain fit for purpose, whether there is scope to reduce administrative burdens, and how the procedural framework governing insolvency proceedings should respond to technological change. This blog post highlights some of the key themes of the consultation and the legislative reforms that may follow.
Proportionality
One key theme underpinning the consultation is proportionality. For example, whether the existing Rules impose disproportionate burdens on businesses with fewer than 500 employees, or whether routine processes could be simplified without degrading creditor and stakeholder protections.
The government is clear that it is focused on meaningful reforms and avoiding unintended consequences, such that it also invited evidence of potential disadvantages of reform.
Creditor participation
A key focus is on how information is delivered and utilised in insolvency proceedings. For example, questioning whether office-holder communications with creditors are proportionate, or whether volume, repetition and complexity impede creditor engagement. In relation to creditor committees, the government is clear from a policy perspective that, while uncommon, creditors' committees and liquidation committees are here to stay. However, given their low take-up, it questions whether tweaks could be made to avoid inefficiencies.
Appointment and office-holder remuneration
The Insolvency (England and Wales) (Amendment) Rules 2026, effective from June 22, 2026, made recent amendments to the Rules. In large part these were a tidying-up exercise aimed at removing outdated provisions. They introduced amendments to out-of-court administration appointments, such as removing filings by fax when made by secured creditors holding qualifying floating charges. The new consultation goes further, potentially removing the requirement for hard copies of emails to be retained and delivered to court in the light of mandatory E-filing in the Business and Property Division of the High Court.
It also canvasses broader perspectives on the process for appointing administrators using the out-of-court filing method, which is available to directors, the company, and secured creditors holding qualifying floating charges. The introduction of E-filing in the courts created uncertainties that are presently addressed by the Temporary Insolvency Practice Direction (MIPD, 2021). In short, this provides that where a notice appointing an administrator by the company or its directors is filed electronically out of court opening hours, the filing - and therefore the appointment - is treated as taking effect at 10am on the next day when the court is open for business. The consultation therefore creates an opportunity for legal clarification and certainty regarding when an appointment takes effect.
Future proofing the rules
An important theme of the consultation is technological resilience. The consultation enquires how the Rules should address issues such as cloud-based records, machine reading, automation, and access to information. On the topic of artificial intelligence (AI), the government is interested in its current usage in insolvency proceedings, potential barriers to AI use under the Rules, and the potential for AI to reduce costs and increase efficiencies in insolvency proceedings.
In relation to digital assets, the government's preliminary view is that the existing legal framework is sufficiently flexible, while noting that the major challenges in this area – such as private-key access, third-party co-operation, decentralisation and cross-border enforcement – cannot be solved by amendments to the Rules alone. Nevertheless, the consultation considers whether the Rules can be improved, for example whether clarification is required should cryptocurrencies one day be recognised as legal currency, rather than assets.
Outlook
In the context of Rules reform, much of the lower hanging fruit was picked and addressed by the Insolvency (England and Wales) (Amendment) Rules 2026, effective from June 22, 2026. The new consultation therefore presents an opportunity for further, potentially broader ranging reforms. The government's response to the consultation will be published by April 6, 2027 and will be instructive as to both the scope and content of future reforms.
*This article was first published in the October issue of Butterworths Journal of International Banking and Financial Law.